6 ms·
I feel like this is nothing new. Every few years, some major sportsball team threatens to leave their city unless the taxpayers fork over mega-billions for a n
by jrockway 8y ago
I feel like this is nothing new. Every few years, some major sportsball team threatens to leave their city unless the taxpayers fork over mega-billions for a new stadium. Despite any measurable economic benefits to having a stadium, the cities fall for it every time. It's the same thing, right? Amazon says "give us free electricity and we'll make jobs", and the politicians buy it even though it's very unlikely to be true.
Maybe someday we'll get an itemized tax bill, so you can see that you paid $4.12 for Amazon's electricity and $1.23 for a new sports arena, and can vote for someone else if that upsets you. Now that I think about it, that will never happen. And so, the cycle continues.
- bcohen5055 8y agoTo be fair they don't pay for it every time... The chargers are now in LA, not SD
- brandonmenc 8y agotbf, anyone saying "sportsball" isn't even going to know who the chargers are
- s73v3r_ 8y agoRight, but then that just makes their argument that much weaker.
- Dylan16807 8y agoBah. They're not even using the term to display any lack of knowledge, because there are multiple sports involved.
- amerkhalid 8y agoI have heard term "sportsball" before. It seems that it is used mostly in context of making fun of people's addiction to their favorite teams.
- dev_dull 8y agoSonics now in Oklahoma.
- gamblor956 8y agoLA is not providing any money for the Rams/Chargers stadium, nor did it pay for any part of the LA Football stadium. We told the teams they could build a stadium if they wanted the second-largest media market in the US to call home, or they could shove it. They did the math and now LA has 2 football teams and 2 futbol teams.
- wgerard 8y agoLA (along with NY and maybe Chicago) is the exception that proves the rule. Most cities that tell teams to shove it just end up losing their teams to other markets: In this case, San Diego and St. Louis.
- CodeCube 8y agoBut are they worse off for "losing" those teams?
- wgerard 8y agoDefinitely a valid question! I think it's hard to define what "worse off" means here, mostly because it's hard to put a number on the value of entertainment to people (other than the obvious ones: ticket prices, etc.). I get what you're saying, though - cities often give up a lot (and probably too much) to keep franchises happy. I'm mostly just pointing out the major power disparity between LA and other cities: Major sports teams want to be in LA far more than LA wants a major sports team. That's not true of, say, Seattle or St. Louis or San Diego.
- cimmanom 8y agoNY already did the losing their teams to other markets thing, they just did it 60 years ago.
- opo 8y agoWhile their is less public subsidy for the Rams/Chargers stadium than many other stadiums, it doesn’t look like it is zero: >..."There will be no public dollars, no taxpayer dollars used for this project," he said. "The entire project has been privately capitalized and is being privately funded." The nuance between that statement — similar claims were made by Inglewood Mayor James Butts — and tax breaks that could reach $100 million lies in the fine print of a 185-page initiative plan filed by the developers earlier this month. It includes two paragraphs of how Inglewood would eventually reimburse the project for the costs of roadwork, utility work and public parks on the nearly 300-acre site. Meany estimated those costs at $60 million. The city would also reimburse costs of security, medical services and shuttles to off-site parking during stadium events, which Butts estimated at about $8 million a year. http://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-stadium-tax-break-20150113-story.html http://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-stadium-tax-break-201501...
- siruncledrew 8y agoIt's pretty easy to pull off. Step 1: Make a threat about jobs/money to get lawmakers to pay attention. Step 2: Get favorable legislation passed. Hold hands with lawmakers in photo-op for the papers. Step 3: Stall on delivering on promises until lawmakers leave office or come up with excuses. Step 4: Profit.
- ErikVandeWater 8y agoStep 0: Donate to both parties to gain favor with the implicit threat it will be removed if favorable legislation is not passed.
- EvilEndures 8y agoThey don't do that usually. They just donate to incumbents.
- kartan 8y ago> and the politicians buy it even though it's very unlikely to be true. For who are this measures passed? Interesting explanation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs
- tajen 8y agoI think this itemized invoice for government services is what Swiss people have.
- dionidium 8y ago> Despite any measurable economic benefits to having a stadium, the cities fall for it every time Yes, just like they "fall for" municipal operas, art museums, Shakespeare in the Park, and any number of other cultural amenities that don't have obvious and immediate economic impact. Perhaps your complaint is less about public investment in cultural benefits than it is an issue with one particular kind of culture?
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThose things don't receive anywhere near the amount of funding that stadiums and arenas do.
- dionidium 8y agoBased on what? Just grabbing the numbers for one institution I happen to be familiar with, the St. Louis Metropolitan Zoological Park and Museum District: > During its history, the zoo-museum district - officially known as the Metropolitan Zoological Park and Museum District - has raised about $1.3 billion, stabilized five once-struggling institutions and helped some of them develop international reputations. Source: https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/metro/zoo-museum-tax-district-shows-age-after-years/article_c0180fa4-08ff-581d-bd15-79649684d0dd.html https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/metro/zoo-museum-tax-dis... So that's $1.3. billion in tax dollars raised specifically to fund the museums and zoo in the largest park of one mid-sized U.S. city. That tax raises 35 times the $5 million per year the city pays on the bond for the old Rams stadium, which generates a lot of articles like this one: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/rams-los-angeles-st-louis-taxpayers_us_5696955ee4b0778f46f7c330 https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/rams-los-angeles-st-lou... Of course, HuffPo doesn't write any articles about the zoo tax, because literal rams in cages is a more noble use of money than figurative Rams throwing a football, one presumes. The number here also dwarfs the direct public subsidy for Busch Stadium, also in St. Louis, which also got a ton of ink and public scrutiny. More info on that subsidy here: https://www.thefreelibrary.com/What+the+public+paid+for+the+Cardinals%27+stadium%3A+the+media+never+told...-a0165692019 https://www.thefreelibrary.com/What+the+public+paid+for+the+...