7 ms·
I mean, what advantage does it have over gold? Advantages of gold vs. Bitcoin: - gold is pretty easy to find, not that hard to buy for the average consumer; B
by bobthepanda 8y ago
I mean, what advantage does it have over gold?
Advantages of gold vs. Bitcoin:
- gold is pretty easy to find, not that hard to buy for the average consumer; BTC is anything but
- gold is physical in form and securing it is not hard; BTC is not physical, exchanges get hacked with losses to accounts, in the event of a natural disaster or some event where power generation and internet is lost you lose access to BTC. (Someone can come break in and loot your gold, but people could also do that with your BTC wallet credentials, and if people are doing that you have worse things to worry about)
- gold at least has some kind of floor value, since it does have uses other than a currency store; the same is not true for BTC
- guiomie 8y agoCan't figure out if this is sarcasm...
- replies_to_all 8y agoGold - Can be transferred instantly for pennies anywhere in the world with an internet connection. - Not controlled by an inflated "paper" gold market. - Can not be controlled by a government.... Yes, I hope it was sarcasm.
- guiomie 8y agoI'm surprised about the downvotes, for me the following arugments can't be taken seriously? "gold is pretty easy to find, not that hard to buy for the average consumer; BTC is anything" ... You can buy BTC with your credit card no KYC needed or you can mine it yourself. Are you gonna start mining gold? If you want to buy to gold you need a trading account, or you order gold and it gets delivered to you, not as simple as buying BTC at all. "gold is physical in form and securing it is not hard" ... You need a safe and/or insurance, much more complicated then using a password/cold wallet. "gold at least has some kind of floor value" ... The floor value is really small if you remove the speculative aspect of gold.
- deevolution 8y agoMaybe its a generational thing, but i have no clue how i would go about buying/trading gold and i dont think anyone in my friend group does either. Bitcoin is far more accessible.
- rrdharan 8y agoIt’s pretty easy to just buy $GLD with any brokerage account if you just want gold exposure. If you don’t trust the ETFs to honor your claims when the apocalypse arrives things are harder of course.
- bobthepanda 8y agoYou can literally go to a gold dealer shop; it's like forex for gold. Even in my moderately sized American city there are twenty that show up in Google Maps within a twenty minute drive. And you buy gold and it's physically in your possession; verifying it is easy, and the best part is you can verify it at some other gold dealer if you're super paranoid. With BTC, you have to find a trusted exchange and a trusted wallet. The average consumer doesn't really know anything beyond a google search and the first two results.
- lisper 8y ago> verifying it is easy Actually, it's not. It's nearly impossible to non-destructively distinguish gold from tungsten wrapped in gold.
- raziel2701 8y ago
- sneak 8y agoSecuring bitcoin is much easier than securing gold. Gold can be confiscated easily; bitcoin is much harder, especially with things like brainkeys. Additionally, gold does not have a built in global teleporter. Bitcoin does. I can send basically an unlimited quantity of value to anyone with internet access in minutes with bitcoin; the same is not possible with gold. If bitcoin is only useful for global remittance and bypassing the long-distance-money-transfer cartels of the world, it is an insanely valuable tool. My estimation is that it is valuable for at least that, and probably several other things as well (e.g. online payments for physical goods that are subject to high chargeback risk, et c).
- comboy 8y agoIn this context, it's much harder to protect gold from the government (if it decides it wants to take it away). Plus buying stuff online is more tricky. I could envision alternative reality though, where there are companies specializing in providing tokens that have 100% coverage in gold. You would need to trust them and their software, but some trust is always involved. The problem is those would be an easy target with physical holdings (so the problem of the gov comes back, but they could choose under which gov to operate). In that scenario, if the problem gets big enough the gov will take care of it, no matter where on the planet is that gold. In the case of Bitcoin though, while temporarily it can be hampered very easily, it's quite impossible to make it completely go away. The biggest point for gold IMO which you didn't mention, since all value comes from people and their beliefs, is thousands of years vs 10 years.
- GW150914 8y agoIf the government wants your gold or private key, they’re going to get it. How long are you going to hold out against their proverbial $5 rubber hose? Solitary confinement? Mundane legal threats?
- comboy 8y agoHow does it know you have one? You can use brain wallet[1], you can use trezor with multiple passphrases. You can give up some of your bitcoins and if you manage your wallets properly then no one can prove you have some more. 1. Don't use brain wallets, unless you really understand security
- GW150914 8y agoBecause at some point you have to pay taxes, or break the law. They nailed Al Capone, and you’re not Al Capone. I suppose you could buy it in secret and never liquidate it, spend it, or declare it... and therefore never benefit from it. I guess that’s a “win” in some books? Otherwise the answer to your question is pretty obvious, and ends with you in prison.
- CyberDildonics 8y agoThe fact that you can use it electronically.
- deevolution 8y agoBitcoin advantage: easily and instantly divisible. Gold not so much. Bitcoin advantage: weighs nothing, highly transportable. Gold not so much.
- qeternity 8y ago> Bitcoin advantage: easily and instantly divisible. Gold not so much. Not so important for a store of value. > Bitcoin advantage: weighs nothing, highly transportable. Gold not so much. Yet requires an order of magnitude more skill and overhead to handle.
- alienplutonic 8y agoHardware wallets are stupid simple to use for BTC.
- qeternity 8y agoStupid simple for you maybe. The average person in the developed world would disagree, ignoring people in a third world country like Venezuela (the example that prompted this comment thread) who likely don't even have a computer.
- keymone 8y ago(bangs head on the wall) > what advantage does it have over gold? can you point me to words "store", "of" and "value" in the above question? > order of magnitude more skill and overhead to handle only if you assume handling gold means dropping the gold bar in your basement and never touching it again?
- dragontamer 8y ago> can you point me to words "store", "of" and "value" in the above question? Bitcoin is up the past couple of weeks. So inevitably, the BTC community will be calling it a store of value. I think the general community is just reacting to the moving goalposts. When BTC's value is up, its a store of value. When its value is down, BTC's value is its transactions.
- DINKDINK 8y ago>where power generation and internet is lost you lose access to BTC You don't need the internet nor the power grid to use bitcoin. To use bitcoin via the Lightning Network minimally, you need a CPU and a method to transmit data. CPU: phone Transmit Data: Bluetooth, QR code/camera. Electricity for your phone: Cheap emergency solar panel
- surfacedetail 8y agoThe Lightning Network? Really?
- topranks 8y agoIt’ll save us all - and work perfectly without the internet too!
- dragontamer 8y ago> You don't need the internet nor the power grid to use bitcoin. > To use bitcoin via the Lightning Network minimally, you need a CPU and a method to transmit data. How do you verify that your opposing party actually has bitcoins to send to you?
- another-cuppa 8y ago> I mean, what advantage does it have over gold? It's electronic. That is the only advantage, but it's a huge one considering that virtually all (yes, virtually all) money transfers are done electronically today.
- antidesitter 8y agoHow are gold bars easier to secure and transport than private keys?