19 ms·
New evidence challenges the story of the Stanford Prison Experiment
- SCAQTony 8y agoThough the experiment appears to have been rigged am I wrong when I say that Abu Ghraib, the torture sessions at Guantanamo and the CIA dark sites and Arizona's isolation units pretty much concur with the SPE results? From wikipedia: On August 20, 1971, Zimbardo announced the end of the experiment to the participants. "... According to Zimbardo's interpretation of the SPE, it demonstrated that the simulated-prison situation , rather than individual personality traits, caused the participants' behavior. Using this situational attribution, the results are compatible with those of the Milgram experiment, where random participants complied with orders to administer seemingly dangerous and potentially lethal electric shocks to a shill.[21]..." "... The experiment has also been used to illustrate cognitive dissonance theory and the power of authority...."
- mistercow 8y agoDo we have good reason to believe that those cases weren't also caused by leadership?
- SCAQTony 8y agoYes, at Abu Ghraib leadership failures and order abuses: https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/12/washington/12detainee.html?mtrref=www.google.com&gwh=91D80460BA7D3BD38A86B48F779A43D1&gwt=pay https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/12/washington/12detainee.htm... "...The abuse of prisoners at Abu Ghraib, the report says, “was not simply the result of a few soldiers acting on their own” but grew out of interrogation policies approved by Mr. Rumsfeld and other top officials, who “conveyed the message that physical pressures and degradation were appropriate treatment for detainees.”..." As for GITMO and CIA dark sites — New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/01/us/report-says-american-psychological-association-collaborated-on-torture-justification.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/01/us/report-says-american-p... "...WASHINGTON — The American Psychological Association secretly collaborated with the administration of President George W. Bush to bolster a legal and ethical justification for the torture of prisoners swept up in the post-Sept. 11 war on terror, according to a new report by a group of dissident health professionals and human rights activists. ..." Amnesty International has a boatload of information regarding Sherif Joe Arpaio and the use on isolation unit and in his words concentration camps: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/aug/21/arizona-phoenix-concentration-camp-tent-city-jail-joe-arpaio-immigration https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/aug/21/arizona-phoen... The chants were directed at the Maricopa County sheriff, Joe Arpaio, who a few months before had called this outdoor jail close to downtown Phoenix – his own tough-on-crime creation – a “concentration camp” in a speech to political supporters at his local Italian-American club. When asked about the comment by the Guardian in July, Arpaio brushed it off as a joke. “But even if it was a concentration camp, what difference does it make? I still survived. I still kept getting re-elected,” he said...."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- olavk 8y agoThe experiment attempted to show what mechanisms cause abuse like Abu Ghraib to happen. The theory was that the power disparity in a prison in itself lead to abuse and not individual personality traits of the abusers. This apparently have not been proven. Other explanations are possible. For example that it was actually deliberate policy to abuse prisoners and that the guards sympathized with this policy. As for the Nazi concentration camps it is important to realize that not everyone were treated equally bad. For example prisoners of war from USSR where treated much worse then prisoners from the western allies. This cannot be explained the Zimbardos theory, but can be explained by deliberate policy and Nazi ideology.
- majos 8y agoI am tired of hearing about this study when there are so many valid criticisms of its methods and conclusions, and it has never been replicated. In particular (as this article highlights) there's strong evidence that Zimbardo explicitly coached the "guards" into treating the "prisoners" harshly, as opposed to the meme narrative that everybody fell hard into their roles organically. Ignoring the ethical questions (which are many), this is just straight up asking experimental subjects to help you reach a conclusion, which is . . . a no-no, experimentally speaking. The Wikipedia page has a pretty good overview of this and other issues: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment
- misterbowfinger 8y ago> Zimbardo explicitly coached the "guards" into treating the "prisoners" harshly Right... shouldn't the guards have refused, then? Wouldn't that be the expected "moral" behavior?
- hellllllllooo 8y agoWho knows. The point is that what was reported isn't what happened so the original findings of the study are invalid and cannot be trusted. To answer your question you'd want to do a new study where your question and the methodology is defined in advance. Defining the questions after an experiment has ended leads to bad conclusions because you are biased by having already seen what has happened and likely to fit your question to match the results. The electric shock experiment (https://www.simplypsychology.org/milgram.html https://www.simplypsychology.org/milgram.html) seems similar to your question showing a willingness for people to go further than they normally would when asked to do so by an authority figure.
