10 ms·
The Age That Women Have Babies: How a Gap Divides America
- YinglingLight 8y agoPersonally, I'm investing in fertility companies/pharmaceuticals.
- EGreg 8y agoI didn’t downvote you. I think this is a relevant comment. What companies have you invested in and aren’t you worried about overpopulation?
- cimmanom 8y agoMost people who get fertility treatments are struggling to have one child, or at most a second - which is still below replacement rate. Fertility treatments for people who waited too long to have kids isn't going to contribute to overpopulation. In fact, if anything, by making it more viable to wait to have children until later in life, and thus increasing the age of first reproduction relative to lifespan (i.e. slowing the reproductive cycle), fertility treatments could contribute to a slowing of population growth.
- YinglingLight 8y agoWhen women get educated in a country, the 'overpopulation threat' becomes a comedic punchline in said country. Every. time.
- beat 8y agoOverpopulation isn't an actual problem. The rate of new births has been steady for decades now, and will remain steady into the foreseeable future. There are about 2 billion children in the world now; the UN expects there will be about 2 billion children in 2100. The population growth we're seeing today is a result of increased life expectancy, not increased birth rate, and it will flatten out in a few decades. High birth rates are a product of extreme poverty, where child mortality is a problem. It doesn't take a lot of wealth for a country to solve most of the basic child killers (sanitation and access to clean water, vaccination, and most importantly, mothers who can read). And the extreme poverty rate is plummeting - from 29% in the 1990s to just 9% today. Fertility treatments are a luxury, something that only the wealthiest tenth or so of the world can even afford. It's for people who are struggling to have one child, not trying to get their fifth.
- dudul 8y agoAren't studies predicting that Africa is gonna double in population size over the next 50 years? Are they anticipating massive depopulation of some countries/continents to even it out then?
- pitaj 8y agoIt wouldn't be overpopulated, even if that happened. It would take orders of magnitude of population growth to overpopulate the Earth.
- dudul 8y agoI wasn't talking about the idea of overpopulation. I was surprised to see that the total count of kids was predicted to be so stable, while at the same time we're expecting ~1 billion more people in Africa.
- beat 8y agoYou have to think about the math in terms of generations. It takes a couple of generations for the processes that reduce child mortality rates and increase adult lifespans to take hold. So there's a boom generation that will be much larger and live much longer than originally expected. As the life expectancy changes from 50 to 70, that's a lot more people - people born a half-century earlier.
- EGreg 8y agoJust because the rate of growth is declining doesn’t mean the absolute numbers - when extrapolated out - won’t exceed some given threshold. You need to be more specific with your numbers.
- mirimir 8y agoI guess that depends on how one defines "overpopulated". As it is, total biomass of livestock exceeds that of all wild mammals. Certainly, if we were clever enough, we could have a world with very little biodiversity. Basically, just humans, livestock, pets, managed trees and food crops, and associated pests. But that would arguably be a tragedy. And it would be extremely fragile, and prone to disasterous collapse.
- bobmarley1 8y agoMalthusian overpopulation stopped being a serious scientific theory years ago. https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_on_global_population_growth https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_on_global_population_...
- overkalix 8y ago> And if, but only if, we invest in the right green technology Key sentence of the presentation. Population overshoot is a fact.
- akshayB 8y ago2008 financial collapse showed how important it is to have a career and also showed how important it is for women to get educated and move forward as contributors in household finances. There are lot of other factors at play here like student loans, financial independence and 4-6 year time frame to get college degree.
- duxup 8y agoIt's unfortunate, because I loved having my wife at home, and hell I'd be happy to stay home.... but it's just financially too risky IMO. The big catch is insurance in the US... and that really pisses me off that it such a big deal. Also FMLA is kinda wonky in the us. I worked for a company based in CA... CA employees got paid on FMLA, I (being outside of CA) did not :P
- exotree 8y agoRecently married and thinking about kids soon. One of use would love to stay home. However, the risk of putting all earning power in one person seems too great, and neither of us have a deep interest in paying for childcare. So no kids for now.
