6 ms·
I can think of two theories: 1. It's a mistake. Someone in legal got carried away. 2. The performance of the L1TF mitigation is so awful that someone at Inte
by amluto 8y ago
I can think of two theories:
1. It's a mistake. Someone in legal got carried away.
2. The performance of the L1TF mitigation is so awful that someone at Intel thought it would be a good idea to try to keep the performance secret.
(Which leads to option 2b. The performance of the L1TF mitigation is so awful that somemone at Intel is afraid that Intel could be sued as a result, and they want to mitigate that risk.)
I would guess it's #1.
- phyller 8y agoNormally I'd give people the benefit of the doubt, but in this case I think Intel has already shown that they have no credibility in anything anymore. They only ever spin everything, the last time anyone said something truthful (former CEO mentioned they needed to try to limit AMD to 20% server share, up from less than 1%), he was not only fired but publicly humiliated.
- kbumsik 8y agoI think it's #1 but this legal change has been more than 2 weeks and there's no response from Intel in this problem. I don't understand why Intel is screwing everything lately.
- djsumdog 8y agoThe wording sounds like it bans any and all benchmarks. How would groups like Linus or Dave2D even operate? It honestly doesn't seem remotely enforceable.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoIt works for Oracle (it is famously illegal to publish benchmarks of DB2 vs other engines), I'm sure intel can make it work for them thanks to Oracle's court case(s).
- jclulow 8y agoI'm pretty sure DB2 is an IBM thing.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoYou're right, it is, I had the wrong DB name.
- laumars 8y agoDB2 is IBM. The court case you were on about was Oracle's RDBMS called Oracle RDBMS. However I believe DB2 might have been used as one of the comparisons against Oracle. Anyhow, specifics aside, you do make a good point.
- TheRealPomax 8y agooops, yeah it would help if I got the names right.
- mping 8y agoI believe you are referring to the DeWitt clause.
- throwaway77384 8y agoSo is the below technically illegal? http://phpdao.com/mysql_postgres_oracle_mssql/ http://phpdao.com/mysql_postgres_oracle_mssql/
- gambiting 8y agoI think OP is using the wrong term - breaching terms of contract is not illegal in itself. It just means Oracle will not do any more business with you.
- Rjevski 8y ago> Oracle will not do any more business with you Isn't that a blessing?
- throwaway77384 8y agomakes sense. so unless they dedicated the resources to figuring out who did it, etc. it's reasonably moot.
- sekh60 8y agoSo what you're saying is that sysadmins should all benchmark Oracle products to prevent their employers from being trapped in Oracle land?
- TheRealPomax 8y agoBreaching terms of contract is most definitely illegal and Oracle can sue any time they want. It's not like trademark law, where you _have_ to sue even if you don't want to; Oracle can ignore anything that comes out not looking bad for them, which still being 100% able to sue the pants off of anyone that goes "hey look this product is worse across the board in real world comparisons to MySQL and MariaDB".
- Dylan16807 8y agoThey can sue but it's not illegal, and they very well may not be able to get any money from you for truthful statements.
- cm2187 8y agoBut you can't buy an oracle license in a shop around the corner. It is going to be hard for intel to enforce it.
- laumars 8y agoPerhaps if Intel were to play honestly then you might have a point. However there's certainly a few ways they could attempt to enforce it through slightly underhanded, yet pretty typical practices for how many multi-nationals like to operate in this day and age. * cease and desist orders. They could probably argue improper use of trademark or something. And by "could" I don't mean "they have a legitimate legal case" but rather "a flimsy one but one that is still scary enough that few people might want to take the risk / expense testing the argument in court. * many benchmarks are ran by reviewers who might have access components before they hit the shelves. It would be trivial for Intel to end that relationship. If it's suppliers further down the chain who are providing samples to journalists and reviewers then Intel might put pressure on those suppliers to end their relationships with said journalists. This might break a few anti-competition laws in the EU but it's not like that's ever stopped businesses in the past. On a tangential rant: I think the real issue isn't so much whether it is enforceable but rather the simple fact that companies are even allowed to muddy the waters about what basic journalistic and/or consumer rights we have. I'm getting rather fed up of some multi-nationals behaving like they're above the law.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoI literally got one with a book on databases as a student, so you kind of can? But the power of the argument is that if it's possible to put this kind of clause in place and enforce it by law for something that's harder to get, then Intel putting that clause in place for the general public has legal prescedent when they do want to take someone to court. It actually makes it easier for Intel to argue that chips are such specialized bits of equipment that even though your average joe can _get_ one, they won't understand how it works and so only highly trainer professionals who have been certified by Intel would be able to reliably benchmarks their products. "As the average user would interpret the results incorrectly, their publication would hurt intel's bottom line". And suddenly you're 95% of the way to having won the case already.
- AstralStorm 8y agoA hotshot lawyer could sue them for this anticompetitive clause for big $$$. (it disallows comparing the product against the competitors)
- vbezhenar 8y agoSue Oracle.
- kashyapc 8y agoYeah, my guess would be it's #1 too; I can't believe that Intel can be so naive that no one on the internet will benchmark the performance—given how all these nasty CVEs are raising such a stink. Serious customers will demand performance numbers; you can't simply answer them with "blocked due to legal".
- chx 8y agoI am not a lawyer but I question whether this is enforceable in the USA and I do not question, rather state this is not enforceable in the EU. All click-though / shrink-wrap licensing the end user is forced to or has to accept automatically is invalid.
- kashyapc 8y agoRegardless of the details of enforceability, this just sends the wrong message to the rest of the industry and community, and doesn't inspire confidence in Intel.
- kashyapc 8y agoSo, Intel indeed redacted the "no benchmarks" thing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17833777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17833777
- _ph_ 8y agoIf you consider how fundamentally broken speculative execution from a security standpoint is, then a fully "fixed" processor will be significantly slower than unfixed ones. The benchmarking clause rather clearly shows this.
- mannykannot 8y agoA corporation the size of Intel doesn't do this sort of thing accidentally, especially as there was no good reason for them to be modifying the terms in the first place.
- lucb1e 8y agoAfter it blows up I'm sure they'll claim it's the former, regardless of the latter.
- da_chicken 8y agoI'd say that it is related to L1TF, but not to keep it secret. It's additional ammunition to use in court when they get sued for performance loss. > Cloud Company: Your honor, the security flaws in the hardware and microcode provided by the defendant necessitated the installation of updates, also provided by defendant, which resulted in a 30% loss of overall performance. Since our business model is predicated on selling the processing power of computers that have CPUs manufactured by defendant installed, they are liable for this loss in productivity. > Intel: Your honor, plaintiff could not possibly prove any loss in productivity. If you'll examine Exhibit A, the Intel microcode EULA, you will see that it expressly prohibits benchmarking. Whether plaintiff is claiming they did these benchmarks themselves or a third party did them is immaterial because our license expressly forbids doing so. Plaintiffs need to show a loss of productivity without relying on performance benchmarks and therefore need to show that the workloads prior to and after the microcode has been installed are equivalent and that the results are detrimental. Now, I don't expect most judges would go for it since EULAs are notoriously weak, but it does give them ammunition to impugn the evidence. It's always possible a judge or jury would listen to that.
- wyldfire 8y ago"could not possibly prove" [without violating the license]. That doesn't invalidate the Cloud Company's claim, it only offers Intel an opportunity to countersue. In that case, they can likely only sue for copyright infringement damages.
- LeifCarrotson 8y agoWhat are the teeth on an admitted-in-court EULA violation? Looking at the license, the only thing it grants the end-user and which Intel could revoke is the license to use the software: > Subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement, Intel hereby grants to you a non-exclusive, non- transferable right to use the Software (for the purpose of this Agreement, to use the Software includes to download, install, and access the Software) listed in the Grant Letter solely for your own internal business operations. You are not granted rights to Updates and Upgrades unless you have purchased Support (or a service subscription granting rights to Updates and Upgrades). So yeah, they could revoke your license to the update and leave you with a lot of insecure silicon...but that's what you had before the update (and, in all likelihood, what you still have after the update, just with a known flaw patched and the system lots slower). I don't even think they could sue you for copyright infringement, because you're not violating copyright, you're violating the EULA.
- Symmetry 8y agoIn 2014 I would certainly assume (1) as well but Intel has been getting less and less open and also more and more willing to creatively stretch the truth in their marketing over the last few years in a worrying way. Currently I think (2) is about equally as likely as (1).
- Rafuino 8y agoThe author updated the post. I'm guessing #1 (I work at Intel). Text and link below. UPDATE: Intel has resolved their microcode licensing issue which I complained about in this blog post. The new license text is here (https://01.org/mcu-path-license-2018 https://01.org/mcu-path-license-2018).
- cestith 8y agoI'm going with option #3. Intel sold me a warranted part without these terms. Now they're trying to alter an existing sale after the fact because they need to fix a defect under that warranty. I will do as I please with my property and they can talk to my attorneys.