9 ms·
There is no way that we are "alone" in a universe estimated to have practically infinite planets. However, the distances between stars and the very short windo
by Razengan 8y ago
There is no way that we are "alone" in a universe estimated to have practically infinite planets.
However, the distances between stars and the very short windows of time in which life may thrive (remember that we may have never known about the dinosaurs on our very own planet if we didn't discover their bones, and we will never see them again) means that we may never meet any other life.
- metalliqaz 8y agoIt's certainly possible if the probability of developing intelligent life is Infinitesimal.
- Razengan 8y agoWe don't know all the forms that "life" or "intelligence" can take. We certainly do not have any proof that it's impossible for life to be different from us, and we're already in the process of creating intelligence that's different from ours. Our understanding of where life can thrive still gets challenged by discoveries on our own planet, or the experiments in our own labs, like the one on metal-based "cells" [0] that I read about recently. [0] https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20906-life-like-cells-are-made-of-metal/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20906-life-like-cells...
- zimablue 8y agoYour basic argument is just not solid, sorry. You're pointing out that one variable in the Drake equation is large and admitting that we literally have __no clue__ about several others. No clue means no clue, we don't know the mechanism by which they happened. They could under present knowledge turn out to be precisely as small as space is big, or even smaller. The "space is big argument" is not good but hopefully it leads you down the rabbit hole of more interesting arguments. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation
- Razengan 8y agoHonestly, the Drake Equation, Fermi Paradox etc. feel like "One-eyed kings in the land of the blind" type of reasoning. The "otherwise we should have met someone by now" is an absurdly weak criteria, given the distances and timelines involved. –––– We know that life and intelligence are possible and that there are plenty of places for them to occur on: We know the universe must be practically infinite. [0] We know there must be practically infinite planets (here "infinite" being a substitute for trillions upon trillions.) [1] multiplied by [0] We know that even lifeforms on the same planet may never come into contact with each other. [2] We know that intelligent lifeforms can decide to leave other intelligent lifeforms alone. [3] We know life can take forms that do not occur naturally on Earth. [4][5][6] We know intelligence can take forms that do not resemble human intelligence. [7] We know that lifeforms do not require humanoid bodies to be able to use tools. [8] We know we don't have the technology necessary to conclusively detect life at distances beyond 2-3 planets adjacent to our own. We know we don't have the technology necessary to disprove life – present or past – on other planets. There is more evidence to support extraterrestrial intelligence than there is to infer that this is the only planet to harbor intelligent life. –––– [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milky_Way https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milky_Way [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinosaur https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinosaur [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncontacted_peoples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncontacted_peoples [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetical_types_of_biochemi... [5] https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20906-life-like-cells-are-made-of-metal/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20906-life-like-cells... [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_organism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_organism [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_intelligence [8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octopus#Intelligence
- xamuel 8y agoTerms like "practically infinite" are meaningless (my finger is practically infinite from an atomic perspective). We don't strictly "know" hardly anything about our universe, rather we have certain models which make predictions which have so-far not been falsified. Drake equation, Fermi paradox, etc., fall under the umbrella of philosophical speculation. They aren't proper science until they make concrete predictions that we can test experimentally.
- mihaifm 8y agoThis is a very optimistic view, but there are plenty of theories claiming otherwise. Check out the Fermi Paradox [1], or the Rare Earth Hypothesis [2] for a more detailed view on the problem. To be honest the easiest explanation for the Fermi Paradox is that we are indeed alone as an inteligent civilization. If we were just an average civilization there should be plenty of evidence of more advanced civilizations across the galaxy, because probabilistically they would be millions of years more advanced than us. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_Earth_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_Earth_hypothesis
- Razengan 8y agoHonest question: Do we have the means to detect conclusive evidence of life on Earth itself from even "only" as far as, say, Pluto, without knowing exactly what to look for?
- adrianN 8y agoYou'd be able to detect radio waves from Earth. We can still communicate with the Voyager probes that are further out. We probably can't detect life on Earth from Alpha Centauri with our current technology.
- Razengan 8y ago> We can still communicate with the Voyager probes that are further out. This is what I mean by "knowing exactly what to look for." Can we place something at Pluto and have it listen to radio waves from the direction of Earth, and compare it to the background "noise" at that location? How different is it? How much of that perceived difference would be our own bias? How much evidence about life on Earth is available to our own instruments from this range? -> https://www.bing.com/images/search?q=Pale+Blue+Dot https://www.bing.com/images/search?q=Pale+Blue+Dot
- simonh 8y ago
- babuskov 8y ago> There is no way that we are "alone" in a universe estimated to have practically infinite planets. Maybe there is a lot of space out there, but not enough time? Maybe the universe is still pretty young and it takes a lot of time to go from zero to intelligent life that knows how to contact each other over great distances.
- Razengan 8y ago> but not enough time? Or too much time, between different epochs even on the same planet. We are intelligent. We know dinosaurs existed. They stood where we stand. We cannot contact them, we will never touch them, and we will never fully learn about them, nor they us.
