7 ms·
I would much rather see people working on solving the affordable housing shortage in the US than on basic income experiments. Because of the high cost of housi
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I would much rather see people working on solving the affordable housing shortage in the US than on basic income experiments. Because of the high cost of housing across the US, a single childless person cannot live on $1000/month in many places. There are cities where rent on a one bedroom apartment is nearly $1000/month.
If you don't solve the affordable housing problem, basic income doesn't have any hope of ending poverty. If you do, many people who are currently living with terrible distress could make their lives work.
If you are only going to work on one of the two, affordable housing should be the priority. If you want do both, cool. But I'm not really seeing affordable housing given anywhere near the attention that basic income is getting.
- sli 8y ago> There are cities where rent on a one bedroom apartment is nearly $1000/month. And I think the reality of this statement is lost of many folks, because it's not just large cities that have this problem. I live in a moderately sized city (~100k people) and rents here are nearly $1000/mo for an average one bedroom apartment.
- kerng 8y agoIn Seattle and SF it's more like $2000 per month.
- erentz 8y agoMinimum in my experience. I haven’t been able to pay under $2000 for a 1 bedroom in the 7 years I’ve lived in Seattle. The cheapest I’ve gotten was $2100 but that was a place where you had to deal with mold, you heard your neighbors every conversation, and the whole building shook when the washing machine downstairs ran.
- ryanmonroe 8y agoI think the fear of not being able to find a job is a large part of the reason people don't just move somewhere cheaper when they can't afford housing. There are of course other reasons, e.g. community, for staying in expensive areas, but I think people would be more likely to move to where they can afford housing if they have an guaranteed income stream. Theoretically this would also decrease demand on the low-end of high-price housing areas, lowering prices.
- pier25 8y agoOr move to another country like Mexico or Thailand.
- taysic 8y agoYou can't outright move to Thailand at least. You'd need to do visa runs in neighboring countries but couldn't live there 365 days a year.
- pier25 8y agoThose were just examples. There are dozens of alternatives.
- taysic 8y agoCountries you could outright permanently move to? Which ones?
- pier25 8y agoYou mean countries that you can simply land and live forever without a visa? I doubt that exists. But it should be easy to get a visa to live in Mexico, Costa Rica, Portugal, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovenia, etc. Thailand and India are more complicated, yes, but getting out for a couple of days every and year and coming back is not such a big issue.
- lutorm 8y agoI think it's funny that Americans (I assume you're American, just based on statistics) thinks that moving to another country is just a thing you can decide to do, given the current immigration debate in the U.S...
- pier25 8y agoI'm not American. I'm Spanish and have been living in Mexico for close to a decade.
- nugget 8y agoIf you don't solve for affordable housing first, then basic income dollars will simply be sucked up by landlords and contribute to even more inflationary pressure in the rental markets. There's already evidence for this in neighborhoods where Section 8 vouchers are predominant.
- scotty79 8y agoThat's why I think basic income should be financed by progressive property tax. It should quickly progress so that you have to sell your eleventh house to pay annual tax for tenth and to count your properties you should include the ones you own directly but also the ones owned by entities you own. This tax would be even good if the money gathered was used for any purpose other than basic income. It incentivises ownership by dropping property prices and discourages rent seeking hoarding of finite and basic resource.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ZainRiz 8y agoBut there is affordable housing. The only problem is that the affordable housing is not in the big cities that those people would like to live in. Go to a smaller town and housing is pretty cheap there. If you get a larger influx of people moving there because of cheap housing, then those cities will suddenly have more job openings available because they have to meet the needs of more people.
- manicdee 8y agoEspecially when the (jobless) renter is getting $1000 a month but is only spending $600 on rent. That's $400 a month per new renter that is going into the local economy through grocery stores, bars, and public transport. That's new jobs being created.
- hollandheese 8y agoWhat small town would that be? Definitely not one on the West Coast. It's around $1000 for a one bedroom here in Humboldt County, and at least $350,000 for a decent 3 bedroom house.
