3 ms·
> I grew up with a web where labor-of-love personal websites -- often about a deep topic the author was passionate about -- were slowly crowded out in number by
by adventured 8y ago
> I grew up with a web where labor-of-love personal websites -- often about a deep topic the author was passionate about -- were slowly crowded out in number by dynamic blogs...
The labor-of-love deep topic authors came to entirely dominate across the board.
They sit at the top of every single search result, under the Wikipedia.org domain.
They moved from writing in-depth on their personal blogs/sites, to writing epic volumes on a site like Wikipedia instead. A place where that vast glorious compilation of human knowledge can easily be shared with all in a quite friendly non-profit, non-soul-eating sort of way (ie the anti-Facebook sort of way). I don't have to get lucky browsing around or dig for hours to find their obscure topic content there, I just conveniently type words into a search box or click one page to the next. No filtering through tons of trash results or in-result ads on Google to find decent quality content.
- DuskStar 8y agoAnd then other people arrived on Wikipedia and decided that five-page articles on every single character in the Star Wars extended universe (pre-Disney) weren't desirable, and deleted them.
- Joeri 8y agoThis is a real problem for future historians. Prior ages kept records of what they deemed important, but failed to document the mundane, which makes it hard to reconstruct today how people lived back then. The same problem is posed by wikipedia. Some of the content being filtered out as irrelevant may prove important to understanding the flow of history in 500 years. We can’t know today what will be important and what won’t be. That’s why archive.org may be a far more useful compendium of human knowledge than wikipedia.
- droopyEyelids 8y agoYou're reading a different wikipedia than I am. Or describing what you hope it could be? The Wikipedia I read is a collection of sentence fragments that sometimes contradict each other before the period, and the sentences often contradict each other within the paragraph. Then, that confused mix is filtered through an army of agenda based editors. The example of this that killed the joy I found in wikipedia was the Hookah page. My friends and I were smoking a lot of hookah in college, so I decided I wanted to learn more about it. The wikipdeia page was incredibly pro-hookah, and cited various stores that sold hookah equipment. When I researched it fully, I found the WHO did a study that showed hookah smoke contains a tremendous amount of tar, users hold the smoke in their lungs longer, absorbing more tar, and the 'shisha' (tobacco) is actually burned- not "roasted," which is the word hookah promonets use to dissemble. It was completely impossible to get that information onto the page, despite learning tons of wiki culture and really working at it for months. After that I noticed the same thing on a huge quantity of pages. Writing and organizing information is hard. It can't be done well by an unfocused committee of people, even if they care. Add in self-interested saboteurs, and you've got a recipe for disaster.