- Someone1234 8y agoMy wife is a public school teacher with a masters degree, the pay is so low and cost of child care so high, that we would have almost broken even having her go back to work. I agree it is higher risk having only one wage earner, but sometimes it makes financial sense, and it definitely can have developmental benefits (e.g. 1:1 ratio instead of 1:6 or 1:8). I would suggest that if anyone does do stay-at-home, that when the kid has all of their shots, you send them to a play group or preschool so they can learn to socialize. PS - We also had kids fairly late, so got all our student loans paid off, and saved a little money which has helped as a buffer.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lainga 8y agoIn the map of motherhood ages for married, college-educated women, there seems to be a band stretching from El Paso, through OK and KY, and ending in West Virginia, where the average age is much lower. It's strongest around the Oklahoma-Arkansas border. Is there a name for this region? It doesn't look like it coincides with any of the "belts" I am familiar with (Bible belt, Rust belt, Black belt, ...)
- angersock 8y agoBaby belt?
- Domenic_S 8y agoI see a map for married women, and one for college educated women, but not one for both. Which one are you looking at?
- lainga 8y agoYou're right, I thought it was by 2 categories. It's just for married women.
- danielvf 8y agoWhat you are seeing is what's left of the Bible belt when you subtract out the heavily African American regions out. http://www.censusscope.org/us/map_nhblack.html http://www.censusscope.org/us/map_nhblack.html That's my big gripe with the NYT article and charts - these would be considerably more informative if they were also broken down by race. As it is, the real story is incredibly blurred.
- mcny 8y agoIf you live in the US, you should seriously consider not having children at all. Personally, I favor a one child policy should the Medicare for all plan fail to gain traction. Under my one child policy, we will drastically cut social services for all children born after a cutoff year and focus the freed up resources on a first child for any given mother. You're on your own for any child after the first child but I imagine the freed up resources will be enough to cover basic healthcare and education for the first™ child. I originally thought natural twins would be exempt but I've decided against it. Only one (live birth) child per mother. With infant mortality rate at under eight per thousand, there is also no need for a "second chance" exception. This is my modest proposal. If the government can't even support this, I dont know what to say other than to say that everyone must stop having children altogether. Refuse to have any children until the society agrees to pay it's fair share of raising a child.
- angersock 8y agoThey pay that with taxes. Taxes come from citizens. Citizens come from babies. If you don't have kids, you don't create taxpayers, and then society can't pay.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mcny 8y ago> If you don't have kids, you don't create taxpayers, and then society can't pay. I don't for one second believe that we don't have the funds. This isn't about money. This is about priorities. What do we prioritize as a society?
- Someone1234 8y agoThis would cause a significant population decline. US population growth is largely being propped up by immigration, with a one child policy (i.e. 2x parents down to 1x child) it is unlikely that immigration could maintain the current population levels. China implemented One Child because they needed population decline or to slow population growth. But even China has now largely scrapped it. > You're on your own for any child after the first child To phase this more accurately, the second CHILD is on their own. The first child, under your scheme, is educated and receives health benefits. The second child will receive no education and will have to suffer from any health ailments that they receive.
- beat 8y agoI'm currently reading Factfulness, and now I cringe whenever I see the word "gap" used in headlines like this. edit: Getting downvoted for this tells me that not enough people here are reading Factfulness. Everyone who has read it knows what I'm talking about.
- tyleraldrich 8y agoYou're getting downvoted because it seems like you're plugging a book and didn't actually say why you cringe at the word "gap" - your comment is pointless and contributes nothing.
- vixen99 8y agoPlugging or mentioning? Anyway I didn't know about this book and now I do so said comment isn't pointless. No need for the unpleasant tone.
