6 ms·
Several important differences between self-driving and smartphones: 1. Driving automation is orders of magnitude more expensive 2. Improperly-tested vehicles
by smt88 8y ago
Several important differences between self-driving and smartphones:
1. Driving automation is orders of magnitude more expensive
2. Improperly-tested vehicles are much more likely to have fatal consequences, meaning a 90% perfect smartphone is OK, but 90% perfect driving software would kill people
3. It's much, much easier to clone an iPhone than Waymo hardware + software
- 3pt14159 8y agoYou're both right. It is much harder to clone Waymo. Doesn't mean that there isn't a second mover advantage. Plus the amount of patents involved in this mean even if you're burning money down a dead end you might stumble upon an insight / patent that would help regardless of the approach taken. Often time with engineering a good design comes out of a known shortcoming of some other subsystem.
- adventured 8y ago> Driving automation is orders of magnitude more expensive Only if you pretend it didn't take decades of gradual improvement to make the iPhone possible, and ignore the epic manufacturing cost of the components. Basically only if you ignore everything that has / does go into smartphones. It took hundreds of billions of dollars of investment into the underlying iPhone components and their near ancestors, to make the iPhone possible. What's the total cost of the specific driving automation segment so far? A fraction of all the money plowed just into semiconductor fabrication development and construction over the last ~25 years so we could have smartphones at all. Then move on to the investment into storage, software, glass, communication chips, security, glass, etc. It'd be equivalent to pretending that we're going to leap from Tesla's hands-free to full automation without anything inbetween. The iPhone didn't materialize out of nowhere.
- smt88 8y agoTotal cost isn't relevant. I'm only considering the IP needed on top of widely-available hardware/software. There are billions invested into electric cars, too, but every large company has access to that technology (either with acquisition or licensing).
- nerdwaller 8y agoAgreed, the cost of the original iPhone vs existing phones was likely “orders of magnitude more” but took a while to proliferate across the competitive space.
- superbaconman 8y agoCouldn't you just mount your sensors next to an existing car's sensors, measure the car's actions then tell your network "do that" based on the mounted sensors input?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- inverse_pi 8y agoExplaining why this doesn't work is a great ML interview question.
- alexsb92 8y agoAs someone not involved in ML, why doesn't it work?
- perfmode 8y agoreducing error on the training set doesn’t always generalize to an unseen test set
- mcny 8y agoYup, I didn't learn much from my image analysis class but the professor made sure that over fitting and under fitting concepts were firmly lodged in our heads.
- 8note 8y agoI don't want to subject my drivers to dangerous conditions to train my cars to handle them
- david-gpu 8y agoWell, there are companies out there (like drive.ai IIRC) training such models end-to-end, so it is not entirely out of the question.
- 8y ago