6 ms·
One big difference is these cases I suspect is the power of unions and regulations. If some enterprising people in New York had tried to set up their own ad ho
by dagw 8y ago
One big difference is these cases I suspect is the power of unions and regulations. If some enterprising people in New York had tried to set up their own ad hoc sanitation service where they'd drive around a neighborhood in a van and for a dollar a bag they'd drive your trash to the dump they'd be stomped down on by unions and regulations in a flash. If a hypothetical Irish banking union had sent thugs each pub acting as an ad hoc clearing house or convinced the brewers union to not deliver beer to 'strike breaking' pubs the the situation probably would have played out very differently.
Basically the real conclusion should be that strikes only work if there is also some additional force preventing outside people from filling the void left by the striking workers.
- paulie_a 8y agoIf someone tried to set up a waste disposal service like that in that time period, unions and regulations would have been the least of their problems. The mob and their body being found in the dump would be a bigger concern.
- dagw 8y agoWhich was essentially my point. It wasn't the striking sanitation workers that brought the city to a standstill, it was the external forces that prevented alternative solutions to the problem that caused the standstill. If that force is union thugs, mob hit men or government lawyers doesn't really matter. Had the unions threatened to stop deliveries to and/or break legs of shop owner who accepted non-official currency in the Ireland example, that strike would have also lasted less than a week as well.
- DoctorOetker 8y agoThe crux of the argument in the article is that strikes in sectors that are undesirable/hard/underpaid are harder to replace, so there is quite a difference: For the meagre effort of keeping a few extra tabs (something they were already used to) they could earn increased reputation or advertisement (while you go the pub 'bank' you might as well have a drink on your way out). The realy price at which people start providing banking functionality is much lower than the average wage of a banker (the banking sector is permission oriented!). The price to get non-garbage collector to start collecting garbage tends to be much higher than the average wage of a garbage collector (the underbelly of society is obligation oriented!) Stated otherwise, if everyone received the average rent, wages for dirty/unhealthy/boring/complicated/... jobs would rise, simply because they can stay home and live cheap. This would be the most neutral and emergent determination of wages since there is no master table from Washington/Moscow/Brussels to decree the relative wages. No need for endless protests and strikes. Examples: - dirty: toilet cleaner, garbage collector - unhealthy or risky: fire fighter, chemical sector - boring: monotonous factory work, high quality assurance inspection - complicated: physics, engineering, ... This does not mean everyone would end up with the same wage, the more collectively undesirable a job, the higher it would earn on top of your average rent.
- wpietri 8y agoYou're making a lot of soup from very little meat. There are plenty of other interpretations here. The simplest one is that in NYC trash collection is treated as municipal infrastructure, not a commercial business. People already pay taxes for garbage collection, so it's highly unlikely they'd decide to also pay vendors in short order.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- davidgrenier 8y agoIf the situation is shit are you so sure that someone would come in to fill in the void? Your scenario relies on the fact that people, in desperate need, were willing to pay more which is exactly what those on strike revendicated.
- clarkmoody 8y agoIf the alternatives are doing a nasty job or not having any money, there are plenty of people who will do the job. In the case of the union, their wages were probably artificially high due to the government keeping out competition. > someone would come in to fill in the void If a good or services is demanded by the consumer, then someone will find a way to satisfy that demand, barring market interference by the state (for legal business - you get black markets otherwise).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rusk 8y agothere are plenty of people who will do the job. That can coordinate and tackle the scale of problem of New York waste disposal? Come off it, you’re going to fall and hurt yourself.
- davidgrenier 8y agoI agree that someone will come in and fill the job, but it will cost more to swap your entire staff, why not front the salary your employees asked for in the first place. Turnover costs a fortune.
- conanbatt 8y agoIt would be typically be true because strong unions have funds because they have high earners employees. Unions that represent replaceable workers (say, retail employees) almost never have any leverage.
- ataturk 8y agoIt's not sexy, but some entrepreneurs could disrupt trash removal. Imagine Uber drivers picking up bags of trash! It's the next new thing!
- beat 8y ago"Regulation" is why they don't just collect that garbage for a dollar and then dump it in the river - or in your yard.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> "Regulation" is why they don't just collect that garbage for a dollar and then dump it in the river - or in your yard. Someone who collects your garbage for a dollar and takes it to the dump is not violating a regulation prohibiting them from dumping it in the river or your yard. The problem is the regulations that prohibit them from doing nothing actually wrong while not fulfilling some arbitrary formality or greasing the right palms.
