5 ms·
Because a public bank is not a for-profit business, it can offer lower interest rates than private options, saving billions of dollars over time. And because th
by refurb 8y ago
Because a public bank is not a for-profit business, it can offer lower interest rates than private options, saving billions of dollars over time. And because the city owns the bank, any interest income would flow back into its coffers. That reduces financing costs and facilitates more lending. Plus, the money stays at home, circulating in the local economy rather than traveling into an investor’s pockets or a risky trading scheme.
I don't think this is well thought out.
They are ignoring opportunity cost. If the city lets a bank hold $1B, they get X amount in interest. If they pull that money out and lend it at a lower rate, they will get a smaller return. That's not "saving billions" at all.
I get the sense the people who thought this up have little to no understand of how finance works.
- gfo 8y agoMy interpretation is that, because the public bank is doing the lending, the city collects on any interest payments made on loans they provide. Because all money on loan from the bank is generating income for the city, the net income is greater than if they simply collected interest from their stash of money in another, public bank.
- refurb 8y agoI get your line of thinking, but in the part I quoted they talked about offering loans "with lower interest rates".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- orch_themed 8y agoI agree with you. The compliance costs alone with starting a bank, plus how do you earn interest back on investing in transportation infrastructure? If the bank makes a loan to the city for a new train line, does the city pay itself back...with its own money? I get the overall activist position against modern finance in the aftermath of the financial crisis, but letting politicians run a bank is not a great idea.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shove 8y agoYour argument sounds a lot like, "if they buy apples at $1 and sell them at $0.95, they'll loose money" It is in fact possible to loan out money at a lower interest rate than a private bank while simultaneously collecting a higher rate than the bank pays on deposits because the bank doesn't lend at the same rate it pays out. The larger that spread, the more sense this idea makes. Seems like an elementary mistake for someone leveling the accusation that the scheme isn't well thought out. Surely there's more to your critique than this.
- refurb 8y agoExplain this particular sentence...Because a public bank is not a for-profit business, it can offer lower interest rates than private options, saving billions of dollars over time.. Where are the "savings"? This money was originally earning interest, not costing money. And of course they need to incorporate the default rate on their loans, which would lower the overall return. Overall, a very hand wavy plan.
- refurb 8y agoAnd looking at the Bank of North Dakota, it indeed looks like they don't save any money at all. The vast majority of funding for the Bank of North Dakota comes from deposits resulting from tax and fee collections. The bank essentially offers below market rate loans by paying lower deposit rates back to the State, ultimately costing the taxpayer.[1] [1]https://www.denverpost.com/2015/03/04/colorado-would-be-wise-to-reject-state-owned-banking/ https://www.denverpost.com/2015/03/04/colorado-would-be-wise...
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThere are benefits besides absolute returns you're not considering (you're not beholden to a commercial entity, off the top of my head).
- tk75x 8y agoI look at it this way: Scenario A: city deposits their funds in a private bank where the funds earn a 1% interest rate. The private bank lends funds at 5% interest. The bank keeps the 4% difference. Scenario B: city keeps their funds in a public bank. The public bank pays out interest at 2% and lends at 4%. Now the city is keeping the 2% difference with the added benefit of total control over its funds.
- bmm6o 8y agoThe public bank would lend the money at a lower rate than a private bank would, but that lower rate could still be higher than the interest rate for the city's deposits at a private bank. The devil is in the details, but I don't think you can dismiss it out of hand.
- im3w1l 8y agoSo it's kind of like a muni bond, but opposite?