- tyleraldrich 8y agoI guess pointless depends on what you're reading the comment section for - I'd put you in the minority if you came here looking for book suggestions. It's certainly unrelated to the article, and the OP didn't understand why they received downvotes, so I believe my explanation was sufficient.
- beat 8y agoOr arguably, your explanation was at least as pointless as the original. And it is absolutely related to the article. The very concept and terminology of "gap" is the first thing Rosling critiques in Factfulness, as a faulty way of thinking that misleads us and keeps us from seeing the truth about the state of the world.
- jobigoud 8y agoDo you see the valley in the histogram?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI attended college part-time and intermittently while my kids were somewhat young. My first full-time job at age 41 was a corporate job that paid above minimum wage. (I have been told that expecting better than minimum wage when starting work so late in life is crazy talk. So I think I did well.) I think the US desperately needs a "mommy track" for college that encourages women with young kids to go to school part-time and take 6 to 8 years to complete their degree. I think this would solve a lot of problems. Waiting too long to have kids can involve problems for both mother and child. (Among other things) An older mom can require fertility treatments to get pregnant at all and there is higher risk of certain birth defects in the child. Historically, we resolved these conflicts by having women have babies young, but with a financially established husband who was typically older. Now, that is decried as evil patriarchy. I'm well aware of the downside of having kids young and being a homemaker a long time. I'm divorced after having been a homemaker and full-time mom for a lot of years. But my problems were compounded by various factors. I'm quite confident that one of the smartest things I did was go to school when I could. I have thought for years that we should foster young moms pursuing their education. But I have no idea at all how to start such a movement, for lack of a better word.
- wgerard 8y ago> I think the US desperately needs a "mommy track" for college that encourages women with young kids to go to school part-time and take 6 to 8 years to complete their degree. I think this would solve a lot of problems. I'm actually surprised this isn't a thing already - my university certainly allowed part-time students who could still work towards a degree. That being said, I think financial aid was also tied into being a full-time student so I immediately see the drawbacks of that.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSome financial aid is available for taking 2 classes, which is defined as part-time. And we could create financial aid specifically for a mommy track. A bigger issue in my mind is the relatively high cost of classes. In places with low college costs for 2 year colleges, the tuition is potentially payable out of pocket. It would be possible to design systems where we give more welfare benefits if you attend college. As education goes up, women have fewer kids. I think encouraging welfare moms to get an education would help deter them from having large families, which is one if the things that compounds their problems and keeps them stuck in poverty. I originally wanted three kids. I ultimately opted to stop at two. The fact that I am educated is likely a factor in that decision.
- klenwell 8y agoEconomics are an obvious factor in explaining the gap. So are cultural attitudes towards sex. This New Yorker article from 2008 digs into the political/cultural factors behind it: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2008/11/03/red-sex-blue-sex https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2008/11/03/red-sex-blue-s... Some of these differences in sexual behavior come down to class and education. Regnerus and Carbone and Cahn all see a new and distinct “middle-class morality” taking shape among economically and socially advantaged families who are not social conservatives. In Regnerus’s survey, the teen-agers who espouse this new morality are tolerant of premarital sex (and of contraception and abortion) but are themselves cautious about pursuing it. Regnerus writes, “They are interested in remaining free from the burden of teenage pregnancy and the sorrows and embarrassments of sexually transmitted diseases. They perceive a bright future for themselves, one with college, advanced degrees, a career, and a family. Simply put, too much seems at stake. Sexual intercourse is not worth the risks.” These are the kids who tend to score high on measures of “strategic orientation”—how analytical, methodical, and fact-seeking they are when making decisions. Because these teen-agers see abstinence as unrealistic, they are not opposed in principle to sex before marriage—just careful about it. Accordingly, they might delay intercourse in favor of oral sex, not because they cherish the idea of remaining “technical virgins” but because they assess it as a safer option.
- jobigoud 8y agoThese may explain the range but the not really the gap.
