20 ms·
I am very skeptical. Air conditioning has enabled large amounts of people to move from cold climates to warm climates (places like Dallas and Hong Kong basical
by legitster 8y ago
I am very skeptical.
Air conditioning has enabled large amounts of people to move from cold climates to warm climates (places like Dallas and Hong Kong basically wouldn't exist like they do without it). And there is a lot more energy spent heating in the north than there is cooling in the south. So on average, I would assume there is a net benefit if you consider the tradeoffs.
I think there is a stigma people have that heating is essential for life, but A/C is optional. But we should really compare them against each other.
- ex-pralite-monk 8y agoI grew up in central Florida in the 1960s. Our house and many of our school rooms didn't have air conditioning until the mid 1970s. It's doable: brick school rooms are a decent insulator. Jalousie windows in every house.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 8y agoplus there is still a lot of heating done with oil and even coal in some places. the temperature difference alone should point to heating being more expensive. (going from freezing to acceptable is a lot more energy than from hot to the same temperature). throw in the added benefit of AC is humidity control and AC is just a win win tech.
- Retric 8y agoHumility makes this less true than you would think. AC’s drip water because they condescend it from the air which takes lots of energy.
- r_smart 8y agoI can't tell if this is a weird attempt at a pun, a funny typo, or some kind of koan.
- BenFrantzDale 8y agoIt’s not the heat it’s the humility.
- SECProto 8y agoThere's also a lot of heating done with wood stoves, burning renewable locally sourced wood, too. Depends a lot on local context. Also, there's a lot less efficiency loss burning oil directly for heat, compared to burning oil for steam for 40% electricity which then gets turned into AC with some further efficiency loss. I expect the AC cooling might still come out on top, but not be nearly as much as implied.
- ryanmarsh 8y ago> places like Dallas ...and Houston which is further south and has a subtropical climate. It boomed in population after A/C became a standard thing. > I think there is a stigma people have that heating is essential for life, but A/C is optional. Yes, and A/C is a public health issue. In subtropical climates it keeps people indoors and away from disease carrying insects such as mosquitos.
- Sharlin 8y agoBut is there really a need for people to live in places like Houston? It's not like the US lacks places with a temperate climate.
- kalleboo 8y agoCan you have it both ways? You could also say "is there really a need for people to live in places like Africa? India? Indonesia?"
- angersock 8y agoYou could even extend that argument to include "is there a need for people to live in a place where they can't grow enough food to sustain their population". I wouldn't pull too hard on that thread here, though.
- Sharlin 8y agoBut the GP’s argument was that AC is good because it made populating places like Texas possible. But was it worth it to populate those places in retrospect if it depended on a technology with known negative externalities? Similarly, the personal automobile made urban sprawl possible. But is sprawl and ensuing car-dependency a good thing all things considered? Many would say no.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- genericone 8y agoA/C was considered absolutely critical in making Singapore's economy flourish, at least according to Singapore's ex prime minister: http://www.digitalnpq.org/archive/2009_fall_2010_winter/16_yew.html http://www.digitalnpq.org/archive/2009_fall_2010_winter/16_y... Lee | Air conditioning. Air conditioning was a most important invention for us, perhaps one of the signal inventions of history. It changed the nature of civilization by making development possible in the tropics. Without air conditioning you can work only in the cool early-morning hours or at dusk. The first thing I did upon becoming prime minister was to install air conditioners in buildings where the civil service worked. This was key to public efficiency.
- gramanat 8y agoWell, Most of the govt offices in India do not have A/C even today. The have fans all over. I guess, the A/C became essential partly because of how we construct buildings - which trap all the heat.
- kajecounterhack 8y agoFWIW this was quoted in the article itself.
- tim333 8y agoAlso the cover photo I think is taken in Singapore on the service road behind Boat Quay about here https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@1.2868298,103.8492369,3a,75y,89.1t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s3v8D2Pk6bUii5qMYDimJyQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@1.2868298,103.8492369,3a,75y,... (though I couldn't get it exactly right on streetview)
- Spooky23 8y agoSomeone should tell that to US government. The first internship that i had in a (state) government office would do early dismissal when the inside temp was over 90 degrees for 2 hours. It was a miserable experience.
- 8y ago
- sampo 8y agoAlso, over similar temperature differences, AC is more energy efficient than heating. With AC you only move the heat, so spending 1 unit of energy you can move 2 or 3 units of heat. More, if the system is highly optimized. With heating, you need to spend 1 unit of energy to create 1 unit of heat. (Unless you heat with a heat pump. But even then, pumping heat for heating operates on less favourable temperature differences than pumping heat for AC.)
