4 ms·
The population of humans is booming. What a shame you had to spoil your otherwise reasonable argument with this canard. In most areas of the global (the Americ
by joe_the_user 8y ago
The population of humans is booming.
What a shame you had to spoil your otherwise reasonable argument with this canard. In most areas of the global (the Americas, Europe, Asia above India), population is not booming but shrinking.
Moreover, the destruction of various sorts we see hardly the result of booming population by itself but massive resource wastage of variety of sorts combined overall short-sightedness. Climate change is 97 billion pound set to destroy our world and it's relation to population growth is quite tenuous.
- mirimir 8y agoSure, the human population is no longer growing exponentially. But mean resource use and pollution per capita is still growing. During the last century or two, when humanity released all that CO2, less than one billion people were responsible for most of it. And now we have maybe 2-3 billion more who demand such a lifestyle. So anyway, it's not population per se that matters. It's the sum over population times per capita impact. And that is still growing exponentially.
- joe_the_user 8y agoSure, the human population is no longer growing exponentially. Which is to say it isn't "booming". But mean resource use and pollution per capita is still growing. Indeed total resource is huge and massively destructive but that use isn't even happening in any uniform per capita basis but rather some individuals, processes and organizations consume far more than others. Bitcoin for example, air conditioning Dubai for example, etc, etc.
- mirimir 8y agoI didn't argue that resource use and pollution per capita is uniform. It's obviously not. But damn, just look at the aggregate indicators. CO2 emissions are still growing exponentially. Ecological degradation is increasing exponentially. We're starting to see widespread firestorms across the northern hemisphere.
- joe_the_user 8y agoI agree we in a horrible, crisis situation. I simply believe pointing to overpopulation as a primary cause is wrong headed. The world's nations could stop a country's worth of energy use tomorrow by banning bitcoin as just a single example. There are other, harder examples but the (awful) problem of stopping runaway really doesn't seem related to a "booming" human population - the quote I originally took issue with.
- mirimir 8y agoThe causes are co-option and destruction of ecosystems, and various sorts of pollution. I do agree that it's inaccurate to focus on overpopulation. Still, some impacts, such as ecosystem co-option for agriculture, and harvesting wood for fuel, are substantial even without industrial development. Also, expecting industrial development to moderate growth rates in rapidly growing populations is iffy. Time lags could push systems into regimes with positive feedback. Ultimately, though, human populations will crash, and stuff will head back toward equilibrium.
- joe_the_user 8y agoThe only possible solution is policy changes that force a significant decrease in resource usage among a wide swath of the developed and less-developed population. That solution would be necessary regardless of the level of population increase we're going to see. The population increase is going to correct itself. The resource usage so far does not seem like it's going. And certainly, populations in less developed areas have done and can quite a bit of damage - but that damage can only be corrected by state policies to prevent poor resource usage. Also, expecting industrial development to moderate growth rates in rapidly growing populations is iffy. This has occurred in a fairly predictable rate over the majority of the world's area. India, the Mid-East and Africa are basically the primary areas of growing population in the world.
- dredmorbius 8y agoFor most of human history, population growth was on the order of 0.04%/yr. It's been about 1.1% in recent decades, 25 times greater. One might even say "booming".
- singularity2001 8y ago1.1% by the way still exponential, just a lower factor than 50 ya
- dredmorbius 8y agoNB, fossil fuel use was doubling every decade or two (3.5 - 7% annual growth) through much of the 20th century. This means that roughly half of all carbon emissions were from the most recent 10-20 years. As of 2007, half of all emissions dated from about 1987. http://www.mygreenlife.com.au/media/article-images/au-cumulative-co2-emissions.png http://www.mygreenlife.com.au/media/article-images/au-cumula...
- A2017U1 8y agoMost projections are for about 10 billion people by 2050. Even if the population stopped growing today developing countries are rapidly modernising. A few billion people soon to be middle class consumers. The world can't cope with every Chinese person consuming as much as the average American, and they are quickly moving down that path, meat and dairy consumption is a good example of this.
- mirimir 8y agoYes, that was exactly my point. India too, and Southeast Asia generally. Maybe even substantial parts of Africa. As far as global climate change goes, we ain't seen nothing yet :(
- A2017U1 8y agoHopefully starting afresh they can avoid some of the developed worlds mistakes like power generation lock-in and poorly planned car based cities. But when it comes to meat consumption, making concrete and airline travel there's currently no way around the huge emissions. Air travel has been growing at 6% for decades now with no sign of stopping and makes up a significant chunk of global emissions. I have no solutions but feel people are underestimating how hard this problem is to fix.