10 ms·
They Don't Build Them Like They Used To: The New Construction Shortage
- acconrad 8y agoInventory is up as well in many locations: https://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2018/08/lawler-few-hot-markets-home-inventories.html https://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2018/08/lawler-few-hot-ma... Signs are pointing toward a correction in the home price insanity, hopefully this will make things more affordable for everyone.
- germinalphrase 8y agoI admit that I don’t have a deep understanding of the real estate market; however, from what I’ve heard the (temporary) reduction of prices in 2008 was largely a unique situation. The reinflation of prices since then would suggest that gov’t doesn’t want to see prices go down significantly (for a variety of reasons) and so it is more likely that prices will simply plateau (and be made more affordable long term by inflating away home values without impact dollar amount to purchase). Thoughts?
- burlesona 8y agoI could buy that devaluation via inflation is coming, and maybe even that the government prefer it, but I’m skeptical that they have the ability to actually do that. Rather it’s more like the fed pushes its buttons and prays.
- johnvanommen 8y agoIt's already happening, but the Fed isn't doing it. Here's what's happening: 1) Trump put tariffs on Chinese imports 2) The Chinese retaliated by devaluing their currency, to negate the effect of the tariffs 3) This had the net effect of strengthening the US dollar That's why home prices are flat-ish in 2018.
- prewett 8y agoHow does a strong dollar affect home prices in the US? The exchange rate only matter when importing something, and you aren't importing anything when you buy a house in the US denominated in USD. Besides, the RMB hasn't been devalued (as in the standard definition, which is creating a new currency and dropping a few zeros). It has risen from 6.29 RMB to 1 USD in April to 6.86 today, but that is +10% and the tariffs are +25%. But a year ago the RMB was 6.68, so the year-over-year increase is +2.6%. Of the four assertions, only #1 is correct.
- mywittyname 8y agoLabor prices must be set in USD. So during a strong dollar, the cost of labor relative becomes the dominant factor in the price of new houses, since material goods can be imported. This makes it difficult/impossible to reduce the cost of a new house by just building smaller houses, since the marginal cost in terms of labor is lower, i.e., installing 30 outlets in a house costs much less than twice the cost of installing 15; only the material costs are doubled. This is ignoring the fact that a strong dollar makes real estate in the US a much, much more attractive investment. Not only do you get a decent appreciation in real value if you own in a desirable areas, but you also enjoy the relative appreciation in value relative to the currency you buy goods in. Chinese investors holding real estate in the coastal USA have done quite well in the past decade.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- davemp 8y agoLooks like a steady increase from the '08 crash. I don't really see the issue.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- schaefer 8y agoI would like the author to show me on a map where they plan to fit an additional 173,000 single family homes in Washington D.C...
- mikeash 8y agoThey’re referring to the entire metro area there.
- pastor_elm 8y agonational arboretum is around 400 acres. Rock Creek Park almost 2000 acres.
- navane 8y agoWhy would he not show the trend up untill 2008 on the graph "Permits per 1,000 new residents in previous 12 months"? That seems shady graphing.
- cascom 8y agoIt seems like these charts are for single family homes only? So a new apartment building wouldn’t be included? If so, that would seem to tell part of the story?
- burlesona 8y ago> People can also shift from single-family to multi-family residences. However the share of households in single-unit structures is 61.5 percent — virtually unchanged from 60.3 percent in 2000, which indicates that no such shift has occurred.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThat graph is pretty useless by only focusing on single family homes in metropolitan areas. Single family homes may hold nationwide as a housing growth indicator but one would expect mature and rising cities to have more multifamily residences even if they had a space boon from obsolete industrial jobs move elsewhere due to urban areas providing less of an advantage due to high numbers of workers being less needed with increased automation. Similarly sixteen high rise permits would do more for housing than one hundred sixty single family homes despite there technically being fewer new construction permits - evem though they would rightfully be more involved in making sure it wouldn't cause disaster. While I do not doubt that many urban areas have a housing shortage that isn't very good evidence given the caveats.
- rootusrootus 8y agoCondominiums each get their own set of permits. Most importantly, just like a single family house, they each have to be issued a Certificate of Occupancy.