- senorjazz 8y agoMaybe each galaxial species is given the perfect planet for them. Distance to other life is so great to avoid one planet species from destroying another. Which considering the appalling job we are doing of caring for our home planet is a good thing. Because if humanity ever finds another species, our track record is pretty abysmal. God only help them if their planet contains a resource we covet
- Will_Parker 8y ago> There is no way that we are "alone" in a universe estimated to have practically infinite planets. What if we are a random sample of conscious life in the space of all possible universes in a multiverse? Many of them will have intelligent life in many places, but the majority have the parameters just tweaked enough to touch the edge and only produce one. Couldn't we live in one of those? (And there is near certainty a given tuning of the parameters produces none but obviously we can't be in one of those.)
- magduf 8y agoThis is exactly why we need to invent a device that allows us to travel, or "slide", between alternate universes.
- simonh 8y agoIf only one in a thousand stars have planets that can support life, only a thousandth of them develop complex life, only a thousandth of them avoid extinction events, only a thousandth of them develop technology, only a thousandth of them avoid destroying themselves somehow. That would give us about one civilisation in every 10,000 galaxies. There are actually a lot more possible stages than that too, I've seen estimates that reasonably put our existence in the observable universe at all as a low probability event and maybe they're right. I've swung either way over the decades. There is a reasonable case that long term technological civilizations might be extremely rare. It's not a foregone conclusion that we are one of many. Personally, I have no idea. It could go either way, but the Fermi Paradox does tend to indicate in the pessimistic direction at least with regard to our own galaxy. The problem is once you say technological life is rare at the one galaxy level, it only takes a few extra stages and a few extra low probability multipliers to make any life anywhere pretty unlikely.
- FireBeyond 8y agoYou leave out the time dimension. The universe is what, just under 14 billion years old, and intelligent life on earth that can meaningfully seek out such things is what, 100 years? That's another remarkably small window in time for us to discover anything - what if a civilization died out a million years ago?
- Razengan 8y ago> You leave out the time dimension. What if a civilization died out a million years ago? This is what I keep bringing up when referring to dinosaurs, and I'm surprised that this point doesn't get presented more often when considering the chances of encountering life on other planets: We have proof right here that life on the same planet can be separated by time and never contact each other, without even bringing cosmic distances into the equation.
- simonh 8y agoYou’re talking as though the dinosaurs and us are deparate life though. We are descendants of the dinosaurs - were the same life.
- csomar 8y ago> There is no way that we are "alone" in a universe estimated to have practically infinite planets. That's very frightening on its own. Assuming the universe is practically infinite, there is another identically similar earth in this universe where another guy that has the same microscopic details as me writing this comment.
- mabbo 8y agoThe problem is that humans, you and me included, are very bad at extremely large and extremely small numbers. We don't have infinite planets. We have 10^21 stars, roughly, and some constant P average planets per star. If the odds of life are 10^-14 per planet, and the odds of intelligent life are 10^-7 per life hosting planet, and we presume every star has one planet that might support life, then in the 10^21 stars in the universe, we'd expect only one intelligent life. That is one possibility! But we simply don't know what the odds of life and the odds of intelligent life are in the slightest. We don't even know what range of possible values are reasonable. And humans are so bad at contemplating numbers like 10^21 and 10^-14. They're too extreme for one to think of them rationally. And saying "well, it happened here, be it must be common" is selection bias- we can only contemplate the problem because it happened here. The right answer is to get more information to improve our estimates of the probabilities. If we can find life at Alpha Centauri, that would either be a hell of a coincidence, or a very good indicator that the probability of life given a planet is high.
- Razengan 8y ago> If we can find life at Alpha Centauri, that would either be a hell of a coincidence, or a very good indicator that the probability of life given a planet is high. Why would finding life on just one more planet – out of the 195 or so "worlds" that we know about, including moons – suddenly make "the probability of life given a planet" high? By your own reasoning, whether we find life at Alpha Centauri, or do not find any life there, will not really change the probability of discovering future life or intelligence among the rest of all the 10^21 * P planets. We could always just keep saying that "There are only 2 planets in the universe with life. No more." "There are only 5 planets in the universe with life." and so on and on.
- mabbo 8y ago> Why would finding life on just one more planet – out of the 195 or so "worlds" that we know about, including moons – suddenly make "the probability of life given a planet" high? Because sampling. It's like election polling. If you ask one person who they're going to vote for and they say "Candidate A", you really have no idea how likely it is that candidate A has massive support. Perhaps you just happened to find the only person voting for that candidate! But if you ask the next random person and they say the same thing, well, the odds that you found the only two people voting for candidate A in your first two random asks is very low. On the other hand, if the second person is not supporting candidate A, that also helps you get a better guess at support levels. You can never know the true level without asking every single person, but with every additional piece of data you can better estimate just what the truth is. Just the same, as soon as we find another star with life, the number of stars we had to search to find that second one gives us a fantastic start to coming up with an estimate on how common life is. We presume that our corner of the universe is a good sampling of the rest, and extrapolate based on what we know here. The key point is that extrapolation from a single data point is wildly innacurate.