- miketery 8y agoWhat? Can we start with an example such as: 1) Take a room starting at 20C, how much energy to get the room to 25C? 2) Conversely take a room at 25C, how much energy to get the room to 20C? Intuitively heating should be cheaper, since loses are heat. Whereas with cooling you'll have inefficiency (e.g. in the pump) in the form of heat, therefore more energy to remove that additional heat.
- adrianN 8y agoHeat pumps can move more than one unit of energy from A to B for every unit of energy they consume.
- timerol 8y agoThe way modern heat pumps work, I can't answer your question yet. What's the outside temperature? Let's say that taking your room from 15C to 20C takes 1.0 energy unit. If it's 15C outside, then I can use a heat pump to gain a bunch of efficiency, say only using 0.2 units of electricity to heat up the inside by one unit. If it's 25C outside, I can do the same in reverse, but I do have to also cool the A/C. We'll say taking the room from 25C to 20C when it's 25C outside takes 0.25 units. The problem happens when there is a big difference in outside temperature. All of the gains of heat pumps disappear. So cooling from 25C inside to 20C inside when it's 30C outside might take 0.5 units of energy, which is a pretty common case. Heaters generally have to deal with much bigger swings, though. It's not uncommon to heat from 15C inside to 20C inside while the outside is at -10C, which takes (asymptotically approaching) 1.0 energy unit. So the inefficiency of the A/C producing heat does matter, but not as much as the difference between the desired temperature and the outside temperature. The rate of heat transfer of the house also depends on the difference in temperature. Keeping a house 10C cooler than ambient takes less energy than keeping a house 20C hotter than ambient. Considering that temperatures on Earth vary from about -90C to 50C, and humans like to keep indoor temps around 20C, cooling is generally more efficient than heating.
- danjoc 8y agoThe article points out the issue with AC isn't energy/CO2, it's refrigerants. >Second, air-conditioners use so-called “F gases” (such as hydrofluorocarbons, or HFCs) as refrigerants. When—as is common—the machines leak in use or on disposal, these gases escape, doing vast damage. HFCs trap between 1,000 and 9,000 times as much heat as the same amount of CO2, meaning they are much more potent causes of global warming. On this basis, Paul Hawken of Project Drawdown, a think-tank, calculates that improving air-conditioners could do more than anything else to reduce greenhouse gases.
- mindslight 8y agoAnd yet "spray duster cans" are refrigerants sold to be purposely vented. A while ago (back when Google worked) I stumbled upon a refrigerant hacking page that detailed DIY retrofitting of refrigeration equipment to use propane as the refrigerant instead. Obviously the flammability is a problem, but as standard refrigerants seem to be pressing towards the flammable-with-harmful-combustion-products direction, I wonder why the industry isn't reconsidering. It seems nicer to have a plain fireball rather than one which creates hydrofluoric acid.
- philipkglass 8y agoRefrigerating and air conditioning equipment can use plain hydrocarbon refrigerants such as propane and isobutane. US approval is fairly recent -- less than 10 years ago -- as you can see in this EPA table: https://www.epa.gov/snap/substitutes-residential-and-light-commercial-air-conditioning-and-heat-pumps https://www.epa.gov/snap/substitutes-residential-and-light-c... I believe that products using these low-GWP, zero-ODP refrigerants are marketed using the term "Greenfreeze." https://cleantechnica.com/2008/09/29/first-greenfreeze-climate-safe-freezer-launches-in-the-united-states/ https://cleantechnica.com/2008/09/29/first-greenfreeze-clima...
- jabl 8y agoHere in Europe (and I believe in many other parts of the world as well) propane and butane have been the standard refrigerant in domestic appliances for a couple of decades. I think the industry went straight to these when CFC's were banned. Considering that your average refrigerator contains a quite modest amount of refrigerant, compared to all the other flammable stuff in your average apartment, it's not really any significant fire risk.
- another-cuppa 8y ago> And there is a lot more energy spent heating in the north than there is cooling in the south. Source for this?
- 21 8y agoMakes sense, you typically need to raise temperature more in the winter than you need to lower it in the summer. And you need heating non-stop in winter, while in the summer half of the day is enough many times. Also, most people have heating, but only some AC.
- pc86 8y agoThis supposition and guessing doesn't really qualify as a source.
- ody4242 8y agoHere is a source for US energy consumption percentages, 1993 vs. 2009: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=10271 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=10271
- flattone 8y agoSure ... But I have always found it much less paintful to wear a jacket to stay warm than having only machine solutions for cooling off.
