3 ms·
This is a weird argument to have. It raises many questions. Like, it's one thing to suggest maybe libel laws should apply to big tech companies. But do we reall
by jchw 8y ago
This is a weird argument to have. It raises many questions. Like, it's one thing to suggest maybe libel laws should apply to big tech companies. But do we really want to force them to be "politically neutral?" Such a thing literally does not exist, for one thing; but who gets to define it? For example, can the president order that a given news source appear higher in the rankings? Who decides what deserves to be ranked higher?
Further, what happens if Google were to prove that it's search algorithm were completely politically neutral (which is obviously non-sense because that statement doesn't mean anything.) What do we do then?
Should we also look at New York Times? What if they are posting too many liberal viewpoints?
- adventured 8y agoWhy would we look at the NY Times? They don't have a monopoly on national news. They have a small minority position overall and always have. Google effectively has three monopolies (or near monopolies): search, YouTube, Android. I include YouTube because in their user-video / amateur-video space they have an overwhelming position, there's nothing even remotely close (Facebook is still a poor competitor, and will probably never capture the higher quality amateur content).
- jchw 8y agoNow we're talking about an entirely different problem altogether. If you want that problem fixed, we need better legislation for tech companies, not worse. Adding more regulatory hurdles and legal obligations will just get you even stronger incumbents.
- Youden 8y ago> But do we really want to force them to be "politically neutral?" Such a thing literally does not exist, for one thing; but who gets to define it? Just a naive idea but personally, I'd say a platform is politically neutral if it takes no action to prioritise or remove content unless required by law. This puts what should and shouldn't be on the platform in the hands of lawmakers, who, theoretically at least, represent the will of the people. However that's bad for business so I'm under no illusions it'll ever become reality.
- jchw 8y agoIt's worse than that. Let's say a far right conspiracy blog is posting a conspiracy about a school shooting before any information is really available. Suddenly, it's on top of Google and being surfaced prominently on Facebook. People don't like this because these neutral companies are now promoting fake, definitely potentially harmful stories. But if you penalize them for this, from one viewpoint, you are suppressing political opinion. That's with a conspiracy; but if you drag the slider backwards, you find that there's no actual tipping point where it's clear action should be taken. Further, what if the far right has more conspiracy theorist than the far left? It would be partisan to not run fake news! Going more subtle, bias in algorithms is a thing. Like PageRank is based on the number of high quality links to your page, right? What happens when rightwing views are underrepresented because their network of links is naturally considered less high quality due to being less linked around the web? And if you think people would never make arguments like this, try to remember how often people fight over the correlation of politics and population density. It's why the United States has a Senate and a House.
- Youden 8y agoIdeally in this case, legislators would introduce a change encouraging deprioritization of information that is provably not factual.