10 ms·
I heard the same thing about the burnout and turnover. Do companies really think they are saving money by paying peanuts, grinding people down to burnout, and t
by ryandrake 8y ago
I heard the same thing about the burnout and turnover. Do companies really think they are saving money by paying peanuts, grinding people down to burnout, and then constantly having to rehire/retrain new people as the old ones leave? Meanwhile the code is a mess because nobody has been there longer than a year and there is no architecture or design continuity. Just frantic patches over other frantic patches by burnt out junior engineers. It makes no sense!
- gerardnll 8y agoCapitalism. Need for money and results. I don't think that anybody wants to burnout anybody, it's just the pressure of the whole system I guess. Money pushes to do things fast. Shareholders and clients to keep happy.
- watwut 8y agoBurning out people at large rate is not effective and persistent crunch is contraproductie. It is less of capitalism and more of wishfull thinking combined with wish to be seen as tough manager.
- Apocryphon 8y agoI'd say it's the pace in which modern capitalism operates at, particularly in tech. When the rate of production goes higher and higher due to automation and a global outsource-able workforce, the shareholders chase after higher and higher profits.
- T2_t2 8y agoNothing has changed, and ironically, this whole part of the question - is it better to burn people out and rehire - is a capitalist question, and answered with capitalist goals.
- watwut 8y agoTesla can't outsource globaly and does not have profits yet. Effectivity is about whether burnout brings higher profits, not whether people unable to gain them burnout themselves or those under them due to wishful thinking.
- gsnedders 8y agoThe question of course is whether the high turnover actually is the most efficient way—you're spending far more employee time training them (both learning the company's approaches at a high level, the problem space, and their way around the code base) than you would if you had higher retention. While you might need to pay more and improve working conditions, would you be more efficient given the individual staff would spend more time being productive?
- ASalazarMX 8y ago> Shareholders [..] to keep happy. In my opinion, this is the biggest flaw of the system. For many investors, a company is less about what it makes and more like a process to grow their money. Even when a company becomes profitable, there's always pressure to make it even more profitable quarter after quarter.
- ucaetano 8y ago> Even when a company becomes profitable, there's always pressure to make it even more profitable quarter after quarter. Would you keep your retirement funds in a company that doesn't grow?
- reitanqild 8y agoSure, as long as it pays good dividends. Not everything needs to grow into the sky.
- ucaetano 8y agoYou do get the fact that a company with no growth but paying dividends will be worth (including the dividends you extracted) exactly what you paid for? It would be worse than buying a bond: you'll get the risk of equity with the returns of a bond.
- reitanqild 8y agoNot an economist, but I have tried to keep informed and what you say doesn't seem like it should follow. (Then again English is not my first language.)
- s73v3r_ 8y agoI really don't care if they "don't really want to", they're still actively choosing paths that lead to that, and don't really care.
- debt 8y ago“Do companies really think they are saving money“ Well they landed a rocket on a barge in the ocean so something about that model must be working right
- scrollaway 8y agoLooking at what's been done isn't a good way of determining whether your process is efficient at doing said thing. You need to be able to compare it to something else. To put it another way: If your method of writing novels is to hire an infinite amount of monkeys and put them to work on typewriters, you can't say "Something about this model must be working right, I came out of it with the complete works of Shakespeare!" They landed a rocket on a barge in the ocean. Maybe with a better process, they could have done that two years faster, for 1/100th the cost, with no burnout. You don't know, and you can't say the model works right just because there's something to show for it. All you know is that the process is able to eventually land a rocket on a barge. It doesn't tell you whether it's good at it.
- malkia 8y agoOr maybe that is THE SMART THING. Realizing that you need resources to accomplish it, and throwing money would do it for you.
- user5994461 8y agoMonkeys have no salary and no rights. It's more scalable and easier to manage than regular employees. Get a lot of monkeys and put them at work. They will produce something. Better have something than have nothing.
- malkia 8y agoThat's a bit like trying to use Apple ][ machines for cloud business.
- 8y ago
- api 8y agoI think it's a case of what is seen vs. what is unseen combined with "you get what you measure." "We're paying more for programmers than almost anyone else in the industry!" is an obvious thing a bean counter would notice and point out. Productivity is harder to measure, and all that time lost to training on the job doesn't immediately leap out in spreadsheets because it's blended with actual work.
- tuba_man 8y ago> "We're paying more for programmers than almost anyone else in the industry!" I can't speak to development specifically, but I looked into one of Tesla's devops offerings and I make slightly more for a mid-level engineer than they offer for a senior position. I also 'only' work 40-hour weeks and my cost of living is about 20-30% lower than there.
- pishpash 8y agoThis is a real problem. But if burndown charts can be translated into dollars, this might be noticeable.
- Amygaz 8y agoIt can and it has been for academic reasons. But no employer tracks that, not even in academia... I can’t find the reference I’m looking for, but cost associated with turn over rate due to narcissists is apparently as high as taking care is ASD. I would imagine turn over rate associated with burnouts not due to narcissism, but simply poor & short term management & vision to be at least on par.
- mcny 8y agoAcademia is the worst offendor when it comes to overworking junior people like teaching assistants...
- bradleyjg 8y agoDoes paying peanuts here mean—not very top of market? Or?
- swyx 8y agoi assume it means an above median annual salary but a very poor hourly rate. usually these discussions omit a calculation of to what extent the engineers took the job knowing this already and still decided to do so of their own free will, and how much is... not so voluntary.
- saghm 8y agoI think it's the converse of the idiom "working for peanuts", which means to make a relatively small salary (see https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/work+for+peanuts https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/work+for+peanuts)
- bradleyjg 8y agoYes, but I don’t think that’s accurate in this case. Unless the “relatively” part is crafted to be an unreasonably narrow comparison group.
- mrep 8y agoTrue. From blind, I think it matches average startup pay. However, that does not account for the fact that most people work very long hours. My brother started off with 80 hours weeks and then came down to 60 hour weeks when he got into his groove at tesla. So when you account for that, it is 33% below average startup pay (assuming other companies are doing 40) which itself is below big tech pay.
- bradleyjg 8y agoI don’t think other companies are doing 40. In fact, I don’t know anyone making six figures that does 40. (I’m not saying no such jobs exist, just that no one I know works in one of them. If other high end software jobs are paying the same for 45-50 that Tesla is paying for 60, that’s on the low side hourly, but the low side of the high end. 75% (45/60) of 150k is still $112.5k plus presumably good benefits and some sort of equity component. That’s damn fine compensation for someone fresh out of undergrad even in 2018. I wouldn’t want to work 60 indefinitely even for great pay, but that’s a separate issue.