- mercer 8y agoThere's quite a bit of criticism of that experiment too: > In 2012, Australian psychologist Gina Perry investigated Milgram's data and writings and concluded that Milgram had manipulated the results, and that there was "troubling mismatch between (published) descriptions of the experiment and evidence of what actually transpired." She wrote that "only half of the people who undertook the experiment fully believed it was real and of those, 66% disobeyed the experimenter".[19][20] She described her findings as "an unexpected outcome" that "leaves social psychology in a difficult situation."[21] In the journal Jewish Currents, Joseph Dimow, a participant in the 1961 experiment at Yale University, wrote about his early withdrawal as a "teacher", suspicious "that the whole experiment was designed to see if ordinary Americans would obey immoral orders, as many Germans had done during the Nazi period."[22] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment#Critical_reception https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment#Critical_re...) I can only speak as a psychology student who read about 'classics' such as Milgram and SPE, and participated in a number of experiments myself. I remember even when I read about the Migram experment, I figured that while I probably wouldn't have administered the severe shocks or participated at all, just in case, there's a chance I might have done so assuming it was all faked. In fact, I'd argue this 'disconnect' from reality, if anything, is a much more interesting phenomenon. I've been part of various hazing rituals, some of them in hindsight quite irresponsible, and I think what made those 'work' wasn't that 'good people turned bad' or 'a few bad apples abused the mechanism', but rather that everyone involved just went along with the prank to an irresponsible degree. One could argue that this supports the idea that people will do horrible things when told to do so by an 'authority', but I can't help but feel that the reality as I've experienced it doesn't fit the narrative of the Milgrams and Zimbardos. tl:dr; I can't help but feel that many of these types of experiments are evidence of flawed reality more than morality. it's less going through some kind of moral reasoning and deciding to trust the lab coat, but more a flaw in our mental heuristics that leads us to construct an alternate reality. things like the bystander effect would support that view, and while it might seem like splitting hairs, I feel they're quite different interpretations.
- retox 8y agoWhy is there a push to discredit this study, seemingly all of a sudden? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17387601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17387601
- jmunsch 8y agoRecent release of the tapes and Video? Possibly to validate violence and authority, or the questioning of them?
- maym86 8y agoWhy do you ask? Do you think it's unusual to question something when new evidence comes to light? Seems entirely reasonable to share updated information on a very well known study.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoWhy was the evidence covered up for so long? What changed to have it come to the light? It's reasonable to reevaluate with new information, it's also worth questioning why there's new information
- hellllllllooo 8y agoAgreed, but that wasn't what OP asked. It just seemed like an odd question given the headline explains that the reason this is being discussed is because there is new evidence available.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoNew evidence doesn't answer their question, why is their new evidence coming out to discredit this study now?
- hellllllllooo 8y agoQ. "Why is there a push to discredit this study, seemingly all of a sudden?" A. New evidence is available as stated clearly in the headline.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agowhat is online moderation
- gnicholas 8y agoHere's an interview with the guy who uncovered the deception, from a local Palo Alto newspaper: https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2018/07/01/was-the-stanford-prison-experiment-a-sham-a-qa-with-the-writer-who-exposed-the-celebrated-study https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2018/07/01/was-the-stanf...
- melling 8y agoReality TV was invented in the 1970s. “Journalist Ben Blum cites new evidence that points to choreographed results and pre-ordained conclusions”
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mercurialshark 8y agoThe worst part about choreographing scientific experimentation to comport with what you suspect is true is that in the not-so-distant-future, the negation and dismissal of your results can serve as evidence that your hypothesis was inaccurate. In summary, it's highly counterproductive. Don't be this guy...
- robbrown451 8y agoIt seems to me that the main point of the study is to demonstrate the plasticity of human morality. That people will adapt to different situations in ways that are surprising. People will become "bad people" if they are in a situation that rewards it, especially over time. This is "situationism," as opposed to "dispositionism." Even if the study is very flawed, and even if the implication that this shift can happen in the course of days rather than longer periods of time is not accurate, I think it is an important concept for people to take in, that can help in everything from crime and punishment, to the design of online forums with automated moderation (a.k.a. "karma systems") so they don't turn toxic, to understanding how voting systems can potentially polarize and divide people, and, extending that last point, to understanding what happens to people at Trump rallies. I suspect a lot of the people who seem so eager to discredit the study have a bit of an agenda, in that the find the implications of the study so uncomfortable. They want to believe they'd be a good person even if in a situation where badness is consistently rewarded over long time periods.
