4 ms·
Everything helps at this point. Because something helps less shouldn’t mean we bash it. Collectively we should do more. While I don't disagree with your sentim
by reaperducer 8y ago
Everything helps at this point. Because something helps less shouldn’t mean we bash it. Collectively we should do more.
While I don't disagree with your sentiment, the article makes an important point:
Plastic straws are 0.03% of the Great Garbage Patch problem.
Plastic fishing nets are 46% of the GGP problem.
The people pushing the plastic straw bans aren't raising awareness of the big problem (lost and abandoned fishing nets), they're just spreading the notion that plastic is evil.
It's a lazy, self-indulgent kind of activism that is about making the person feel better, not solving a problem.
You want to "raise awareness" of the real problem? Start putting up posters in the seafood departments of supermarkets showing a fishing net stuffed with 20 tons of rotting sea life that's still killing fish 15 years after it floated away from its boat.
- brightball 8y agoWhat would a better net be made out of? Hemp maybe?
- reaperducer 8y agoI don't know much about fishing nets, but cotton seems plentiful, is biodegradable, and there are plenty of poor cotton farmers in need of increased demand for their product. If someone knows what fishing nets were made of before they were made of plastic, please chime in.
- bluedino 8y agoCotton also absorbs water. Most of the problem is that a billion pounds of fishing nets are left in the ocean every year, harming wildlife.
- ams6110 8y agoThey must have been made out of natural fibers originally, but I would imagine a big problem with that would be that they would absorb water and become very heavy.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoCotton requires a lot of water to grow and process.
- chewbacha 8y agoHemp was the original material for fishing rope and nets :)
- cwyers 8y agoI regret that I only have one upvote to give here. This is probably the most perfect, succinct statement of the problem.
- stinos 8y agothey're just spreading the notion that plastic is evil ... not solving a problem Isn't there at least some possibility the former does help the bit with the problem? There's enough uninformed people out there. So while the straws itself aren't going to cut it, in general spreading awareness about plastic and waste in general might just get more people to be more careful. Start putting up posters in the seafood departments of supermarkets showing a fishing net stuffed with 20 tons of rotting sea life that's still killing fish 15 years after it floated away from its boat I'm not sure this would help more than other initiatives. Possibly, but still. In any case it is unfortunately quite non-realistic in this society.
- fauigerzigerk 8y ago>Isn't there at least some possibility the former does help the bit with the problem? I don't think so. These things eventually become public knowledge and the result may well be cynicism, apathy or things like climate change denial. It's important to be honest, rational and effective or the only way to change anything will be scaremongering and bigotry.
- tedunangst 8y agoThe focus on straws would seem to reinforce the notion that the plastic we see is the problem, and the plastic we don't see isn't a problem, with the potential negative outcome that people declare mission accomplished after the straws are gone.
- chewbacha 8y agoSounds like the straw ban got you to do some research and raised your awareness. Seems to be working.
- dnautics 8y agoattention is a limited and rivalrous resource
- fucking_tragedy 8y agoYou're just looking at the garbage patch as if it represents the entirety of the problem. Straws are the 7th most collected item during beach clean ups, after plastic bags and before plastic & foam containers.
- learc83 8y agoAnd what percentage of the total weight or total volume of garbage collected do straws represent?
- njarboe 8y agoInteresting stat. Personal experience? Almost all plastic in the ocean comes from fishing vessels and dumping of garbage into rivers in Asia. It would be interesting to know where those straws come from. All of this plastic discussion recently was due to China banning the importation of plastic from recycling systems in the West. People were made aware of how their plastic recycling was not really working out like they thought and actually was causing harm to other people. Banning plastic straws is like a little penance that we can do to get our psyches back in balance and close that small window that opened in our awareness onto the vast amount of consumption all of us do.
- marcosdumay 8y ago> Straws are the 7th most collected item during beach clean ups So, not even on this count are they relevant?
- fucking_tragedy 8y agoYou aren't even familiar with the statistic and you're willing to paint it as irrelevant?
- intended 8y agoBut that doesn’t work The communication problem is not solved by being exacting. How many people can tell you exactly what’s going on with an algorithm - and how many people will stop their work to listen ? On the other hand, put picture of kittens or unusual scenarios... Mass communication isn’t only about accuracy.
- jstanley 8y agoAlgorithm development isn't only about correctness either, but correctness is usually a necessary condition.
- intended 8y agoThe point being that algo correctness is relevant you are writing code, and communication effectiveness is what you care about when you deal with mass communication.
- chewbacha 8y agoYou want 24,000 metric tons of plastic straws to be in the Pacific Ocean then? Because even 0.03% of 8 million is still a lot of plastic straws. Maybe we can dump them in your backyard then.
- drdeadringer 8y agoWould you prefer the fishnets in your backyard?