10 ms·
Energy Department teams up with Bill Gates to move mini-nuclear plants to market
- ianai 8y ago“Southern Company and TerraPower plan to develop and license a test reactor before developing a 1,100-megawatt prototype by 2030.“ Seems entirely too little too late. We need enough of these to power US infrastructure and electric transportation ASAP.
- yazr 8y agoEnergy is a BIG, HUGE industry (about 5-10% of world GDP). It will always be a mix of technologies. Cost wise, however, i agree nuclear is late to the party. In 2018, we had large contracts for solar(+storage!) at 3cent/kw (in the US, Mexico and Saudi Arabia). European new nuclear came in at 15c/kw.
- cm2187 8y agoI understand mostly because it has been regulated to death
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI have doubts you’re going to be able to remove enough regulation to get nuclear near the same cost as storage backed renewables (which will continue to decline in cost each year even further). Without storage, renewables are already close to or below 2 cents/kWh (unsubsidized). Can nuclear startups make generating units as fast as automated fabs can spit out solar panels?
- alexeldeib 8y agoA big argument I have heard in support of nuclear is that it is good for maintaining some amount of base load. As I understand this is particularly important in the current scenario of renewable energy without good storage, since we can't necessarily maintain our energy requirements with solely other clean (relatively speaking) forms of energy.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThe race will be to see who can win the day: modular commodity nuclear, or utility scale battery storage (Flow batteries, lithium ion/polymer, etc). Presumably, both get cheaper as you make more, but anyone can make batteries and ship them around the world with little notice. Tesla’s Hornsdale Power Reserve system was built in 90 days. I don’t know of any nuclear plants that get built faster than 10 years.
- Jedd 8y ago> I don’t know of any nuclear plants that get built faster than 10 years. And the Brits are demonstrating just how woefully optimistic costs, build quality, and schedules can be even with that kind of protracted delivery expectation : https://jeremyleggett.net/2018/08/22/why-the-uk-nuclear-renaissance-plan-is-doomed-to-failure-in-30-pictures-and-charts/ https://jeremyleggett.net/2018/08/22/why-the-uk-nuclear-rena...
- bilbo0s 8y agoI don't know man? If you're familiar with dispatch stacks, you know that 3c/kw is REALLY attractive. Regulation or no regulation, I don't think you're gonna get down to 2c or 1c with a new nuclear plant. Maybe I'm wrong, and one day someone will figure out how to build SUPER cheap nuclear plants? But I doubt it. Best I would think they could do is some sort of hybrid system that uses nuclear generation, and then storage via a conventional hydro storage system or something maybe? I'd have to do the math on that. But yeah... 2c? That's very hard to do.
- joering2 8y agoMight be talking about European regulations. 15c per kw versus 3 in usa - thats 5x magnitude. Doesnt suprise - gallon of gas in most european countries (sold by liters and funny thing - you first pump then pay!) is about 40% more than same amount in USA. it has been like this forever and doesnt look like will ever change.
- pfdietz 8y agoMoltex is claiming they can get below $0.04/kWh (for N-th of a kind plants; FOAK would be a bit more expensive.) They can claim this plausibly for two reasons: first, they can build a MUCH smaller containment building, due to lack of water or other volatiles in the nuclear island. Second, their design isolates the turbines from the nuclear island with a molten salt "thermal battery". This allows some dispatchability in their output, but more importantly it means turbine trips have no effect on reactor stability, which means non-nuclear-grade turbines can be used. This is apparently a very large cost savings.
- bayesian_horse 8y agoI like regulating things that are radioactive or can potentially go boom. Especially both. [And yes, I know some designs are theoretically not able to melt/blow up]
- trothamel 8y agoThat's a lot closer than you'd think then. While it varies from location to location, the capacity factor of solar seems to be about 20%. That means - sustained - a solar system generates 20% of it's maximum power rating, because the amount of power it produces is lessened during the winter, cloudy days, and of course at night. The nuclear capacity factor, on the other hand, is rather high. Upwards of 90%, and sometimes even upwards of 100% (due to the powerplants being able to produce more energy than they were designed for). If you factor that in, a nuclear plant has about a 4.5x capacity compared to a solar plant, meaning you'd have to spend 13.5c/kw for solar with the same capacity. Of course, this varies greatly based on where you are. In sunny climates, solar's capacity is more like 30%, while in northern climates, it can be 15%. And I'd imagine the cost of new nuclear very much depends on regulations - in the US, it might as well be infinite.