- esharte 8y agoHousing is used as an investment asset and a source of income rather than a home. If you took all the investors out of the housing market, housing should cost just the price of construction.
- MrFantastic 8y agoIn the more expensive areas you are actually paying more for the land than the house. $500k properties are torn down to build new homes.
- SilasX 8y agoAnd a lot of government policy is based on getting people to buy a home, attaching a lot of net worth to its value. Then, surprise! People vote in a way that keeps up housing costs!
- baby 8y agoI’m not sure I understand why it would be more important. If you have universal income you can then probably afford to move to a cheaper place. Whereas making housing cheaper is just going to attract more people and you’re going full cycle.
- smattiso 8y agoCalling it an affordable housing "shortage" implies that we need more housing in order for it to become affordable. The fact is there is already plenty of housing (people live somewhere don't they?) the problem is that it is unaffordable because supply and demand will never cause the rents to go down en masse. It's one of the few limited resources that people are forced to buy that essentially has no maximum price. Everybody starts getting basic income? Rents will rise to eat up the majority of that income without some external control. The same way we needed unions, minimum wage, etc. we need a collective bargaining system for the renters vs. landowners. Rent control, what have you. It's kind of the antithesis of the American dream but what we have isnt working all that well.
- DoreenMichele 8y agohttps://www.geekwire.com/2018/every-100-families-living-poverty-west-coast-no-30-affordable-homes/ https://www.geekwire.com/2018/every-100-families-living-pove... There is a serious homeless problem in the US. Some folks "living somewhere" are living in a tent or an illegal Air BnB etc.
- smattiso 8y agoAs a percentage what are talking about? There are homes and apartments aplenty, the biggest issue is the economics of it. What would cause rents to go down? An oversupply? What would cause an oversupply? Barring some regional crash it would have to be overbuilding. People aren't dumb and they won't overbuild. They will build as demand increases but they certainly won't lower prices. If anything they will raise them. It's obvious.
- eanzenberg 8y agoIt’s unaffordable because many people are inherently selfish and want to live in desirable locations as opposed to the already afforable areas that the majority land-mass of the USA consititutes.
- smattiso 8y agoI dont think that's it at all. Even in "undesireable" places the rents approach what a median income earner can afford anywhere. It's akin to why we have minimum wages. Without them people will work (out of desperation) for pennies because they have to.
- SilasX 8y agoRight, if you don't similarly fix the housing bottleneck, then nothing stops rents from just advancing to capture the additional UBI. I think there's a general problem here, about the "how much you got?" economy -- increasingly many critical goods are charged for in a way that effectively eats up any gain in income. For example, college and health care -- you get hit with an obscenely high bill and they just figure out how much you can really afford and charge that.
- Jach 8y ago> a single childless person cannot live on $1000/month in many places. Is this really the demographic that should be optimized for? Seems there's a nice financial incentive to find a partner and split the cost of rent. As a single childless person myself (who has shared rental houses with a friend for several years now to lower costs of rent and keep it "affordable") I've been led to believe that the cost of having children amortizes (especially as you add more children) with incentives, and really pays off as you get into old age. If it were up to me I'd rather optimize for the family unit rather than singles.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWe have been optimizing for the nuclear family since the 1950s. Meanwhile, our demographics have diverged from that. This is part of the problem. We have more singles, more childless couples and more single parents. Their housing needs are not being met. We expect young single people to rent an apartment designed for a family and get roommates. If that works for you, that's already available. The assumption that someone with basic income should get a roommate is an assumption that they really aren't allowed to aspire to the same things as middle class people, like a space of their own. A lot of women currently de facto use a romantic partner as a means to cover rent and it causes all kinds of problems. Expecting people to pair off to have a decent place is essentially expecting a polite form of prostitution.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y ago> Expecting people to pair off to have a decent place is essentially expecting a polite form of prostitution. What it really boils down to is that an average middle class family in the past had a full-time housekeeper. Typically, those housekeepers were single women. Nowadays, that same demographic group has kids of their own. I wouldn’t call it prostitution so much as pragmatism.