- sunseb 8y agoWe are 7.6 billion people - who want a job, a house, a car, that eat meat, that want to travel the world. It's a zero sum game. I think it's a good thing that people have less babies. (I am 33 years old, I am in a relationship, we don't want kids, and it's ok, you can contribute to the world without having kids.)
- frockington 8y agoIt's not a zero sum gain economically. The amount of wealth in the world is constantly increasing
- Denzel 8y agoPlease explain to me how anything you said leads to the conclusion "it's a zero sum game". Literally, nothing of what you said even supports that conclusion. I fear you don't understand what zero sum means or rather you don't understand why it wouldn't apply in this case.
- sunseb 8y agoYes, that was a bad analogy, sorry. What I wanted to say really: overpopulation is at the root of all the planet's troubles. For example, "There’s a strong chance a third of all people on earth will be African by 2100": https://qz.com/africa/1099546/population-growth-africans-will-be-a-third-of-all-people-on-earth-by-2100/ https://qz.com/africa/1099546/population-growth-africans-wil... What could go wrong ?
- Denzel 8y agoSure that's less hyperbolic and more reasonable. And I can appreciate how someone can arrive to the conclusion that overpopulation represents a significant problem. Thanks for updating your wording.
- beat 8y agoYou seem to be assuming that lines of growth continue in one direction forever. They do not. In 1900, the population of Sweden was about 5M, and the birth rate was 4.02 (which was already falling from its historic average of around 5.0). In the 19th century, 20% of the population fled to the US to escape famine. Today, the population is around 10M, and the birth rate is 1.79. Sweden was pretty typical of Europe, pre-WWI. Would you have said "What could go wrong?" when talking about Europe's birth rate and population growth a century ago? No? Then why be afraid of the same pattern in Africa? Population growth today is mostly a function of increased life expectancy and drastically reduced child mortality rates. Low child mortality has led to reduced birth rates everywhere, to the point where most industrialized nations have negative growth (discounting immigration). The birth rate has already leveled off globally. It will level off in Africa, too, and the population will stabilize. A century from now, Africa will have zero population growth.
- dzdt 8y agoIts amazing to me that the distribution of first time motherhood age is bimodal. Are we really at the point where the college track is so far seperated? I would have expected enough in-between variations to keep the distribution single-humped. This makes me worried about the implications. There ought to be middle tracks, to have kids and a career without putting one aside so long or to such a great extent.
- zaroth 8y agoRaising kids takes an infinite amount of time and resources. Or to put it another way, the ROI of investing additional time into raising your children remains high as you go from spending 5 minutes a day up to 1,000 minutes a day. So I think it’s natural and beneficial that parents try to invest the maximum amount of time into their children as physically possible, and career will come second to that. I’m not at all saying the choice shouldn’t be available to work and raise children, or passing any moral judgement on families who take that path. Just that it doesn’t surprise me that a lot of people decide they will focus on one or the other and not try to do both. Advancing in a career and parenting a child are both extremely onerous (and rewarding) tasks. There are only 24 hours in a day, and in both employment and parenthood you are “competing” against other people who are 100% committed to one or the other. Speaking for myself as a 36 year old male, the number of hours I work is probably 50% what it was before I had my two children. I used to be the #1 contributor at my job, no task couldn’t be done, no customer couldn’t be blown away, no deal couldn’t be closed through mastery and shear force of will. Now my priorities have shifted. That level of focus and exertion simply isn’t possible anymore with the number of hours a day I spend with the kids.
- jsonne 8y agoI like most of what you're saying, however, I would propose this. For kids, at a certain point, more interaction becomes detrimental. As an impending father, who will likely be the primary caretaker, I want them to spend a significant portion of time without my help so they learn and grow and can problem solve from an early age. Obviously not abandoning them or something so extreme, but letting them be creative and become their own person. As an aside, I think this all in parenting attitude some people, not saying you necessarily, have is what pushes people to have children later (if at all).