- lukeschlather 8y agoI think you're applying an imaginary capacity factor to a number that already accounts for solar's intermittent yield. Solar is simply way cheaper than nuclear.
- realusername 8y agoDoes that account as well for the longevity of it? The current nuclear reactors lasted around 40 years already without much issues, I wouldn't bet the solar installations to last that long.
- robbiep 8y agoSolar installations are generally rated for a 30 year life, so ¾ of nuclear isn’t bad, especially when you add in decommissioning costs which are going to be a lot lower for solar
- natmaka 8y agoUK discounted provision for decommission costs: £100+ billion in 2013 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/jun/23/britain-nuclear-atomic-clean-up-decommissioning https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/jun/23/britain-... £161 billion in 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20170516093449/https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nuclear-provision-explaining-the-cost-of-cleaning-up-britains-nuclear-legacy/nuclear-provision-explaining-the-cost-of-cleaning-up-britains-nuclear-legacy https://web.archive.org/web/20170516093449/https://www.gov.u... £234 billion in 2018 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nuclear-provision-explaining-the-cost-of-cleaning-up-britains-nuclear-legacy/nuclear-provision-explaining-the-cost-of-cleaning-up-britains-nuclear-legacy https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nuclear-provision... ... and counting.
- yazr 8y agoEDIT UNIT CORRECTION: this is 3cent/khw and 15 c/kwh This means it is cost per final energy produced i.e. after taking into account capacity factors, day/night, etc
- caymanjim 8y agoI don't think we're facing any critical electricity shortage, at least in the continental US. This is just one of many new power generation systems being pursued. It is neither too little, because any amount helps, nor too late, because the need for more electricity is going to continue forever. I'm not sure how this is a negative thing.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoNegative? Reliable and ultra-long term fuel disposal (i.e., the lack there of) is still unsolved.
- caymanjim 8y agoI was referring specifically to the parent's concerns. Fuel disposal is certainly a problem in nuclear in general. I'm not sure about this specific reactor type; it's possible it produces less-troublesome waste, but I don't know. Most power generation is exceedingly bad for the planet in one way or another, but nuclear is certainly a whole lot better than fossil fuels.
- A2017U1 8y agoEngineering wise the disposal problem is solved. Making it politically palatable isn't. Australia has long debated taking the world's nuclear waste, numerous commissions have found it feasible and safe. The community is overwhelmingly against it though.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoIs disposal really a concern when we're facing the collapse of entire continent-sized ecosystems? Compared to runaway global warming, even widespread radiation poisoning seems trivial. And such poisoning is both hypothetical and extremely unlikely to be widespread.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoWe need more than "clean" energy. We need a change in a number of habits. We need actual leadership, and not only gov types. Etc. Nukes are the easy short term way out. The issue is what that means over the long term and how it impacts the other vectors in entity. of this problem. Without a wake up call we'll continue to mindlessly zombie on, as we have been. Nukes __might__ slow that (but only if they don't also create a false sense of overconfidence). However, they're not going to alter the course. They alone are not going to change the end.
- yazr 8y agoHere is the DoE press release https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/southern-company-and-terrapower-prep-testing-molten-salt-reactor https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/southern-company-and-terr... This is a new sodium liquid fuel design. It is NOT the travelling wave reactor, which has been championed by TerraPower for the past 10 years. These are 2 very very different designs which is confusing to me.
- loeg 8y agoThe submitted article seems to be mostly cribbed from the DoE's tweet; this link is much better. dang or sctb, could you update the link to the energy.gov one?
- jabl 8y agoFrom their website, it seems work on the traveling wave concept wound down several years ago (not spelled out explicitly, but lack of updates). I'd guess they figured out the traveling wave concept wasn't workable, and switched to another design.
- DennisP 8y agoAs of last fall, they've partnered with someone in China to build a traveling wave reactor there. https://www.smh.com.au/business/bill-gates-and-china-partner-on-worldfirst-nuclear-technology-20171106-gzfrf0.html https://www.smh.com.au/business/bill-gates-and-china-partner...
