7 ms·
I really don’t see the point of recycling. These are the steps I’ve taken to reduce my impact on the planet: eating a plant-based diet, never traveling by plan
by paulcole 8y ago
I really don’t see the point of recycling.
These are the steps I’ve taken to reduce my impact on the planet: eating a plant-based diet, never traveling by plane and only rarely by car (I never learned to drive and the vast majority of my travel during the year is by bicycle, public transit or foot), never having kids, and living in a small apartment.
Does separating my glass and plastic jars really make that much of an additional difference?
- nrb 8y agoI think never traveling beyond a 30-mile radius is more detrimental to society as a whole than an occasional flight. After all, a carbon offset for a round-trip cross-country commercial flight is about $10 which can at least mitigate that impact.
- justinator 8y ago> I think never traveling beyond a 30-mile radius is more detrimental to society as a whole than an occasional flight You know when you travel by plane, you fly over most of the terrain you might have encountered if you took a bicycle? What's more detrimental now? Twain wrote, "Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the earth all one's lifetime." But read his books, and you'll see how he traveled: slowly. > a carbon offset for a round-trip cross-country commercial flight is about $10 You can't buy yourself out of your contribution to CO2 in the air. That $10 doesn't remove anything. It buys piece of mind, and the hope that things in the future may be better. For now, the world keeps warming. There's no capitalistic mechanism invented yet that's going to change that.
- stephengillie 8y agoWalking across the United States is a slightly-uncommon and somewhat historic hobby. It can be done in under 300 days.
- nrb 8y agoI was referring to cultures experienced and perspective gained more than terrain covered. Most people today cannot afford to travel as slowly as he had the great fortune of doing. I agree that a carbon offset doesn't absolve you of responsibility, but like everything in life, it's tradeoffs.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> You can't buy yourself out of your contribution to CO2 in the air. That $10 doesn't remove anything. It buys piece of mind, and the hope that things in the future may be better. For now, the world keeps warming. There's no capitalistic mechanism invented yet that's going to change that. What's so complicated about "tax people that produce CO2, pay people that capture CO2"?
- usaar333 8y ago> After all, a carbon offset for a round-trip cross-country commercial flight is about $10 which can at least mitigate that impact. That uses an offset price of $7/ton, which seems rather low. Otherwise, offsetting the world's emissions would be only about $200b a year (.2% of world economy)
- Dylan16807 8y ago$10 per ticket, not per plane.
- usaar333 8y agoI'm using 1.5 tons/ticket. Source: https://co2.myclimate.org/en/flight_calculators/new https://co2.myclimate.org/en/flight_calculators/new
- Dylan16807 8y agoYou're right, I got the wrong number.
- nrb 8y agoThat site appears to be changing tons per ticket based on flight class to try to capture a higher donation.
- usaar333 8y agoThat's simply because higher classes occupy more space and thus proportionately are responsible for a higher percent of emissions. https://www.myclimate.org/fileadmin/myc/files_myc_perf/12_flight_calculator_documentation_EN.pdf https://www.myclimate.org/fileadmin/myc/files_myc_perf/12_fl...
- nrb 8y agoI pulled that number from http://co2offsets.sustainabletravelinternational.org/ua/offsets http://co2offsets.sustainabletravelinternational.org/ua/offs... which takes into account origin and destination, any additional legs, and month of the year. SFO -> JFK direct round-trip in July for about 0.9 metric tons
- quadrangle 8y agoYour steps go far beyond what most people do. However, the real significance is at the macro level. It's not about what individuals do, it's about the systematic effects. Our system today wouldn't function at all if everyone acted like you (I'm not saying it would be bad! We probably should have a totally different system that would work for far more people living your way). The real issue with consumption and waste-disposal lies with the patterns in the economy that encourage the creation of disposable products in the first place. All that said, recycling can still be positive if done right. ANd separating glass and plastic etc. would be trivial if the producers of goods were set up more to make it as easy as possible.
- cc439 8y agoThere really hasn't been any point to recycling paper, plastic, and glass for quite some time now. Recycling glass hasn't made sense ever since local bottling plants ceased to exist in most cities, removing the system by which they were able to re-use recycled bottles. Recycling paper is obviously no longer a sensible activity given the issues of contamination and lack of economic incentives given just how cheap sustainably harvested wood has become. Plastic, well plastic would make sense if we could ever figure out how to sort all the different types automatically. The re-use of recycled plastic is basically limited to a handful of common product types (plastic bottles that are either HDPE or PET and easily identifiable as such). That said, one should always make an effort to recycle aluminum properly. There's a reason aluminum is often referred to as "solidified electricity" and it's because it takes enormous amounts of energy to extract aluminum from raw ore. Recycling finished aluminum goods cuts out that entire step of the production chain and has an enormous impact on large-scale energy consumption.
- marmadukester39 8y agoWHY cant we just standardize on bottle/cup size/shape? Just use different labels.
- lurquer 8y agoRecycling is a way to profit off of virtue signaling. Why should I separate my trash to make some recycling company more profitable? If they pay me enough, I might do it. Otherwise, it's all going into the landfill. Even aluminum. If some aluminum company wants it bad enough -- and if it's worth enough -- they can go dig it up. I dislike companies making profits on forced labor. Too many virtue-signaling municipalities mandate recycling (and sometimes even charges you for pickup) just so some recycling company can increase its bottom line. Nonsense. Bury everything. It's cheap.
- maxerickson 8y agoWhat's the pejorative term for when you brag that you just don't give a fuck?
- Mediterraneo10 8y ago
- mratzloff 8y agoIt's easy to reclaim glass and aluminum. In my apartment, it's a matter of setting out a bag every week or so.
- mlinksva 8y agoThank you for what you do (and do not). My guess is recycling doesn't make much of an additional difference. There's a reason it's third in reduce-reuse-recycle. I separate out recyclables mostly out of habit (and garbage service bin for recycling is much larger than than one for garbage) but I wonder whether recycling could be a net negative due to moral exhaustion/fatigue/substitution -- surely there is research on this, and I would love pointers to it.
- beerlord 8y agoIf you’re not going to have kids, there will simply be fewer people next generation who will share your concerns about the environment. If you absolutely want to minimize your environmental impact to the extent that you think reproducing is pointless, isn’t the logical end result to immediately commit suicide as well?