- quantgenius 8y agoThis depends on the market. This is definitely not the case in NYC
- Spooky23 8y agoHuh? The NYS Attorney General approves all condos separate from the local building permitting process.
- mdorazio 8y agoI'm not following what your point is. If I'm reading the first table in [1] correctly, 20+ unit condo (and maybe apartment?) complex new construction starts have been declining annually while single-family home construction has been increasing. This seems to support the parent comment's argument that growth indicators are out of alignment with what markets actually need. [1] https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/quarterly_starts_completions.pdf https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/quarterly_starts...
- deedubaya 8y agoI'm in an isolated market, but I recently priced out a new build of a single family home. Bids between contractors fluctuated by over $200,000 for the same sets of plans on the same lot. Their excuse was high demand for sub-contractors that would work on the project that was paying the highest. - done well - done on time - done within budget Pick two.
- AstralStorm 8y agoFor the customer, number 2 would be the best to skip, but it is the worst for the developer as they cannot really sell an unbuilt house easily, while they get to pay the debt or such leverage plus construction company. They also cannot do 3 as the budgets are super tight already.
- adventured 8y agoIt's interesting to see the pre-built / manufactured home business is only finally starting to pick up sales again after imploding post year 2000. We used to see 350k manufactured home units sold per year in the US throughout the 1990s. That fell to ~50,000 for '09-'12. Now back up to 100k units again. There used to be a stigma about these types of homes in regards to quality. I was surprised at how relatively nice they are now, looking at the Clayton Homes site (a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway). I would think these types of inexpensive housing units are a critical element to relieving the US housing shortage again. https://www.bloombergquint.com/business/2018/08/16/cheap-and-sleek-manufactured-housing-is-primed-for-a-comeback https://www.bloombergquint.com/business/2018/08/16/cheap-and...
- briffle 8y agoThere is a middle ground too, prefab homes, where the walls, floors, etc, are all built off-site in a factory, and then shipped to your location in sections. It allows for faster building (can go from foundation to roof on and siding up in 2 days) and in theory, much cheaper costs.. Currently, most roof trusses are already built this way, but all walls, flooring, etc, electrical, plumbing, etc, are all custom done on site, meaning much higher costs. However, the hi-end companies I was looking at when I last looked were much more focused on the speed, then the cost efficiencies.
- TheTaytay 8y agoThis was my experience as well when I thought, "Gosh, $200/sq ft seems too high for a home. I bet someone could do well building them off-site, shipping them to me, and bolting them together on-site." As it turns out, $200/sq ft appears to be the _minimum_ of prefabs these days. Cost savings is not the benefit from what I could tell. Reduced waste, sure, but not reduced cost.
- mywittyname 8y agoI think a lot of areas still have regulations in place that prevent manufactured homes from being built/installed in a neighborhood. I grew up in a region where these were incredibly common. Most of my friends grew up on one of these (doublewides, as they were called). They were actually very nice, the build quality was decent, it was incredibly spacious for the price, and they could be installed pretty fast. For about $60-70k in '95 dollars (105-120k today) a family could live in a brand new 2200 sq. ft. house on 2.5 acres of land.
- floatingatoll 8y agoIt’s disappointing to see Zillow ignore the wage pressures that are reducing housing demand nationwide. Permits are decreasing per growth capita because that segment can no longer afford houses.
- Symmetry 8y agoIf housing demand was going down then housing prices would be going down. That's not what we see except in certain markets such as Detroit.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If housing demand was going down then housing prices would be going down. Assuming supply (in the economic sense) was constant; if supply was dropping, then prices could go up even with demand dropping.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoI don't know if you're expert, but I'm curious: What's the push/pull balance between destruction/abandonment of old homes vs. construction of new homes vs. constant habitation of the existing homes? I guess I'm asking is the effective amount of houses on the market stable, decreasing, or increasing? Also, relative to number of people looking for homes, what's the situation?
- floatingatoll 8y agoThere are a lot of assumptions coded into this, not the least of which being “mortgage lenders only approve applicants with sufficient wages”, which has repeatedly been proven false over the years. Our housing market is not as rational as your statement implies.
- Symmetry 8y agoHuh? The only thing I'm assuming is that sellers try to get the highest price possible and buyers try to get the lowest. If the existence of loans made buyers stop caring about the price of homes then it would be relevant but everybody I've seen homebuying still cares deeply about the price despite paying for it by loan.
