5 ms·
Humans are clearly exceptional in numerous positive ways. There is no real debate to be had there. Let me know when the whales, monkeys and dolphins put a tele
by adventured 8y ago
Humans are clearly exceptional in numerous positive ways. There is no real debate to be had there.
Let me know when the whales, monkeys and dolphins put a telescope into orbit. And let me know what the grieving orca thinks about generational knowledge transference or the afterlife.
Human exceptionalism isn't simultaneously a degradation of the amazing traits of other species. Just because humans are exceptional intellectually compared to gorillas, that doesn't actually take anything away from gorillas.
- projektir 8y agoNeither of those things indicate that humans have wildly different inner lives, though. A lot of these may perhaps be attributed to a combination of language development and tools usage, neither of which is really relevant to the parent's point in any way, so I don't really understand your digression. Humans DO have a history of degrading the inner lives of animals and it's a problem. We don't even know for sure that humans are exceptional intellectually compared to gorillas in an objective sense, we're just deriving that from the aforementioned telescope example which is not scientific in the slightest. Humans have plenty to be proud of but with things like "we're more intelligent" or "we're more emotionally developed" as opposed to "we got a lucky combination of things" I'd rather be really careful.
- emodendroket 8y agoThere's no need to resort to fancy engineering projects -- where's the animal that knows how to craft novel utterances to express new ideas, or the animal that has a sense of self? The animal that has an awareness of its own mortality? The animal that can appreciate ideas like morality? It doesn't exist.
- jahewson 8y agoYou’re literally describing dolphins: “New evidence suggests that dolphins, like elephants and the great apes, may comprehend their own mortality.” https://www.mnn.com/earth-matters/animals/stories/do-dolphins-mourn-their-dead https://www.mnn.com/earth-matters/animals/stories/do-dolphin...
- interfixus 8y ago> * It doesn't exist* [citatation needed]
- emodendroket 8y agoGenerally you can't really prove a negative but feel free to give counterexamples
- interfixus 8y agoOf something you claim cannot be proven, perhaps a less categorial expression than "It doesn't exist". I do believe I have seen animal examples of all three of your statements, an logically, there must have been among our ancestors, but the onus isn't really on me.
- emodendroket 8y agoLook, I can't prove that there aren't goblins either, and yet I bet you wouldn't demand I couch a statement about their existence in weak language like "to the best of my knowledge, there is no evidence that goblins exist."
- interfixus 8y agoYou claim the non-existence of "the animal that has a sense of self". This is unsubstatiated, to say the very least, or patently nonsense, to say a bit more. And yes you can. I use expressions all the time very much like "to the best of my knowledge, there is no evidence that God exists".
- emodendroket 8y agoIf it's so nonsensical surely you can find counterexamples. Animals are frequently confused by their own reflections. I never claimed that you can't use noncommittal language to dismiss things for which there is no evidence; I just don't really feel like there is any point.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- toomanybeersies 8y ago> Humans DO have a history of degrading the inner lives of animals and it's a problem Humans have enough a history of degrading the inner lives of fellow humans, let alone other animals.
- 36bydesign 8y agoThings human value (exploration, science) aren’t necessarily things other species would value. We tend to destroy the planet in our pursuits, so I’m not as confident as you are in our own species’ intellectual superiority. Many species have better memories than humans, including most monkey/ape species. We have exceptional dexterity while dolphins don’t, so is it a fair fight to judge intelligence by putting a telescope into orbit? Do dolphins have as high a rate of depression in their species as humans? Do they have as many wars as us? Again, are we really that much more intelligent than these other species? Measuring intelligence is hard because we don’t have a rigorous definition.
- emodendroket 8y agoThe only species which even begins to have a plausible comparison is the octopus. Yes, I feel completely confident saying we're more intelligent than orcas or monkeys.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoBut the question was if “more intelligent” gives us the authority to eat them, or make them go extinct by destroying their habitat, or abuse them for medicine trials. And if “more intelligent” is a valid reason you are immediately entering a weird area where it is okay to eat a baby because hey, it’s less intelligent! But I doubt many people would think that’s a valid reason, so we’re back to speciesism. which is also problematic because then we appoint the human as sole judge and juror of all living things.
- emodendroket 8y agoThat's a separate question but not the one any of the posts I replied to were addressing. I don't think it's honest to attribute to shield properties they don't have simply because you don't like the implications of the reality.
- JoshTko 8y agoSo did humans 20,000 years ago lack emotional depth since they had yet to invent complex technology?
- laretluval 8y agoThey likely had the same cognitive capacity as us, and if dropped into a modern environment could invent complex technology. No other animal can do this as far as we know.
- colanderman 8y agoYes, but "designing complex technology" has little to nothing to do with capability to feel emotion.
- laretluval 8y agoIt establishes a major way in which human minds are different from animal minds, such that generalizing from humans to animals may be incorrect.
- tlear 8y agoHumans had bow and arrow, sling, spear thrower. Which is might as well be satellite in orbit when compared to tech of any animal we know off.
- sharmi 8y agoTool making and use among animals have been documented for quite some time. [1] What's significant is , in most cases, the animals are both "tool makers" and "tool users". They find items most suitable for their purpose and adapt it as much as possible. May be, they are not as versatile as we are, but they have the recognition that 1. Objects can be repurposed for some other use that what they see in nature. 2. Certain objects are better suited than others, though they are similar. 3. A fore said objects can be modified further to increase efficiency. 4. This knowledge is often passed among communities and families through observation or teaching rather than as genetic changes. >> Both bonobos and chimpanzees have been observed making "sponges" out of leaves and moss that suck up water and using these for grooming >> Elephants have been observed digging holes to drink water, then ripping bark from a tree, chewing it into the shape of a ball thereby manufacturing a "plug" to fill in the hole, and covering it with sand to avoid evaporation. They would later go back to the spot to drink. >> Indo-Pacific bottlenose dolphins made up of approximately 41-54 animals, are known to use conical sponges (Echinodictyum mesenterinum) as tools while foraging. ...During sponging, dolphins mainly target fish that lack swim bladders and burrow in the substrate. Therefore, the sponge may be used to protect their rostrums as they forage in a niche where echolocation and vision are less effective hunting techniques. Sponging may be socially learned from mother to offspring. >> Woodpecker Finches have been observed to use a different type of tool with novel functional features such as barbed twigs from blackberry bushes, a plant that is not native to the islands. The twigs were first modified by removing side twigs and leaves and then used such that the barbs helped drag prey out of tree crevices. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals