3 ms·
How would they know they are different species? They don't have their DNA. The Denisovans are just a different form and we don't find them outside one cave. And
by EGreg 8y ago
How would they know they are different species? They don't have their DNA. The Denisovans are just a different form and we don't find them outside one cave. And now they claim that different species can interbreed? Who determines all this?
- Symmetry 8y agoWhether Denisivans and Neanderthals are different species is mostly just a matter of semantics. We have had a pretty good look at the DNA of each and it's clear that the two were evolving in isolation for hundreds of thousands of years resulting in genetically distinct populations. The difference between Denisovans and Neanderthals is about half the difference between humans and either. It's not at all unusual for two different species to be able to interbreed. Lions and tigers for instance or horses and donkeys. Mules, the offspring of horses and donkeys are sterile, though, so the two populations can't mix. Ligoers, the offspring of a male lion and female tigers, aren't entirely sterile but have very low fertility. With humans and neanderthals there are portions of the Neanderthal genome related to reproduction that were very heavily selected against in a way which seems to indicate that male hybrids at least had moderate fertility problems until those genes were removed. So it's not black and white at all. We have zero evidence for any reduction in fertility between Neanderthals and Denisovans since we have very few examples of hybrid offspring and this sort of analysis needs lots of data - so who knows.
- danieltillett 8y agoWe wrote almost exactly the same thing :) One nitpick it is not male hybrids that had reduced fertility, but following Haldane’s rule it was the male SSA (sub-saharan african) and Denisovan/Neanderthal female offspring that were infertile - the other way around were fertile or else there would be no descendants of the Denisovans and Neanderthals living today.
- EGreg 8y agoThat’s my point. We don’t know the amount of gene transfer between the two groups at different times. Calling something two different species usually implies some sort of allopatric speciation leading to almost zero gene sharing. Can you name a single proven example of something like this happening in the last few thousand years?
- danieltillett 8y agoHappens all the time in biology - let me introduce you to the Coywolf [0]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coywolf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coywolf
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI thought some female mules were fertile. eg https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/3378453/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/3378453/
- danieltillett 8y agoYes we do have the DNA of Denisovans and Neanderthals (extracted from bones), but more importantly we have the living descendants of both (Eurasians in the case of Neanderthals and Melanesian/Australian Aborigines in the case of Denisovans). The issue if Denisovans and Neanderthals are different species to sub-Saharan Africans is complex (nothing in biology is simple). Looking at the gene flow into existing populations it appears all Neanderthal and Denisovan genes came in via the male side. This suggests that the offspring were subject to Haldane’s rule [0], which is a strong marker for interspecies not intraspecies hybridization. More importantly, the three homo populations fit all the criteria for being different species that apply to the rest of the animal kingdom (i.e. genetically isolation and genetic adaptation to different environments). We should not forget that different does not mean inferior. Lions and tigers are different species of the genus Panthera, can they interbreed (Liger) and are subject to Haldane’s rule. Despite this one is not a better cat than the other. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haldane%27s_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haldane%27s_rule
- toasterlovin 8y agoTo be more precise, there are actually only a few known bone fragments of Denisovans, so details about their morphology is not known. You can tell that they’re different species by analyzing the DNA to figure out when the lineage diverged from a common ancestor with Neanderthals. In the case of Denisovans and Neanderthals, if I recall correctly, they diverged like 400k years before the specimens which have been found were alive. Whether that qualifies as a different species depends on how you define species. But the divergence is similar in scale to the divergence between humans and Neanderthals, so if you consider humans and Neanderthals different species, then Denisovans are also a separate species. The alternative is to consider then all different varieties of human. Edit: just wanted to add this write up by Razib Khan for anybody interested: https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2018/08/22/hominins-are-still-having-sex-caught-in-flagrante-delicto/ https://www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2018/08/22/hominins-are-still...
- danieltillett 8y agoThe divergence was likely longer ago than that - the current consensus is 744K years ago [0]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denisovan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denisovan
- toasterlovin 8y agoSorry, I worded my comment awkwardly. I meant roughly 400k years before the time when the individuals who the specimens are from were alive.
- matt4077 8y ago(1) They do have the DNA... That's actually how this discovery came about, and the reason for all the progress in this field over the last few years. Svante Pääbo at the Max Planck Institute and his team invented a method to extract DNA from ancient bone fragments a few years back. (@) The term "species" doesn't really have a definition in biology. You seem to be suggesting that producing offspring defines two individuals as belonging to the same species. That's not a workable definition because most life on earth doesn't breed at all. It's also not the correct, obsolete definition, which had always been "producing offspring that is itself fertile". Otherwise, tiger and lion are one species (producing infertile liger when they mate).
- danieltillett 8y agoLigers are not infertile and species does have a definition in biology. Where the argument comes about is if two different populations are different species or not.