5 ms·
It is hard to overstate how difficult it is to hover a helicopter this precisely for this long. Helicopters are dynamically unstable. If you take your hands o
by lisper 8y ago
It is hard to overstate how difficult it is to hover a helicopter this precisely for this long. Helicopters are dynamically unstable. If you take your hands off the controls, they start to flip over almost immediately and become unrecoverable within 2-3 seconds.
The best analogy I've heard: imagine trying to stand on a basketball. Now imagine trying to stand on a basketball without flailing your arms around. Now imagine trying to do that for half an hour while someone's life depends on you not screwing up even for a single second.
- chrischen 8y agoThey can’t do computer based stabilization?
- lisper 8y agoAuto-hover technology does exist, but it's not common. Also the pilot has to be able to do it manually in case the autopilot fails, and so most pilots will elect to do it manually at least some of the time just to stay in practice.
- dogma1138 8y agoIsn’t AFCS with hold position capability pretty much standard these days?
- lisper 8y agoNo. https://www.reddit.com/r/flying/comments/998c8b/helicopter_pilots_how_common_is_afcs_nowadays/e4lrcay/ https://www.reddit.com/r/flying/comments/998c8b/helicopter_p...
- tinus_hn 8y agoPerhaps the smart thing would be to practice in situations where an error does not cause someone else to get electrocuted.
- lisper 8y agoA fair point, but you wouldn't get electrocuted in this case. You'd die when the helicopter crashed. (Not that that makes a lot of difference.) More to the point, helicopters and power lines have both been around a lot longer than helicopter autohover technology, and aviation is an inherently conservative enterprise. Even if these sorts of repairs are being done using autohover today (I don't know) they were surely flown manually in the past. UPDATE: I asked this question on /r/flying and got this response from an actual helicopter pilot: https://www.reddit.com/r/flying/comments/998c8b/helicopter_pilots_how_common_is_afcs_nowadays/e4lrcay/ https://www.reddit.com/r/flying/comments/998c8b/helicopter_p... "In a low energy state like an OGE hover, and especially when doing dangerous work like utility (as in the video), live hoists, etc we are almost always handflying. You would be surprised at how few helicopters out there are even capable of auto-hovering. We have an IAHAAS system on the Pave Hawk which in theory can do things like auto hover, auto land, maintain radalt and baro altitudes, even fly zero vis approaches etc. but we don't trust it. I have personally seen it do some sketchy things like virtually departing us from controlled flight during a steady hover for literally no reason."
- derefr 8y agoWhat does it mean for an autopilot to fail, in this case? We're not talking about an automatic guidance system, like in fixed-wing aircraft. We're talking about a thing that translates high-level commands on the stick to low-level commands to the motors, like a car's automatic transmission. Cars with automatic transmission don't have a "backup manual transmission" for when the automatic transmission fails. The automatic transmission doesn't fail.
- manigandham 8y agoNot having a backup doesn’t not mean that no failure is possible, that is a very odd thing to say. Automatic transmissions fail all the time, and then the car stops moving. Ok for cars but serious problem for flight so these aircraft have multiple automatic and manual redundancies. Helicopter autopilots are indeed full guidance systems like fixed wing aircraft, but they can hold the craft in hover position because it's just another flying position possible for helicopters, but it is still actively flying.
- derefr 8y agoI misspoke. What I meant is, the ASIC controlling the automatic transmission—the thing that makes it "an automatic transmission"—doesn't fail. It's just a simple bit of solid-state electronics. It'll probably outlive the car. Other parts of the automatic transmission system fail, sure, but those parts are the same parts that are in a manual transmission. (Because, after all, in modern cars, a manual transmission's control system still ends up as signals sent to an electronic gearbox.) So, like I said—in modern cars, where you've just got an electronic gearbox anyway, there's no sense in having both the ASIC issuing control-commands to the electronic gearbox, and a backup manual stick for issuing the same commands. If there's any fault in the system, it's far, far more likely to come from the stick's mechanism breaking down and issuing spurious commands, than from the ASIC breaking down and issuing spurious commands. And more likely than either is the gearbox getting messed up because it's sitting in a hot, dirty engine compartment.
- tjohns 8y ago
- tormeh 8y agoThe pilot has to be there anyway, right? So where's the profit in fixing this? And so it doesn't get done..
- nomadiccoder 8y agoThe profit can be in reducing errors, being better than human control, etc. which can reduce time spent on the line
- marcosdumay 8y agoAt the cost of turning every automation problem into a worst case disaster. Until the technology is good enough for taking the pilot away, it's not a gain.
- pathseeker 8y ago>Until the technology is good enough for taking the pilot away, it's not a gain. If that were true modern airlines wouldn't have autopilot.
- chrischen 8y agoModern anything wouldn’t have anything.
- marcosdumay 8y agoAirplane pilots have plenty of time for fixing any problem that may appear mid-flight. It's because of this that airplanes don't have autopilots landing or taking them off. And by the way, there's an ongoing discussion on airplane groups about all the new failure modes created by the autopilot-pilot interface. It creates plenty of problems.
- modells 8y agoThere's no inherently intractable reason aircraft "need" human pilots when autopilots are faster, better and make fewer errors. At this stage, an aircraft guider would be able to instruct the aircraft as to what's needed. At some point in the future, AI/ML/DL will replace that role entirely such that the lineman communicates with the aircraft directly. Then, as a further iteration (40-100 years), the lineman is also replaced by robotics on a drone-like platform.