- donttrustatoms 8y agoThe link clearly states that this is the MCFR - Molten Chloride Fast Reactor. I think the confusion may lie in that people equate fast reactor with sodium. It's a fast MSR.
- inamberclad 8y agoBy Energy Department, they mean the Department of Energy (DoE), right?
- Aloha 8y agoAccording to the article, yes
- dmix 8y agoWasn't there a YC backed company doing something similar with nuclear a while back?
- acidburnNSA 8y agoThere are like 50 advanced reactor companies out there. But I think the one you're referring to is Oklo. https://www.thirdway.org/infographic/the-advanced-nuclear-industry-2016-update https://www.thirdway.org/infographic/the-advanced-nuclear-in...
- acidburnNSA 8y agoOr possibly Transatomic, which rumor has it has recently shuttered its doors.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoMini-nuclear plants. 1100 megawatts. These are completely in disagreement. Terrapower focuses mostly on large plants to power an increasingly urban world. The media has gotten that Terrapower does small reactors wrong for over a decade.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> 1100 megawatts Isn’t that smaller than the average power plant?
- rgbrenner 8y agothere are 99 nuclear reactors operating in the US, producing about 100,000mw. So about 1000mw/ea. Many of the plants in the US have more than one reactor.. but you can see on this page, plant capacity/units is about 1gw/ea [edit: corrected, thanks], and many of the single reactor plants are about that size also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_largest_nuclear_power_stations_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_largest_nuclear_po... Note, that page has the largest plants.. about ~45. There are only 61 in the US. So there are a few smaller ones not in the list. If you built a 1100mw reactor, it would be ~#42 largest plant.
- taf2 8y agoIsn’t this not about size of energy produced but rather the physical size of the reactor?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- acidburnNSA 8y ago*1 GW each. A small reactor is under a few hundred megawatts. A micro reactor is on the order of tens of megawatts. It's quite hard to make economic reactors below that.
- danschumann 8y agoI heard Bill Gates on a ted talk a long time about talking about some sort of nuclear power that would burn waste and was like a candle. I think this isn't that.. but anyway, it'll be nice if we have excess power.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoThat's the traveling wave reactor which is just a breeder that doesn't need reprocessing. The first will be sodium metal cooled (not salt). This is a fluid fuel reactor that has similar reprocessing reducing goals.
- pfdietz 8y agoTerrapower's reactor uses molten chloride salts, with fuel dissolved in the salt. An issue with this sort of reactor is the entire primary loop becomes loaded with fission products, and becomes intensely radioactive. I prefer the MSR (molten salt reactor) design by Moltex. http://www.moltexenergy.com/ http://www.moltexenergy.com/ Their design also uses molten salt, but contains the fuel-bearing chloride salt inside tubes. A separate, non-fueled salt circulates around the tubes. For reasons of chemistry, this enables them to use a fluoride salt outside the tubes, and unlike homogenous fluoride-based MSRs the reactor structure can be made of stainless steel rather than more exotic (and expensive) nickel-based alloys. It also reduces the volume of chloride needed, which is an important cost savings if the chlorine has to be isotopically separated to reduce production of 36Cl (which has a halflife of 3x10^5 years.) The high cross section of chlorine for thermal neutrons is also why chloride MSRs are necessarily fast reactors. Moltex's design retains the major advantage of MSRs, which is the absence of volatile materials in the containment building. It is the vaporization and pressurization of these materials in an accident which forces the containment to be large and strong.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoFair points. The challenge with fluid in tubes is fuel density. Very hard to get it high enough to be economical. Good old solid nuclear fuel can be upwards of 15 g/cm3.
- iamgopal 8y agoIsn't stainless steel not so resistant to chloride ?
- acidburnNSA 8y agoCorrect. But there's some fancy high-nickel and other stuff that can likely handle it if you control the chemistry carefully.
- jabl 8y agoThe challenge in a traditional MSR design is that you have half the periodic table swimming around in your primary loop at high temperature. From a corrosion perspective that's pretty challenging.
- bayesian_horse 8y agoMy main concern (I'm not a nuclear engineer) is that smaller nuclear plants means lots of radioactive material (fuel/waste) is being moved and stored in a piece-meal fashion, enabling "small scale" accidents or even theft.