- coolaliasbro 8y agoI apologise for all the child comments but I find your posts compelling. However, your 3rd paragraph above seems a bit at odds with your idea in an earlier comment to rebuild SROs. In any case, I think the same sorts of housing opportunities should be available to all, which is why I brought up the fact that the USA has ample unused housing, it's mostly just an issue of policy/assholes in power.
- jondubois 8y agoI used to like the idea of Basic Income, but now I think that all the money would go into rents and property owners would absorb all the value. the problem of affordable housing is actually very simple and the solution is obvious; too many people are moving to big cities; so everyone ends up competing for increasingly limited real estate (in a desperate bid to cut their commute times to less than 2 hours per day). One of the main reasons why so many people are moving to urban centers is because that's where all the jobs are; it's a direct result of the centralization of capital in the hands of corporations. Corporate HQs are in big cities because they want to get access to the best talent and corporations are more likely to find talent in places where there are lots of people to choose from. One solution would be for the government to introduce legislation to encourage companies to hire remote workers. Another solution would be for the government to introduce legislation to make the economy less focused on corporate growth. Due in a large part to corporate lobbying, whenever a politician is presented a choice between a free solution and an expensive one; they tend to pick the expensive one.
- DoreenMichele 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_room_occupancy SROs used to be pretty commonly available. We tore down up to 80 percent of them over the course of two decades, probably because Baby Boomers were wealthy enough to not need something that cheap. We never rebuilt them. I think rebuilding them would be a step in the right direction.
- coolaliasbro 8y agoI see your point, but AFAIK, there is ample empty housing to ensure everyone in the United States has a roof over their head, so maybe appropriating dis/misused properties toward this end would also be an option?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't know. I've spent years researching this issue. I had a class on Homelessness and Public Policy through SFSU when I was living in Fairfield, CA. This was long before I was homeless. Then I spent nearly six years homeless and researching how to get myself off the street and back into housing and this was very eye opening. I would like to read through the several thousand page Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance, but I'm having trouble finding the time. I haven't gotten very far. I am trying to create pilot programs and find things that actually work. I would like to stop just shooting down suggestions that don't work and start saying "Well, we did x, y and z in my small town and that got such and such results and here is how you can try to replicate that." But I'm still struggling to make ends meet myself, and yadda. So it's slow going.
- coolaliasbro 8y agoDitto school debt, health care, and child care. If these costs were not (increasingly) the burden of proles, we could all do a lot more with what we have/where we are currently at economically.
- jcranmer 8y ago> Because of the high cost of housing across the US, a single childless person cannot live on $1000/month in many places. There are cities where rent on a one bedroom apartment is nearly $1000/month. Let me correct that for you: a single, childless person cannot maintain a lower-middle class living standard on $1000/month. If you start giving up amenities, you can live on less money. You don't need cable TV, nor do you need to have a budget for eating out. Of course, the two single biggest savings you can do are a) move to a lower cost of living area and b) get a roommate or two. Half the rent of a 2-bedroom apartment is going to be about 50-60% the rent of a one-bedroom apartment. Basic income shouldn't be targeted to ensuring that people can afford to bum around on no income in a high-cost of living area. If you want to live in a high-cost location, you should secure the income to live there.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoBasic income shouldn't be targeted to ensuring that people can afford to bum around on no income in a high-cost of living area. If you want to live in a high-cost location, you should secure the income to live there. Sam Altman and other tech giants are proposing basic income as a means to provide for people incapable of getting jobs due to automation permanently eliminating jobs for large numbers of people. They predict permanent unemployment of up to 80 percent of the population. The jobs being eliminated currently pay between $20k and $50k. Once they eliminate those jobs, they are talking about giving you about $10k and no hope of ever having a full time job again. Please go talk to the people who are proposing UBI as a solution to this scenario, not me. I am not actually pro UBI. I am for seeing this as another industrial revolution and further improving worker's rights. Among other things, the first industrial revolution gave birth to the expectation of a 40 hour work week in order to spread earned income around. I am all for people working for a better life. But people like Sam Altman would like to design a world in which that is simply not possible for most Americans and would like to then throw a few crumbs to the masses for whom a job is simply not a possibility in the world they foresee and would like to optimize for. (Though I think if your goal is to eliminate jobs -- rather than find ways to redistribute work -- then UBI needs to be designed as a middle class income, not a poverty level income. Otherwise, you are an asshole in my book if this is the world you want to design for people who aren't already millionaires.)