- taeric 8y agoNo. If the study was flawed, there is no real take away. Pretty much period. Imagine if physics claimed it was ok that they couldn't predict the motion they were trying to describe, because they still had fancy equations. The entire point is the predictive point. Now, if there are parts that are replicating, then good. We hopefully learned something. But if the study doesn't replicate, you are just pushing an agenda. Odd, as that is what you claim others are doing.
- abnry 8y agoCorrect. As a study stands flawed, there is no real takeaway. However, a flawed study does not mean the original conclusion is false. Merely that the evidence the study provides for it cannot bolster it. But now the study is part of the societal conversation, and this means the idea of moral plasticity is something on people's minds, especially in the context of the study. This isn't the same thing as a rigorous study, but it does prove the point that many people /feel/ that moral plasticity /is/ a thing. This is not rigorous, but in a way, it gives a weak confirmation of the relevance of the idea. Think of some alternatives: we aren't wondering if the study suggests people will become hyper moral when given the power to act harshly. Nobody talks about that.
- twblalock 8y agoNo matter what evidence is brought against it, the Stanford Prison Experiment is going to continue to be part of the psych 101 curriculum. It's going to be taught as a revealing experiment about human nature, or an example of poor experimental ethics, or both at the same time. It's just so deeply ingrained in the way the subject is taught that it's going to stay there even if the conclusions are phony.
- anoncoward111 8y agoWe once taught creationism in schools too
- wpasc 8y agoUnfortunately, in some places we still do (kinda what the OP was saying).
- daveFNbuck 8y agoI don't recall it being taught in my intro psych class. If it was mentioned, it couldn't have been essential.
- dwaltrip 8y agoI think the curriculum is likely to change over time. Change that occurs over decades is still change...
- sp527 8y agoProbably a more useful commentary on the enduringly persuasive effect of emphasizing an association with Stanford.
- schizoidboy 8y agoThis article summarizes Zimbardo's response to them (Reicher et al) as: > How has Zimbardo responded this time? [By reasserting that](http://www.prisonexp.org/response http://www.prisonexp.org/response) 'none of these criticisms present any substantial evidence that alters the SPE’s conclusion'. And at the same time that he berates his critics (without engaging with their arguments), he reworks his story to now say that, yes, Guards were told to be tough, but not how to be tough. For Zimbardo, then, this is all just fake news. Except that it plainly isn’t. Here is Zimbardo's response from that link: > From the time of being recruited with national ads to be actors in a "university-backed social science experiment to be shown on TV," every participant knew their actions and voices (from lapel mics they had to wear always) would be seen and heard on national TV by family and colleagues. Any similarity to the intense build-up of emotional confrontations between SPE guards versus prisoners, 24/7, was diluted by the daily itinerary of the British research team (Alex Haslam and Stephen Reicher). These researchers frequently intervened, made regular public broadcasts into the prison facility, administered daily psychological assessments, arranged contests for the best prisoners to compete to become guards, and as in many “reality-TV” shows, created daily "confessionals" for participants to talk directly to the camera about their feelings. Ironically, the results of this show could be interpreted as further evidence of the “power of the situation,” although in this case the “situation” was that of reality-TV. > Among the participants in this BBC-TV prison show, several of whom had contacted me afterwards, was Philip Bimpson, the ringleader of a prisoner rebellion against the hapless guards. He said, in part: > > The prisoners won because they had organized themselves quicker than the guards; their subversive actions and organizational skills outwitted the guards who were disorganized in their new surroundings. They did not understand that they had to organize themselves and form a set of rules that they all agreed on… I think the group is being exploited by the BBC for commercial gain. Me and my new friends in the group joined the experiment for the furtherance of science & not to be used as a form of cheap entertainment." (Personal email communication, 26 Feb. 2002; supplemented by my subsequent visit in Glasgow, Oct. 10, 2004) > I therefore reject the use of this “replication” as a scientifically valid challenge to results from the SPE (for a more detailed response to this criticism, please see my article in the British Journal of Social Psychology, 2007, Vol. 127.).