- jawns 8y agoOne of the other interesting implications of this gap, which is mostly attributable to education, is that it leads to far more income inequality, which in turn leads to a host of nasty problems. For instance, as the divide between the haves and the have-nots becomes wider, it becomes harder to change one's station in life, leading to cycles of poverty. In previous generations, people were more likely to marry outside of their education level and their family's economic class. So you might get a solidly middle-class, white-collar guy marrying a woman from a working-class family who never went to college, and they lived off one income. But nowadays, it is much more likely that both spouses work, and also that people marry within their own class and education level. So, in general, you get either two low-income earners, two middle-income earners, or two high-income earners. That greatly widens the household income gap, because now you're dealing with a combination of two incomes of roughly the same degree. And so it becomes much harder for people to make changes to their economic status, because dual-income households are the norm, and if both spouses have to work, they have less time and opportunity, particularly at the lower end, to do things (like earn a degree) that might help them improve their economic status.
- nugget 8y agoThis is sometimes referred to as "assortive mating". In the 1970s, a male executive was more likely to marry his secretary and a male doctor was more likely to marry a nurse, and nobody would think that unusual. Culturally we have shifted away from those norms and nowadays the executive marries another executive or white collar professional and the doctor marries another doctor. This reinforces inequality in many ways (income, culture, parental education and involvement.) There don't seem to be any clear answers for how to address the implications of this trend.
- watwut 8y agoSecretary and nurse were pretty high far enough for women and neither could progress much further. Isn't it then still educated men marrying educated women relative to gender possibilities? The different seem to be only that women had lower level of education in general. A men at that time would only rarely marry up.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aj7 8y agoRemarkably, the green areas [older first births] track America’s progressive strongholds perfectly. Theories?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Remarkably, the green areas [older first births] track America’s progressive strongholds perfectly. Theories? The article points out the factor that is a near complete explanation: education.
- someguydave 8y agoDual-income households in expensive cost-of-living areas.
- DanielleMolloy 8y agoIdeological indoctrination aside, it may suprise some people here that the german GDR had 92% working women, many of them in technical and scientific fields and many having three children. One of the things they did right here is offering proper childcare widely around typical work time windows. The society and often husbands too felt responsible for children, it was not seen as "a mother's thing" like many in this thread seem to do. This has implications up until today, with several prominent and well-educated female politicians and public figures being GDR-born. It was not all perfect (housework and childcare was implicitly still seen as a mother's thing, mothers could request special housework days, sometimes questionable things like full-week kindergardens and so on), but much better than what young people face today when moving to west-german states (where the jobs for educated people can be found) where old-fashioned mindsets and kindergardens closing at 4pm and at random full days throughout the month persist. A single generation of children born among both men and women working in decent jobs did this. Angela Merkel is one of these GDR children, she studied physics and has a PhD in quantum chemistry. She is childless, but her mother - despite being very old now - is still teaching English because she has never stopped being passionate about her chosen profession (I know an interview where Merkel says that her mothers work attitude always inspired her). Well, she never had to throw her education away because society or her husband expected it either. Another well-known politician I can think of here is Sarah Wagenknecht. Peter Scholze who just won the Fields medal was born in Dresden (growing up in Berlin) - his father is a physicist and his mother is a computer scientist working as network technician.
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoIncidentally the GDR also had an extremely high divorce rate. I never saw an adequate explanation of the reasons for this. http://www.history.ucsb.edu/faculty/marcuse/classes/133p/133p04papers/CSmithEGermWomen046.htm http://www.history.ucsb.edu/faculty/marcuse/classes/133p/133...
- DanielleMolloy 8y agoThis can be attributed to people who work themselves being independent from a potentially abusive person's income; and to widely spread atheism, much more than in most European states (currently still 50% atheists (approximately, depending on the survey)).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]