2 ms·
Keep in mind a lot of makers, inventors, etc. are not very good at the CEO job. It's probably unlikely that Jony Ive (a truly brilliant designer) would have an
by adventured 8y ago
Keep in mind a lot of makers, inventors, etc. are not very good at the CEO job.
It's probably unlikely that Jony Ive (a truly brilliant designer) would have any business trying to run Apple.
James Dyson, a great maker, isn't the CEO of Dyson (and hasn't been since 2001). He's the chief engineer. (see the nice article below that he wrote describing how he had to bring in outside operators once they hit scale [1])
Neither Nikola Tesla nor Edison demonstrated good skill at running businesses. Musk is not a greater maker than those two.
You don't want John Carmack running id Software's day to day operations, nor do you want Shigeru Miyamoto running Nintendo. At that level, you want to aggressively focus on what you're best at.
Even Henry Ford, who was a decently skilled business operator, was still not the best available option for running the day to day operations of his own company at scale. It's crazy hard to run an extremely large business well, and the level of skill it demands is every bit as rare as the maker-type talent.
I happen to agree with this Bloomberg article. What Musk needs is Alan Mulally or the equivalent (a Gwynne Shotwell if you will; an extremely difficult challenge, given the requirement that the person be compatible with Musk):
https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2018-08-23/how-elon-musk-can-save-tesla-hire-alan-mulally-ford-s-savior https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2018-08-23/how-elon-...
[1] https://www.inc.com/magazine/201203/burt-helm/how-i-did-it-james-dyson.html https://www.inc.com/magazine/201203/burt-helm/how-i-did-it-j...
- pbreit 8y agoElon has a pretty good track record of CEOing SpaceX (12 years) and Tesla (15 years), two of the most impressive and impactful companies of our generation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bdcravens 8y agoTesla has never had a profitable year, yet the company's voting structure requires almost 90% of shareholders outside of Musk to vote to ever oust him. He has even more control of SpaceX, having majority ownership and a super-majority of voting shares. It's virtually impossible to unseat him as CEO, so pointing out that he's CEO doesn't really establish anything about his quality at holding that position.
- pbreit 8y agoThat seems like an odd way to evaluate a CEO. I would evaluate more on what the company is able to achieve (yes, I understand Tesla's lack of profitability).
- tptacek 8y agoThat's a non-sequitur answer. He's refuting your claim that you can evaluate Musk's ability from his tenure at those two companies, because both are structured such that he can retain control regardless of his performance. He's not providing you with a rubric for evaluating CEOs, but rather pointing out how your own rubric is flawed.
- pbreit 8y agoI don't understand. How is his retaining control based on the structure of voting rights related to his job performance?
- bdcravens 8y agoGood question. You're the one that implied he must be a good CEO because he had been one for so long, which is silly if he can't be fired. "Elon has a pretty good track record of CEOing SpaceX (12 years) and Tesla (15 years)"
- pbreit 8y agoI'm saying he's a good CEO because has been a fantastic one for 15+ years at 2 world-changing companies. He's made shareholders 10s of billions of $$ so obviously would not be fired.