- elicash 8y agoThe root of the problem is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis
- modells 8y agoSocial "experiments" with messy, squishy, meat-monkeys... GFL controlling conditions or repeating "experiments." It's not exactly science, more like philosophy. Sometimes, I swear psychologists enjoy exploring the same areas of the mind as serial killers. hmm...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSomeone who majored in psych once told me that most folks in it have no idea how people operate and are trying to get a clue.
- cf498 8y agoThe Stanford Prison experiment goes far beyond the replication crisis. It was a non scientific "experiment" with doctored results. The fact that it was actually taught in the academic field is unbelievable.
- elicash 8y agoI'd argue the best way to root out doctored results is with replication of experiments. It's not just because there might be different segments of populations that might react differently and different approaches to doing the study, but also to protect against something more malicious.
- cf498 8y agoThere is no replication attempt necessary. It wasnt a scientific experiment, it was little more then a publicity stunt. The topic itself is extremely important. If anyone is in the situation to make a study with consenting subjects in those circumstances, which is rather hypothetical, they should much rather stick to original research. I do agree, the replication crisis is an important topic, but it assumes the studies in question have at least an academic standard. If they dont, and its not publicly acknowledged in the field but instead celebrated, its a failure of the field itself.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- celias 8y agohttps://www.stuffyoushouldknow.com/podcasts/how-the-stanford-prison-experiment-worked.htm https://www.stuffyoushouldknow.com/podcasts/how-the-stanford...
- taneem 8y agoAs a child in primary school (in Lesotho, southern Africa): when a teacher left the classroom everyone was supposed to silently complete work. To enforce this, one student would be appointed "name taker". This person would write down the names of anyone who spoke while the teacher was out. Punishment for being on the list was often physical. One day I was made the name taker while the teacher was out. Most kids stayed quiet, but two other segments emerged: the scycophants and the outlaws. The sycophants would attempt to "help" me identify noise makers by pointing them out. In exchange they would hope to be safe from the list, and would use that immunity/privilege to lord over other kids. The outlaws were kids who, once they were added to the list, talked and joked freely, knowing that they were doomed anyway. They felt they were fearless, and they goaded others to join them. I've always remembered this experience, for how quickly a group of children organized themselves into social dynamics that echoed human systems more generally.
- pc86 8y ago> I've always remembered this experience, for how quickly a group of children organized themselves into social dynamics that echoed human systems more generally. Which makes perfect sense when you remember than children are, in fact, human.
- jplayer01 8y agoGoing to need a source for that claim.
- JimboOmega 8y agoWhat incentive is there for you to take names properly, instead of using the power to compel others - talking or not - to do as you wish?
- kace91 8y agoI had a similar experience in primary school in Spain (though punishment was never phisical). The incentive is that if the class is made of, say, 30 kids, you are appointed once and then suffer through the appointments of the other 29 kids (a little less in practice since known troublemakers won't be put in 'power' for obvious reasons). There are plenty of opportunities for mob punishment if your mates don't feel you're being fair.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThis seems to understate the deception of the study. Many of the individuals involved in the study have spoke of it. You can find plenty of quotes on the Wiki page [1] and many others elsewhere as well. Everybody was coached on their roles, and even the prisoners also saw it as a sort of improv scenario. The individual who was famously filmed 'breaking down' claiming "Jesus Christ, I'm burning up inside!" and "I can't stand another night! I just can't take it anymore!" has been framed as an example of a mental collapse from the study. The individual himself however has stated that he thought he would have been allowed to continues his studies as a prisoner - but that was not the case. So he faked a mental collapse to get out of the experiment early (after 36 hours) and get back to his studies. --- As an aside this experiment shows how absolutely crucial objective third parties replicating even keystone studies from reputable institutions is. The one thing that's completely clear is that Zimbardo had predetermined his conclusion and he was going to do anything to get it. That he resorted to something like this (while claiming it was all organic) is far more egregious than an researcher p-hacking or even just outright faking results. That there's no major system for replication means much of what we know about social and even physiological (clinical studies have shown major issues with reproducibility) science could be completely wrong. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment#Criticism_and_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment#Cri...