- logfromblammo 8y agoDip shirt in liquid with boiling point lower than water. Re-wet as necessary. Or weave sealed cells of a phase-change material with high thermal mass that melts at around 33 degC into your fabric, and freeze the garment before wearing it. This makes possible a thick, heavy jacket that you can wear to keep cool.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- powercf 8y agoThe world doesn't need any more people. Fewer would be an improvement. My problem with AC is how ubiguitous it is, and how people use it without thought of the environmental cost. It's ridiculous in many cases: people who sleep with their windows open and AC on (this exists), AC bus travel, where one needs a jacket, jeans and warm socks as the bus will be cold after a few hours. Air conditioning shows how far some people have become distanced from nature, and the environment in which they live. People who live in warm climates should expect to feel warm, maybe (at times) uncomfortably so. But good building design, suitable clothing, an open window, and a fan when temperatures get unbearable can go a long way. In the summer, I sleep (comfortably) with a window open, listing to the sound of my neighbours' AC units kicking in. It's depressing. That's not to say that AC doesn't have valid uses, but that in many cases a more balanced, environmentally-friendly approach can be taken.
- mc32 8y agoSome things which could be avoided: open doors in cooled buildings to entice people to go in (for example 7/11 or general retail in tropical or hot places). Refrigerated aisles in supermarkets which don’t have doors to keep cool air mingling with warmer air in the aisle., etc. Offices which keep so cool, people wesr jackets in the office when not winter. Those are wasteful examples.
- barkingcat 8y agoMany store fronts have large sliding glass walls that open up the entire structure to open air - and they blast AC at 16 degrees inside, while the entire store is open to 30+ degree air outside. The idea is so that the AC would leak out the doors and entice people to want to walk into the store. But that means that all the AC is wasted. This kind of irresponsible use of AC is everywhere in hot climates in large shoppping streets, pretty much everywhere - North America, Asia (in asia it's insane how much AC is wasted), and I don't see it as much in Europe but probably some stores do it. That's just a waste and is really sad.
- abraham_lincoln 8y agoYou say it is a waste, but to the store, it is an advertising expense. Would you rather they buy Facebook ads and use hydroelectric (assuming ad server's power source)?
- ergothus 8y agoWhy does the conclusion have to be "A/C Good" or "A/C Bad"? In some cases A/C literally makes normal functioning possible, and is thus a boon to society and opens the argument to what level of environmental costs are worth it. In other cases, A/C allows someone to not have to change to lighter clothes to be comfortable, or they have poor insulation and thus have to use A/C far more than they otherwise would. In these cases there is much less argument that A/C is worth the environmental impacts. Exploring the difference is valuable - instead of arguing "Good/Bad", we can start arguing "How can we make things better?". Reducing unneeded A/C is just a good idea, and admitting that A/C has environmental impacts does not mean we have to instantly ban it. We shouldn't compare A/C against heating because there's no value in knowing if one is "better" - we need both. We should instead act to reduce unneeded A/C use _and_ unneeded heating use (and to keep, if improve, needed uses).
- Nition 8y agoIn Hong Kong in particular I noticed that every commercial building seems to have the AC perpetually on 18°C (65°F) even when it's 30°+ outside. I don't get it because it just makes you have to take a jacket with you. Why not put the AC on 23°C (73°F) in summer?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 8y agoBuilding managers love that, but people do not because buildings don’t heat evenly and solar gains will make many people uncomfortable at 72-73.
- sjg007 8y agoThis is a well known issue and it developed historically because of business wear (suits etc..)..
- thaumasiotes 8y agoThe reverse issue is also common -- you need to go from your house (comfortable) through the outdoors (freezing cold) into the mall. The mall is kept at a toasty temperature, which means you arrive wearing heavy cold-weather clothing and immediately overheat. I don't see how this could have developed from business wear.
- dghughes 8y agoIn my region of south eastern Canada the summers seem to be hotter and seem to be lasting longer. Today for example 27C and 80% humidity. Normally 15C to 20C and low humidity would be normal this time of year. With the cost of fuel oil (common here) many people have installed supplemental heating in the form of heat pumps. The side benefit is they also have cooling capabilities. My point, the local power company said in a news release power use during the summer took a big jump. But even with all the A/C units in use power use is still 20% lower than in winter, heating uses much more energy (and many people also supplement with wood).
- avip 8y agoThat's because your winter is more extreme. In any modestly hot country, electricity consumption peaks in summer.
- jrace 8y agoAlso not every house in Canada has AC....but ALL have heating.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ant6n 8y agoThe delta for AC cooling seems to be <10C, the delta for heating could be up to 50C. So it seems pretty sad that the energy consumption is only 20% lower.