- beat 8y agoYou're missing the point. What prevents them from doing exactly what I suggested? Regulation. Without some standard in place to say "Garbage must be taken to a specific place", they can (and will) just take it anywhere. Those regulations about waste management didn't happen in a vacuum. They're not just there to cause headaches or corruption. They were created in response to observed problems - like dumping trash right into rivers. And that "trash" might include really dangerous substances. Moreover, the raw profit motive of capitalism encourages such behavior. If it costs two dollars to dispose of the waste safely, or one dollar to drop it in the river, the market's response is to drop it in the river. That's just free market economics. Tragedy of the commons is an actual thing. The economic term for this is externalizing costs. The market, on its own, is strongly motivated to externalize costs whenever possible. There's no inherent morality to economics, any more than there is an inherent morality to thermodynamics. It's just a fact of nature. But externalized costs are a form of theft - they push cost of business onto the general public, without payment. Regulations exist to keep business from stealing from the rest of us.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> You're missing the point. What prevents them from doing exactly what I suggested? Regulation. You may be the one missing the point. What prevents ordinary people from taking trash to the dump for $1? Regulation. > If it costs two dollars to dispose of the waste safely, or one dollar to drop it in the river, the market's response is to drop it in the river. That's just free market economics. Tragedy of the commons is an actual thing. And if it costs one dollar to dispose of the waste safely but incumbents can charge two dollars if they get a law passed to impede competition, the market's response is to get a law passed to impede competition. That's just "free" market economics. Collective action problems are a real thing. > The economic term for this is externalizing costs. The market, on its own, is strongly motivated to externalize costs whenever possible. It's also motivated to internalize benefits, which organizations do through the mechanism of regulatory capture. And those regulations exist to enable businesses to steal from the rest of us.
- mistersquid 8y ago> Basically the real conclusion should be that strikes only work if there is also some additional force preventing outside people from filling the void left by the striking workers. When talking about labor and unions, this is essentially a tautology because the power of unions is the power of collective bargaining. Collective bargaining cannot obtain unless all human capital (laborers) is deployed through the union. Human capital that is outside the union fractures the power of the union and destroys the power of collective bargaining. In vulgar terms, human capital outside the union is referred to as "scabs" that temporarily heal the wounds produced by a labor dispute. EDIT: readability, grammar
- repolfx 8y agoIn theory maybe but in practice most countries have laws that protect unions on the books. Union force is not simply the force of collective bargaining.
- eesmith 8y agoThe first unions existed before there were laws to protect them. Eg, the bootmakers of the Boston Journeymen Bootmaker's Society used collective action in the early 1800s, even before their right to do so was explicitly decided in Commonwealth v. Hunt (1842). Yes, there are laws to protect unions. You cannot look at that in isolation. There are also laws to prevent some types of collective bargaining. Think of it more as a negotiated arrangements - unions agreed to avoid some behaviors in exchange for certain legal rights. For example, in a free market, a union should be able to use its collective bargaining power to negotiate a closed shop arrangement with an employer. This is illegal in the US. In the same free market, employers can agree to blacklist people because of their union membership. This is also illegal in the US. We could remove all laws which would protect unions, leaving them hobbled by all the laws which prevent them from fully exercising collective bargaining. But pressure builds up, as you can see by the (successful) wildcat strike this year by teachers in West Virginia.
- perkee 8y ago>If some enterprising people in New York had tried to set up their own ad hoc sanitation service where they'd drive around a neighborhood in a van and for a dollar a bag they'd drive your trash to the dump they'd be stomped down on by unions and regulations in a flash. Commercial carting (everything but households and public trash cans) in NYC is done by enterprising people with some regulations that get flouted because of the impossible time pressures they're put under. They die and are injured at a terrible rate. https://www.propublica.org/article/trashed-inside-the-deadly-world-of-private-garbage-collection https://www.propublica.org/article/trashed-inside-the-deadly...
- perfunctory 8y agoThe argument is not really about strikes. > If some enterprising people in New York had tried to set up their own ad hoc sanitation service they would also be doing very useful and important work (would just be paid even less perhaps).
- rusk 8y ago> If some enterprising people in New York had tried What makes you think they didn’t? The scale of the problem in New York means you’d need an awful lot of such individuals to keep up and the workforce isn’t that flexible ... These guys work very hard and in a highly coordinated way that is hard to replicate. Which was the point that they were proving by going on strike. Bankers in Ireland in the 70s not so much though if it happened in Ireland today it might be a different story ...