- sexmachine 8y agoSeems like selection bias for at work. I am curious how many of the subjects were pyscopaths. As a pyscopath, i agree with this experiment from what I've observed in wild, people almost always help to traiter and seek immunity regardless of the severity of the act.
- aaron695 8y ago> Turns out it could be wrong. > In his sharply reported article, "The Lifespan of a Lie," Ben Blum lays out why the Stanford Prison Experiment and its supposed conclusion could be bogus. It is a running joke that it was a shitty experiment. Could we just move on. https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-06-30 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2013-06-30
- Teletype 8y agoA friend of mine in my UNSW class was in this experiment ( 1973/4), and he told me afterwards that he always knew he could leave at any time. Of course, other Psych departments ( especially Skinner ) did not like social Psych, to put it mildly, and visa versa.
- austincheney 8y agoNormally, in science, reproducibility is an important qualifier. If an experiment cannot be reproduced its significance to science is low. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproducibility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproducibility People can come up with all kinds of personal reasons to qualify or disqualify an experiment that can never be reproduced, but these reasons are often not scientific and not related to the merits of the experiment.
- jaxtellerSoA 8y ago> in science, reproducibility is an important qualifier. News alert, an alarming large amount of scientific (published, accepted) experiments aren't reproduce-able. https://www.nature.com/news/1-500-scientists-lift-the-lid-on-reproducibility-1.19970 https://www.nature.com/news/1-500-scientists-lift-the-lid-on... https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-39054778 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-39054778
- austincheney 8y agoThen I will rephrase to say that in science an experiment gains superior trust and credibility when it is reproducible. Experiments that cannot be reproduced have less or no credibility.
- sn41 8y agoIt would be good if this were true, but this is just another shibboleth. Nothing done in the Large Hadron Collider is reproducible. Theoretically, yes. In practice, no. Only the LHC itself can run those experiments again, and there's always other new things to do. Ultimately, one major factor is the credentials of the experimenters. We may not like it, but some of the major experiments done today do boil down to "proof by authority".
- mAritz 8y agoThere are bigger, better, faster colliders in the works (I think) or will be planned. Won't they be able to reproduce it independently?
- mpax 8y agoWe have research publishing requirements in academia these days, which puts quantity over quality of research. I think we should swap those with required replication studies of published results.
- throw2016 8y agoThis is yet more evidence of the reproducibility crisis and raises serious questions of the quality of peer review. Clearly the system needs urgent reform, especially studies that present controversial or extraordinary findings. For decades this study has been used in discussion 'as fact' and while there is no evidence it was used in formulating policy given policy drafters and makers frequently refer to research it is quite possible it was and that is a dangerous end result.
- dalbasal 8y agoI would throw in a long term view here. Karl Poppers work on scientific epistemology created a big chunk of the modern, working scientific method. His big concern was unfalsifiable theories. The two big targets he was aiming at were Marx & Freud. Marxism (also other political theories) became more philosphically oriented and stopped calling their theories scientific. Psychology/psychiatry adopted more scientific methods of enquiry. Still, we have serious quality issues in the field(s).
- V-2 8y agoThe experiment was criticized (convincingly) in "The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness" by Erich Fromm. Even without bringing any hitherto unknown evidence in, it's not difficult to see its various flaws.
- chasd00 8y agoI have two very rule-testy boys aged 6 and 8 and it would be fascinating to watch them wheel and deal for what they want if it weren't so GD frustrating at the same time. My 8 year old is very much my way or the highway and will fight tooth and nail. The 6 year old, from dealing with his quick to fight older brother, is much more open to negotiation but very sly and manipulative. I consider it karma realignment because they're exactly like I was as a child. My poor mother has asked me more than once ".. now do you understand?" Heh
- JoeAltmaier 8y ago8 or 9 is old enough to just talk about this behavior? "We fight about everything like such and such. What can we do instead of that? If we continue to fight, will our relationship get better or worse?"
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoIt was what it was. There were things to learn from it. This blame game is not especially helpful?
- ganoushoreilly 8y agoIt's less about the blame game, more on the changed circumstances around the end results. When the experiment has become a standard and referenced within a field with purportedly incorrect or nonfactual information.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoReally? Wasn't it discredited decades ago? All that remains is sensationalist articles about who knew what, when.
- olavk 8y agoBut if the experiment was flawed we might learn the wrong things from it.