- tootie 8y agoI'm sure Uber is working on this.
- brodsky 8y agovery edgy, but this isn't reddit.
- aidenn0 8y agoMost modern designs are specifically designed to not create materials that are easily weaponizable, which reduces the value of them (and thus theft). Accidents are an issue, and what do do with the waste is a huge question that will decide whether or not nuclear plants are economically feasible moving forward.
- basicplus2 8y agoJust because one cant make a nuclear bomb from the material does not mean it cannot be weaponised.. Anything radioactive that can be spread into the food chain is an issue.
- lallysingh 8y agoThere's a lot there that depends on the specifics of the substances. Radioactivity doesn't mean dangerous or weaponizable. Bananas are radioactive. Granite countertops are radioactive.
- bayesian_horse 8y agoI assume they are not fueling nuclear plants with bananas and granite.
- Baal 8y agoWhat could possibly go wrong? Radioactive material everywhere in private hands.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoSmart people like Bill Gates are interested in nuclear because of the low footprint associated with the unbelievably high energy density of nuclear fuel. 1.5 soda cans of the stuff fissioned in a conventional reactor releases enough energy to power an average american's entire life (including transportation, heating, and electricity). The waste created is about 2 soda cans of toxic solid stuff that can be easily, safely, and practically stored in deep crystalline bedrock like the Finns are doing. Other energy sources dump their (more dilute) waste into the air causing lung disease (worldwide fossil fuels are estimated to kill 3 million per year this way) and global warming (death toll still unknown). Intermittent renewables are energy harvesters with free fuel but they require vast swaths of land, concrete, steel, fiberglass, storage, transmission, rare-earths, lithium, etc. etc. Nuclear has tiny land, material, waste, carbon, etc. footprints due to its energy density. The risks associated with radiation are just overblown by almost everyone. Nuclear reactors have net saved 1.8 million lives already, and counting [1]. [1] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es3051197 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es3051197
- Baal 8y agoI see you have never had to desl with radioactive material and activated tools in private companies. It is not a pretty sight. But hey, keep advertising nuclear. How much do they pay you?
- sctb 8y agoCould you please improve your commenting? We're looking for civil and substantive posts that are informative. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ToFab123 8y agoWill this type of reactor produce material that can be used in nuclear bombs and produce waste we will have deal with for millions? Of years. Is it "just" a smaller version of the current types of reactors?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoI've never understood this. If the waste product is radioactive for millions of years then doesn't that mean it's not very radioactive? Wikipedia has this to say: Since radioactive decay follows the half-life rule, the rate of decay is inversely proportional to the duration of decay. In other words, the radiation from a long-lived isotope like iodine-129 will be much less intense than that of a short-lived isotope like iodine-131.¹ So my understanding is radioactive products are dangerous because body takes up the elements and they're either chemically toxic, dangerous because of radioactive decay, or both. So isn't this solved by vitrifying the waste and burying it? Glasses tend to be extremely chemically inert. I'm not convinced the spectre of nuclear waste warrants the paranoia it receives. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Physics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste#Physics
- pfdietz 8y agoMaterial will eventually be decaying in the environment at the same rate it is produced, in steady state. This is independent of the halflife. What a long halflife does is increase the time until that steady state is reached. If we operate a nuclear economy for a million years then a hell of a lot of that long lived isotope will have accumulated.
- DennisP 8y agoThe only waste from molten salt fast reactors is fission products, i.e. atoms that already fissioned. Encase them in glass and they'll be back to the radioactivity of uranium ore in 300 years. We could use these reactors to eat the nuclear waste we have right now.
- Aloha 8y agoI think this is a great idea. That said, this article seems like a puff piece for the DoE under Trump. Nor does the article linked really support the headline either. Consider the source. "When Anschutz first started the Examiner in its daily newspaper format, he envisioned creating a competitor to The Washington Post with a conservative editorial line. According to Politico, "When it came to the editorial page, Anschutz's instructions were explicit—he 'wanted nothing but conservative columns and conservative op-ed writers,' said one former employee." The Examiner's writers have included Michael Barone, Tim Cavanaugh, David Freddoso, Tara Palmeri, Rudy Takala, and Byron York." That said, don't take my word for it, look at their home page (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/ https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/) and judge for yourself.