- zokier 8y agoIt is possible, and done in some cases. Check out Bell 525 for example
- taneq 8y agoThey can. I remember a field trip back in university (maybe even high school, it was years ago) to an emergency response center. They had a medevac helicopter with auto-hover, where the pilot could just hit 'position hold' and it would hover there while they winched someone to safety. I'd imagine the reason a DJI drone's capabilities are so much greater than those of a helicopter carrying passengers is that the former can fall out of the sky every now and then and it's no big deal. The latter has to pass a whole lot of rigorous FAA (or equivalent) testing.
- exikyut 8y ago> I'd imagine the reason a DJI drone's capabilities are so much greater than those of a helicopter carrying passengers is that the former can fall out of the sky every now and then and it's no big deal. The latter has to pass a whole lot of rigorous FAA (or equivalent) testing. This reminded me of another comment I read recently, and I was actually able to remember where I read it! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17723107 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17723107 > Hi- I used to work in regulated pharma and I want to be clear: " The core problem is that the FDA-approved devices are optimized not for getting the best result, but for ensuring the manufacturer can't be blamed if something goes wrong" is a misleading statement. The reason everything is regulated is that sometimes things do go wrong, and it's necessary to have root cause attribution so the problem can be remedied and a fix deployed, and, if somebody did something illegal or dumb, they can be sanctioned. (The quoted part of this comment, itself from a previous comment, is the part I found relevant, but I quoted the whole thing (reply and all) because I found the whole thing interesting.) I think I can naively say with confidence that aviation and medical certification are very similarly rigorous. So, it sounds to me that the autohover functionality you describe was perhaps the equivalent of Tesla "Autopilot" (which really amounts to auto-steer). The context of doing rescue lifesaving over sea is indeed very stringent, but at the same time, it's not going to be the end of the world if the helicopter moves around a bit, because it's in the open air. And if the situation is dire - strong crosswinds, or someone in critical condition - the pilot's training probably instructs them not to use it. In this situation, letting the controls go for 2-3 seconds (as per the other comments here) is going to mean an unrecoverable crash, and perhaps a rotor blade might cut one of the cables and then you have 220kV waving everywhere, hitting other power lines, touching the ground..... no. You just find the best pilots that can hover Really Well™, and pay them metric stupid amounts of money so they don't go anywhere else. Now I'm wondering if the pilots hold hovering competitions, in the same way people in the military frequently do target practice.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoOkay I've actually flown helicopters, and it's not that hard. Harder than fixed-wing, but much easier than standing on a basketball.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI would wager that it's easier to hover a helicopter than a fixed wing aircraft.
- sowbug 8y ago:) It can be done! (If your point of reference is the ground.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vP13XPMNfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vP13XPMNfc
- perl4ever 8y agoI have not actually flown a helicopter, but every time I tried one in MS Flight Simulator, I promptly lost my balance, flipped over and crashed directly after taking off. However, it may be that using some other form of control than a mouse works better.
- akavel 8y agoI've bought a joystick (some inexpensive HOTAS set actually [1]) specifically for playing helicopter sims. It makes a world of a difference. I mean, still hard, but suddenly approachable at all and fun. And notably, all the hand movements you do must be super tiny. According to youtube, that's how it is on real helis too. [1] namely, Thrustmaster T-Flight HOTAS X, IIRC
- dreamcompiler 8y agoThe real thing is easier than a simulator. The sensory inputs that come from your butt are invaluable and impossible to reproduce in a desktop simulator. Plus you're very highly-motivated to stay alive.
- lovemenot 8y ago
- k_sze 8y agoWhich makes me wonder: are there different classes of heliopter piloting license? Maybe one for commercial passenger flight, one for forest firefighting, one for work on overhead power lines, one for acrobatics, one for search-and-rescue? Maybe it’s different per government? I’m not really into aviation and don’t have any helicopter pilot friend.
- lisper 8y agoYes, you can get the same grades of helicopter license as you can a fixed-wing license: private, commercial, and airline-transport pilot. Most people who get a commercial and an ATP also pick up an instructor rating along the way, but that is mostly orthogonal to the other three.
- k_sze 8y agoAh, ok. So the classes are not very special-purpose (e.g. firefighting vs search-and-rescue), at least where you’re from.
- lisper 8y agoThose are just the official FAA requirements. There are additional requirements for speciality occupations mandated by industry and insurance standards. See e.g.: https://www.reddit.com/r/flying/comments/3zzajl/fire_pilots/ https://www.reddit.com/r/flying/comments/3zzajl/fire_pilots/
- genericid 8y agoThat sounds like deadly accidents should be happening every week.
- fermienrico 8y agoI call bullshit on this analogy. If it required similar skills to a human standing on a basketball, then a Helicopter is an monumental engineering failure.
- lisper 8y agoIf you don't believe me, go to your nearest general aviation airport, hire a training helicopter and an instructor, and try it yourself.
- fermienrico 8y agoOther Pilots have already commented - it is nowhere as difficult as balancing on a Basketball.
- akira2501 8y ago> then a Helicopter is an monumental engineering failure. That's baffling. Engineering is the art of compromise. The helicopter _does_ have many compromises in it's design, but it's benefits are unmatched by other aerial vehicles. In other words, the benefits outweigh the negatives.