4 ms·
Also area is not the same as volume. Second growth forest tends to have less wood than old growth. I grew up in British Columbia, Canada. I remember when you
by btilly 8y ago
Also area is not the same as volume. Second growth forest tends to have less wood than old growth.
I grew up in British Columbia, Canada. I remember when you could see a whole row of logging trucks driving by carrying one tree. As in, each section of the tree filled a logging truck. There are trees where that tree was today, but they represent nowhere near the same amount of carbon stored in the form of wood.
The article failed to point this factor out.
- weberc2 8y agoBut now that carbon lives in buildings, paper, landfills, etc and there is new carbon in the form of the smaller trees. From a carbon sequestration perspective, it would seem that this is strictly better than waiting for trees to get old, right?
- andyidsinga 8y agothis might be the case, but we would also need to know how much of that wood is being used for heating and cooking
- armenarmen 8y agoI am certain that percentage of the biomass of an old growth trees, like the one mentioned, devoted to cooking and heating is negligible.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- btilly 8y agoSome, but not all. A lot of the wood gets burned. Either as the purpose of the wood, or as how the forest got cleared. (Fires are particularly common in the tropics on purpose, and fairly common in the temperate zones by accident. As California demonstrated this month.) In the process of turning tree into manufactured goods, there is a lot of waste that tends to wind up in the atmosphere. Manufactured goods are themselves vulnerable to fire, decay, beetles, etc, so some of them are released. Tracking how much is released, and when is very hard. That is why according to the Kyoto protocol, a tree is counted as released as soon as it is cut down. All told, deforestation is estimated at around 10% of total greenhouse gas emissions.
- privacypoller 8y agoYou must have grown up on the coast or the island, because I grew up in the interior and they never had trees like that outside of the temperate zones. The majority of the province has logging but it is not giant, old-growth ancients and never was.
- btilly 8y agoYou are absolutely right. I grew up on Vancouver Island. And the giant Sitka Spruce is a coastal tree. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picea_sitchensis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picea_sitchensis for more, including a map of its range.
- temp64201292 8y agoThat is because almost all of the giant Redwood and Giant Sequoia trees in the Pacific Northwest were destroyed by logging by the start of the 1920s. Darius and Tabitha May Kinsey's Kinsey, Photographer: A Half Century of Negatives is a book of Darius Kinsey's photographs of logging camps in Washington and Oregon in the 19th century. The camps were inland and there are many photographs of the giant trees growing in the mountains. The giant tree forests did not stop at the US border, and BC had the same logging boom in the 19th century. It is disingenuous to claim that new growth coniferous and Boreal forest is the only thing BC has ever had, when most of the BC giant tree forests were destroyed only a few generations ago.
- btilly 8y agoNo, the person that you're responding to is correct. When someone from British Columbia says "interior" they mean anything past the coast mountain range. This is a semi-arid climate that didn't readily support any of BC's large tree species, namely red cedar, douglas fir, and sitka spruce. It doesn't matter how many pictures from a century ago that you have of big trees inland, or on the west side of the first mountain range. That's not the interior, and isn't relevant.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoI'm strongly suspecting the # increased, but the volume and/or mass of wood has gone down because the "sustainable" artificial forests seem to have less mass than old growth.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoI'd imagine that on a yearly basis, plantation forests sequester more carbon than old growth forest. Modern pine trees (especially pinus radiata in NZ) are incredibly fast growing. Time from planting to harvest is 25-30 years for pinus radiata. The old trees that they were cutting down would've been hundreds of years old. The growth rate of trees slows down over time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ItsMe000001 8y agoMaybe the sarcasm tag is missing? What's the point of looking at "rate of growth"? Look at how much wood there is in total at any given point! Trees that are removed are not exported to somewhere outside earth, so that growing them faster would remove more carbon.
- richardw 8y agoAs long as the wood isn't burned it's still removing carbon from the atmosphere, which is our primary goal. When the carbon was in the ground it was still fine, we don't need it off-planet. Metaphor: water as carbon. Thick pipe with faster flow can move as much water as a slower moving fat pipe. You're focusing on the cross section of the pipe.
- Scarblac 8y agoMuch of the wood is burned. In the Netherlands (and in the wider EU? Not sure if this is a national or EU thing) power plants have to burn some percentage of biomass instead of fossil fuel to meet "sustainability" targets, and they burn wood pellets imported from the US to do that.
- szemet 8y ago> The growth rate of trees slows down over time. No, it is accelerating - according to this study in Nature [2]. "reviewed records from forest studies on six continents, involving 673,046 individual trees and more than 400 species...97% of the species surveyed, the mass growth rate—literally, the amount of tree in the tree—kept increasing even as the individual tree got older and taller" [1] "for most species mass growth rate increases continuously with tree size. Thus, large, old trees do not act simply as senescent carbon reservoirs but actively fix large amounts of carbon compared to smaller trees; at the extreme, a single big tree can add the same amount of carbon to the forest within a year as is contained in an entire mid-sized tree" [2] [1] http://science.time.com/2014/01/15/study-shows-older-trees-absorb-more-carbon/ http://science.time.com/2014/01/15/study-shows-older-trees-a... [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature12914 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature12914
- MAGZine 8y agoPeople stopped harvesting redwoods because iirc not only are they protected but they're not a good source of lumber because when you fell redwoods, they shatter unless if you're careful.
- ac29 8y agoA non-trivial amount of redwood is still cut down, including in the Bay Area. This mill near Santa Cruz processes ~20 million board feet a year: https://bigcreeklumber.com/ https://bigcreeklumber.com/
- dbcurtis 8y agoSequoia Sempervirons, the coastal redwood, is good wood and naturally weather resistant. It is still logged. Sequoia Gigantis, on the western slope of the mid Sierra, is brittle and not very practical to log. (please pardon my Latin spelling. English spelling gives me a rough time....)