- C4stor 8y agoExcept your house is heated by literally anything that's doing anything inside it (like your own body, cooking, using a computer, taking a shower, ...), meaning it never reaches the outside temperature except if it's inhabited for a long period of time. Meaning cooling have to compensate for every bit of activity, whereas heating doesn't.
- 8y ago
- ryandrake 8y ago> I think there is a stigma people have that heating is essential for life, but A/C is optional. I don’t know if it’s a stigma but it’s arguably a myth. Having lived both in areas where 40C is normal day after day in the summer and other areas where 0C (or below) is normal day after day in the winter, I can tell you which of heating and cooling is optional. In the extreme heat, as long as you drink enough water, you’re usually fine without air conditioning (but very uncomfortable). In extreme cold, blankets only go so far and you risk dying if the heat goes off. In my view one is definitely a luxury and the other is not. Actually curious: is there anywhere on earth that the heat (by itself, assuming proper hydration) will kill you like the places on earth where the cold will kill you?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yosito 8y agoTemperatures over 105°F/40°C can be deadly for some people. Hydration is just one of several factors that affect how much heat the human body can handle. As far as I know, a reasonably healthy person with hydration and shelter wouldn't die from the heat alone anywhere on earth. But people often can and do die during heatwaves in many parts of the world.
- isostatic 8y agoIn 2003 a heat wave was blamed for 70,000 deaths in Europe (mainly France) On the other hand wi yet 2015 was blamed on 40,000 deaths in the UK alone
- etiennemarcel 8y ago2003 was a wake up call. The heat wave this year was the second hottest since 2003 and there have been a lot fewer deaths (at least in France). People are better informed and the health professionals are better prepared.
- canhascodez 8y agoIn the near future, climate change will make wet-bulb temperatures higher than 35 C / 95 F possible. At that point, you are no longer able to sweat to cool your body. This can kill you in fairly short order.
- forapurpose 8y ago> there is a stigma people have that heating is essential for life, but A/C is optional. It's not a stigma, but a reality. Humans survive in a certain temperature range. On large parts of the earth for large parts of the year, the outside temperature is below the safe range. On only a few small parts of the earth - often where there are no other resources - is the temperature above the safe range. Humanity survived 200,000 years without A/C; I'm guessing heat was a necessity pretty early on, at least to inhabit most of the planet. And anyway the question is irrelevant. We need to reduce energy consumption; is this some sort of competition between the heating and a/c industries?
- GordonS 8y agoIt's not just about surviving though. Sure, AC is not absolutely required for life in many cases, but it allows one to be comfortable and productive, such that life without it wouldn't be very pleasant or practical.
- gerdesj 8y agoplaces like Dallas and Hong Kong basically wouldn't exist like they do without it I have visited both Texas and HK at peak heat as a tourist - I'm from the UK. Yes it does get a bit warm in both Dallas and say Kowloon but you learn to adjust. You slow down and bimble. You notice shade and instinctively go through it. You keep yourself hydrated and lots of other tiny strategies. This is how people have done it for centuries. I did live in the Middle East for a few years, so that gave me a few pointers. A/C is nice but not necessary (for a real value of necessary)
- Hextinium 8y agoAs someone whos AC at work died during the summer in Dallas my productivity after the AC went out was a quarter to a fifth of my output before. The cost to my employer for that reduction is well worth the cost of AC.
- gerdesj 8y agoSod your employer, we are talking about the cost to the commons (planet)
- rconti 8y agoI had bad luck arguing this a couple of weeks ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17762156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17762156
- dionidium 8y agoI'm from the Midwest and I now live in New York. My heating costs are significantly less than my A/C costs. My energy bills increase dramatically in the summer. Is my usage not typical? Or are there "hidden" costs I'm not considering? Second: isn't the shift you describe also a significant contributor to sprawl, which also increases energy waste?
- twothamendment 8y agoI think the difference is A/C is more of a modern comfort that allows us to live in hot places. People could live in cold places without any modern technology or utility service. Fire and a pile of wood was all it took. Both are essential in either extreme, but we've had one solved for much longer.
- waterhouse 8y agoI personally consider air conditioning one of the pillars of civilization.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zaarn 8y agoI consider this stigma the other way around, though I live in a much colder country; an A/C is essential because cooling yourself off is hard. On the other hand, you can forgoe heating by buying another thick blanket, keeping warm is relatively simple compared to keeping cool, notably because the human body naturally produces heat. All you need to do to keep warm is to prevent it from going away.