4 ms·
Making it easier to repay student loans with other people’s money will surely fix the student loan crisis. How could it possibly make it worse? Sigh.
by MBCook 8y ago
Making it easier to repay student loans with other people’s money will surely fix the student loan crisis.
How could it possibly make it worse?
Sigh.
- jakamau 8y agoI don't see this decision using "other people's money" to repay student loans. From what I read in the article, the employee would earn match benefits up-to-but-not-exceeding normal limits for money they put in towards their student debt and 401K retirement. e.g. Employee A has no student debt and contributes $5,000 to their employer's 401k program - qualifying them for a $5,000 employer match to their retirement. Employee B has student debt and contributes $4000 to their student debt payment and $1,000 towards their employer's 401k program - qualifying them for a $5,000 employer match to their retirement.
- gowld 8y agoCorrect, but it's still promoting excessing borrowing, which causes price increases. The "other people" now becomes future-you: "throw away your retirement to pay for overpriced colleges". Cash subsidies are usually bad, because the cash gets siphoned off by monopolists or near-monopolists. Instead the government should be directly purchasing and distributing in-kind, and using its power to negotiate a good price. This is how Medicaid works and how public colleges work.
- MBCook 8y agoThat was my reading too. I’m just assuming this is going to be a standard benefit pretty fast. And now instead of saving for retirement at a youn age (compound interest is a very powerful thing) and instead use this benefit to pay off their loan. But I worry people will just interpret this as ‘your job will help pay off your loans’ and this be willing to take on more/bigger loans than they would otherwise. So now they’re on the hook for more and don’t get the retirement benefit they could have elected for. It can be used well, I worry it won’t be.