5 ms·
Sort of. Russia is a threat in that they're an expansionist power whose interests are not always aligned with ours, and that their culture is one where you tak
by nostrademons 8y ago
Sort of. Russia is a threat in that they're an expansionist power whose interests are not always aligned with ours, and that their culture is one where you take any advantage you can and use it to leverage your power.
Many Americans don't realize just how small Russia is in terms of the real numbers that matter. Their GDP is less than half of California's. (You can see why they've been funding Californian secessionist efforts - an independent California is a bigger threat to America than Russia is - but so far these have pitifully low traction amongst actual Californians.) Their population is less than half of the U.S, and is shrinking. Their military is a pale shadow of its Cold War size. Many people have this image of them as the second world superpower, which was always a bit of a mirage, but is doubly false after the breakup of the Soviet Union, which took away half their population and 25% of their land area.
There's a certain irony where most Americans think the biggest threat to American hegemony is either Russia, North Korea, or Islamic fundamentalism (the former two of which are bit players with outsize threats, and the latter of which has the organizational & technological sophistication of 200 years ago), while the real threats are either an ascendant China (4x the U.S. population, 60% the GDP and projected to overtake the U.S. by 2029, already the world's largest trading partner) or domestic disturbances that lead to the breakup of the U.S, much the same way the USSR broke up.
- smallnamespace 8y ago> they're an expansionist power That's somewhat debatable, if you mean 'expansionist' like Russia would like to rebuild the USSR or a new Russian Empire. What Russia is trying to do is ensure it has a strategic buffer zone between it and the West and friendly rulers and states on its borders, much like any state with Russia's military history would be interested in doing. Combined Russian/Soviet casualties in WW1 and WW2 were on the order of ~60mm people out ~160mm total. Both NATO and the EU have progressively expanded towards the former Soviet bloc since the fall of the USSR. From the West's perspective, this is bringing liberal multiparty democracy and stability to an unstable Eastern Europe. But from Russia's perspective, why should it fully trust the West that was so recently its enemy, and when the attempted adoption of liberal democracy and capitalism in the 90s failed so spectacularly (Russia's GDP fell by a full 50% and life expectancy dropped by years [2]). Not trying to shill or defend Russia's invasion of Crimea or Ukraine here, but if you just look at the map of a formerly hostile alliance moving steadily eastward and you were Russia, would you really just throw up your hands and say 'yes, that is how the world should be' and tacitly accept it? [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO#Vilnius_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_NATO#Vilnius_Gr... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1116380/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1116380/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sequence7 8y ago> But from Russia's perspective, why should it fully trust the West that was so recently its enemy, and when the attempted adoption of liberal democracy and capitalism in the 90s failed so spectacularly (Russia's GDP fell by a full 50% and life expectancy dropped by years You say this is because of the failure of liberal democracy and capitalism but your citation says it was most likely caused by: "rising poverty rates, unemployment, financial insecurity, and corruption" Perhaps the Russian state should focus on addressing those issues instead of invading and trying to destabilise other countries. > Not trying to shill or defend Russia's invasion of Crimea or Ukraine here, but if you just look at the map of a formerly hostile alliance moving steadily eastward and you were Russia, would you really just throw up your hands and say 'yes, that is how the world should be' and tacitly accept it? Here you describe NATO as a hostile force but it's clear that the countries joining NATO were wise to do so as a defense against a hostile Russia.
- konart 8y ago>Here you describe NATO as a hostile force but it's clear that the countries joining NATO were wise to do so as a defense against a hostile Russia. The cause and the effect. 'hostile Russia' is a result of NATO expansion (among other things), not vice versa. From Russia's perspective it was not wise from NATO to accept those wise countries, expecially considering NATO had an aggrement with Russia on this part. >Perhaps the Russian state should focus on addressing those issues instead of invading and trying to destabilise other countries. Usually you have to deal with both internal and external issues at the same time.
- sequence7 8y ago>> Here you describe NATO as a hostile force but it's clear that the countries joining NATO were wise to do so as a defense against a hostile Russia. > The cause and the effect. 'hostile Russia' is a result of NATO expansion (among other things), not vice versa. From Russia's perspective it was not wise from NATO to accept those wise countries, expecially considering NATO had an aggrement with Russia on this part. The argument that Russia is just defending itself against hostile expansion rather falls down when you count the number of countries that are members of NATO who have been the victim of Russian expansion (0) compared to the number that are not a member of NATO who have been the victim of aggression (more than 0). That rather implies that being a NATO member protects you from Russian invasion and explains the desire, for every country that can, to join NATO. >> Perhaps the Russian state should focus on addressing those issues instead of invading and trying to destabilise other countries. >Usually you have to deal with both internal and external issues at the same time. Perhaps but Russia does not appear to be dealing with the internal issues which is my point.
- beat 8y agoI recently read Eleven Nations (which I recommend), and in the epilogue, the author sounds quite hopeless. He does not believe the USA, or Mexico, or Canada will survive the 21st century in their current forms/borders. Imagine, for example, that California secedes (or more to the point, the northern California coast secedes). What would Seattle and Portland do? How about Vancouver? After all, Vancouver has far more in common culturally and historically with San Francisco than it does with, say, Nova Scotia. And why would LA and San Diego join San Francisco's revolution? Their dominant culture has more in common with Tijuana. Part of the author's argument is how much sense it would make for what is currently northern Mexico and southwestern USA to break off and become an independent nation together.
- DataWorker 8y agoInnumeracy is at the core of a lot of strongly held political convictions. And I get the sense that some section of the population thinks it’s racist to consider any non-white nation a threat. Russia can be vilified without triggering any of those concerns in people who might find such thoughts repugnant - eg anti-Muslim or ethnocentric or racially tinged — if they were expressed towards other nations.
- y-c-o-m-b 8y ago> There's a certain irony where most Americans think the biggest threat to American hegemony is either Russia, North Korea, or Islamic fundamentalism (the former two of which are bit players with outsize threats, and the latter of which has the organizational & technological sophistication of 200 years ago), while the real threats are either an ascendant China (4x the U.S. population, 60% the GDP and projected to overtake the U.S. by 2029, already the world's largest trading partner) or domestic disturbances that lead to the breakup of the U.S, much the same way the USSR broke up. The media does a great job perpetuating this illusion too. Even the more independent and supposedly "impartial" networks like NPR participate in propagating these minuscule issues. You hit the nail on head with your remarks on domestic disturbances though - the damage from that alone is severe.