- foota 8y agoIs part of the benefit to these that the risk can be more accurately calculated and insured against?
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoGood news for Japan if this gets developed successfully. We have a ton of nuclear reactors on some of the most seismically active land on the planet - only a matter of time for another Fukushima.
- baybal2 8y agoI myself is against idea of small scale nuclear. Economics is not of its side. Every single nuclear facility is has a lot of fixed expenses to keep it running. Think of the amount of qualified cadres needed to run it: every nuclear power station is effectively a small science institute on its own. Multi-gigawatt facilities are the ones where nuclear has biggest the payout. The few nuclear power stations that are being completed these days are single reactor designs and effectively experimental plants. This is why digits on economics got unfavourable recently. Fuel costs are negligible in comparison to every other operating expenses. This way, simple PWRs and BWRs on multi-gigawatt scales are the only designs making sense economically. Next gen CANDUs make great sense for fuel economy (and economic costs of refuelling), but even then, frequent refuelling needs are not as dramatic as the higher costs of CANDUs. Heavy water price has only been going up - and even something like an international initiative to setup a global heavy water "bank" will help little. 4th Generation reactors - the first few reactors are assuredly can't run at profit. Their sole purpose are to be research facilities. Any nation constructing them should have full realisation that constructing gen 4 only servers the purpose of advancing its science and industrial competence, not and making money in any immediate future.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Every single nuclear facility is has a lot of fixed expenses to keep it running Counterintuitively, economies of scale are more frequently found in small products which can be mass manufactured than big projects which must be custom built. This isn't an ironclad law. But neither is "nuclear must be big." > the first few reactors are assuredly can't run at profit "Assuredly" based on what? This article is about a commercial reactor project. One of many. Their investors have less of an interest in "advancing [their nations'] science and industrial competence" than in turning a profit.
- baybal2 8y ago>Counterintuitively, economies of scale are more frequently found in small products which can be mass manufactured than big projects which must be custom built. This isn't an ironclad law. But neither is "nuclear must be big." Nuclear power stations are not a mass manufactured product. The most pass produced ones still amount to decade long projects. There are no nuclear reactors that amount to "just add water" replicate designs, and there wouldn't be any in foreseeable future. Just look at small coal firing powerplants, even smallest ones suitable for use in utilities are horrifically inefficient, horrifically expensive per kW/h, and still involve tons of on-site and custom engineering solutions every time. All and every vendor of "turnkey" powerplants market them as such, but just ask any power engineer if it is actually so: coal feed systems have to be optimised for type of coal used, flue solids capture systems have to be customised, foundations have to be custom engineered to accommodate heavy machinery (imagine a turbine shaft of many tonnes to get few mm bend due to soil subduction), and of course the geometry of the plant has to accommodate position of coal storage, flyash storage, transformer sites, administrative buildings and etc. >"Assuredly" based on what? Based to watching nation scale efforts of gen 4 reactor commercialisation failing every time. All of them wanted money from day one, and all were sure that "this time we got it right." >Their investors have less of an interest in "advancing [their nations'] science and industrial competence" than in turning a profit. Given the known level of intellectual ability of a successful finance professional (aka "Pro Investor") in a Western country, this doesn't surprise me at all.
- ksec 8y agoSometimes it fractionates me, how we manage to move from 1 to 1000x the computation power and yet Nuclear technologies seems to move at a very very slow pace. I would also like to know why no one invest in Nuclear Fusion?
- DennisP 8y agoPeople have started investing in fusion. Tokamak Energy and a new company spun out of MIT's fusion program have both gotten tens of millions, for fairly mainstream designs. There are also companies using more speculative designs, the biggest being Tri Alpha, which started in 1999 I think and has about $500 million invested. There's also Helion, which got a modest investment from YCombinator. One reason fission moves slowly in the U.S. is the NRC. A couple years ago I got to sit in a meeting between a bunch of U.S. reactor startups and a former head of the NRC. The reactor people's main complaint was that the NRC required detailed blueprints before it would even look at a design. It would take several hundred million dollars to get to that point, and then the NRC would give a flat yes or no. With a no you were done, and with a yes you still have nothing but a paper reactor. It's a very difficult environment for investors.