- Finnucane 8y agoI find it sort of odd that they feel that keeping an existing house longer is a bad thing. The house I live in now was built in the 1850's, and I lived for a while in a house from the 1780s. The main drawback is you have to get used to there being no level surfaces or right angles.
- Symmetry 8y agoIt's great to keep old houses but unless the population stops growing you need to build new ones for people to live in. Well, they can keep living with their parents but most people want to move out.
- Finnucane 8y agoSure, but what the article is suggesting is that older houses should be torn down and replaced, by another single family home. So it doesn't really add to the housing stock to do that.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoIsn't the main drawback that there is a lot of maintenance needed on old houses? I worked many hours on a fixer upper built around 1900 by an amateur homebuilder. It's incredibly frustrating that every single change you want to make to windows, doors, or anything is complicated by non-right angles. It increased the time required for basic repairs by 2-fold, so much re-doing needed to get even a mediocre fit, never mind a great fit.
- munificent 8y agoI've lived in houses built in the 40s and 90s. I would take the former any day of the week. I'm not generally a "they don't build them like they used to kind of person", but my experience with houses is that older homes were built to last while newer ones are just built to sell. Of course, there's probably some survivorship bias there. All the shitty homes from the 40s are gone now.
- Finnucane 8y ago
- 394549 8y agotl;dr: homebuildling activity is still depressed from its 2008 high.
- joshuaheard 8y agoNo mention of stricter mortgage requirements resulting from '08 crash? Lower demand = lower supply.
- chucksmash 8y agoThis related blog post is an interesting read: Building Affordable Housing: Where Has the Entry Level House Gone? http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2016/08/building-affordable-housing-where-has.html?m=1 http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2016/08/building-affordable-...
- mywittyname 8y agoThis kind of highlights a huge issue with being poor: lack of mobility. If people with modest budgets could afford to pack up and move to Columbia, Missouri, then the cost burden of housing could be mitigated somewhat. We'd probably see housing prices stabilize across the country. As it stands, only wealthy people can afford to migrate across the country, usually in pursuit of even more wealth. This just adds to the problem because it results in more dollars chasing a supply of existing houses that isn't expanding rapidly enough. Probably, the only way to reverse this trend now is to raise property taxes on single family homes in desirable locations such that it becomes uneconomical to maintain them as such. Then these massive tracts of suburbia can be bought up by developers who are incentivized to build high-density housing. Of course, a serious proposal of this sort is likely to get you killed.
- chucksmash 8y agoHeh, not to be the guy posting urbankchoze links all day but the author has thoughts on this as well actually[0]. The whole article is a good read but the thing that feels most pertinent is the idea of dynamic zoning; instead of zoning an area for single family residential you'd essentially zone areas such that new construction rules would be: - allowed_height = max(2, ceil(avg_area_height * 1.5)) - allowed_occupancy = ceil(avg_area_occupancy * 1.5) And then without the need for zoning exemptions and political zoning fights, you let neighborhoods up zone themselves organically based on demand. Average building two stories? You can build a three story low rise. Average height three stories? You can build a five story replacement. I think lowering the barriers to higher density in-fill would effectively accomplish what you're aiming for while side stepping some of the political issues you've foreseen with raising taxes on people until they're forced to leave their homes. [0]: http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/05/how-to-make-urban-housing-more_7.html?m=1 http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/05/how-to-make-urban-ho...
- drpentode 8y agoHere's an unexplored possibility: What if the places with room to build single-family homes are too far away from where people work? If the commute is too long, people might prefer to stay where they are.
- gwbas1c 8y agoI just built a home. There's a lot of out of control factors that make it harder to build. "Historic districts" are basically ways to add extra red tape for the NIMBYs. HOAs are now more common and also add red tape for NIMBYs. Environmental changes for energy efficiency aren't always funded by banks. One of the things we need is to abolish things like HOAs and historic districts; and then reform lending so it will fund environmentally-friendly building codes.
- scaryspooky 8y agoBuilding codes themselves are driven by industry and manufacturers. This has been a huge driver for the increase in size of house, compare a 1960s era bathroom against modern code and you will find the increase in minimum sizes dramatic.