- throw2016 8y agoBasic income is more than just about affordability. Higher housing costs is a problem that needs to be urgently addressed beyond just basic income as it diverts and concentrates resources in the renteer class, resources that could be used for other productive economic activity and job creation. Free markets need 'choice' to work efficiently, consumer choice, manufacturers choice, its always labour who don't have 'real choice' as you need to work to survive, it's not a choice. And no labour market is ever liquid or fluid enough to afford 'choice' and the very nature of labour makes quick choice difficult. What basic income has the potential to do is introduce choice in this critical component of free markets and give it the same power as capital and consumer choice. However given how disruptive it is to 'entrenched interests' its an extremely difficult idea to pull off. It defines the bitter struggle between capital and labour for 300 years and there won't be easy wins. Studies, funding, motives, methodologies, data need to be examined carefully as they could be studies simply to discredit the idea and kill it at birth, or reduce it to a 'extremely basic income' as a tool to subsidize employers.
- ilaksh 8y agoYou can't get a decent one bedroom for $1000 in San Diego. It's more $1300 for a decent one. But even $1000 is extremely difficult to find if not impossible. My dad is in a board and care in San Diego so I want to stay near him for awhile. But I work for a startup without funding and I am sick of living with roommates, so I am moving to Tijuana.
- rubicon33 8y agoLets, for the sake of argument, say you could solve the housing crisis instantly. Suddenly, homes in major cities drop to $100,000, thanks to some hypothetical government backed program. The part of the problem that nobody ever seems able to solve, is what you do for existing owners who are locked into a 30 year mortgage on their $1,000,000+ property. You would effectively be wiping out their life savings. There would need to be some way of appeasing the existing owner base, before you can ever solve the housing crisis.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThat's not what I am suggesting at all. I am suggesting we need more small spaces, like SROs (I have already linked to the Wikipedia article on that in a different comment). In the 1950s, most new homes were around 1200 square feet and held about 4.5 people. Today, the typical new home is over 2400 square feet and holds about 3.5 people (IIRC). I see zero reason why 2400 square foot homes would lose any value whatsoever if we built more small homes so people who can't afford a house that big can still afford a place of their own.
- RestlessMind 8y ago> I see zero reason why 2400 square foot homes would lose any value whatsoever if we built more small homes One factor why house prices are high is that demand exceeds supply. By building small homes, a lot of demand would be catered to by a new pool of housing. Heck, even those who could afford bigger houses but prefer smaller houses for whatever reasons (eg. frugality) would be removed from demand side. So now there would be a downward pressure on house prices.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIn much of the US, homes are gaining value at better than minimum wage rates per hour. Given that people working minimum wage jobs cannot work 24/7, owning a home is putting money in your pocket faster than a minimum wage job. This means that downward pressure on home prices amounts to slowing hyperinflation to a more reasonable rate. This isn't remotely the same as gutting the equity for existing homeowners (much less putting them "upside down," where they owe more than the house is worth). http://www.worldpropertyjournal.com/real-estate-news/united-states/seattle/2018-zillow-group-consumer-housing-trends-report-2018-minimum-wage-report-home-appreciation-report-for-2018-real-estate-news-10834.php http://www.worldpropertyjournal.com/real-estate-news/united-...
- mendelsd 8y agoA major factor affecting housing affordability is the quantity of credit being assigned to mortgages relative to investment in the real economy. This is well explained by a professor of finance here (52 mins): https://youtu.be/N-FDdHj7rPk https://youtu.be/N-FDdHj7rPk