10 ms·
Dietary carbohydrate intake and mortality: a prospective cohort study
- olalonde 8y agoSome interesting discussion on /r/keto: https://www.reddit.com/r/keto/comments/97zwph/science_bbc_lowcarb_diets_could_shorten_life/ https://www.reddit.com/r/keto/comments/97zwph/science_bbc_lo...
- nonbel 8y agoFrom a comment there: >'The findings "will disappoint those who, from professional experience, will continue to defend their low carb cult, but contributes to the overwhelming body of evidence that supports a balanced approach to caloric intake recommended globally by public health bodies," Collins added.' https://www.cnn.com/2018/08/17/health/low-carb-high-carbohydrate-diet-risk-of-death-intl/ https://www.cnn.com/2018/08/17/health/low-carb-high-carbohyd... Given the obvious problems with this study (their definition of "low carb" is wrong), this is just an astounding display of hubris.
- davidmr 8y agoThat to me read more as CNN getting someone uninvolved in the research to give a quote that makes for good copy. I agree that it's not a particularly useful thing to say, but it's important to note that Collins is not involved in the core study.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 8y agoThis should be the top comment. And 37% is not low-carb. If anything what this shows is that if you have moderate carbs, you won't be doing so well. But if you have moderate carbs + more plant-based food, you'll be healthier. So all this study showed has nothing to do with carbs, but everything to do with eating more veggies = you'll be healthier. I bet that if had they replaced not just part of the meat/animal fat with veggies, but also another 20% of those "low carbs", they would've gotten even healthier people (and on an actual low-carb diet, too!).
- nonbel 8y agoLook at their figure 1, it cuts off at 20% energy from carbohydrates. I don't think there was a single person in this study on an actual low carb diet.
- pestkranker 8y agoIt is really great to see more studies regarding low carbs diets. They are widely used in the fitness industry based on ‘Broscience’ and many Instagram models are paid to promote this kind of lifestyle.
- mattmanser 8y agoWhat's eye opening about this as well is low carb diets lose you 4 years of life, compared to 1 year of life in a high carb diet. we estimated that a 50-year-old participant with intake of less than 30% of energy from carbohydrate would have a projected life expectancy of 29·1 years, compared with 33·1 years for a participant who consumed 50–55% of energy from carbohydrate (difference 4·0 years [95% CI 2·6, 5·3]). Similarly, we estimated that a 50-year-old participant with high carbohydrate intake (>65% of energy from carbohydrate) would have a projected life expectancy of 32·0 years, compared with 33·1 years
- lylecubed 8y agoThis is far more interesting... So, the "low Carb group" (Q1): had higher % of smokers, had higher % of diabetics, exercised less, had higher % of men. I don't trust the study results at all.
- anewone 8y agoIt's possible to control for these factors by adjusting your expected outcomes accordingly. Not saying they did since I haven't bothered to read the study though.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- totemizer 8y agoNo, it means that the people who were compelled to follow a low carbohydrate diet for one reason on another lived shorter. It doesn't tell you anything unless you know why they followed the diet they followed.
- Leary 8y agoNote this from this study: "Low carbohydrate dietary patterns favouring animal-derived protein and fat sources, from sources such as lamb, beef, pork, and chicken, were associated with higher mortality, whereas those that favoured plant-derived protein and fat intake, from sources such as vegetables, nuts, peanut butter, and whole-grain breads, were associated with lower mortality" So if you want low carbs, don't eat too much meat. Plant based diets, such as the Mediterranean diet have been shown lead to reduced all cause mortality in randomized control trials [1]. Getting your diet right really isn't that hard, just eat fresh plant based food. [1]https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1800389?query=featured_home https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1800389?query=fe...
- totemizer 8y agoI really wish to know why those people were on low carbohydrate diet though. It seems to me that most people don't do that without a good reason.
- nightski 8y agoWell, anecdotally for me it is just because of how I feel on such a diet. It takes a while for the body to adjust, but once it does I feel like I am on a high that never ends. No ups & downs, just pure focus and energy. Would it be like that for everyone? Who knows. But I have never felt this before on any other diet. That's why I stick with it. (Note I do about 5% carbs, 80% fat, 15% protein) Even if this ends up with higher mortality (which I highly doubt this claim, there is a lot of research and results it is in conflict with) - I'd rather live feeling like this than the alternative. I also question the meat claims because there is also a lot of evidence to the contrary. It seems like there may be a confounding variable in there that is skewing the results.
- nonbel 8y ago>"I really wish to know why those people were on low carbohydrate diet though." They weren't. It looks like the lowest in the study was ~20%, which is about the upper bound on what could be considered "low carb".
- nefasti 8y agoSorry, but I stopped reading here “who completed a dietary questionnaire”
- std_throwaway 8y agoWho uses a certain (previously uncommon) diet that is said to help with diabetes and other serious issues? Those who are of average good health or those who experience some issues that already start to manifest? I wonder if the study corrects for those factors. Does the average person even participate in those studies? We really need multiple long-running (50+ years) randomized study that controls for all influence factors to really answer the questions. Something that is unlikely to be accomplished in our current political lifetime and unlikely to be completed within our lifetime.
- nonbel 8y ago> "We really need multiple long-running (50+ years) randomized study that controls for all influence factors to really answer the questions. Something that is unlikely to be accomplished in our current political lifetime and unlikely to be completed within our lifetime." This would be a waste of money. Its not going to tell you anything about the effect of diet in any real people, only "average" people.
- not_weev 8y agoIndeed. Show me the goddamn biochemistry, not this cargo cult pseudoscience.
- davidmr 8y agoWhat specific quantitative reasons do you have to suggest a questionnaire is not appropriate for this type of study? Did I miss some other study somewhere that suggests a questionnaire can never produce good science?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThat's how most dietarey studies are conducted, including ones contradicting this study. It's not that this kind of study is very accurate; but it's nearly impossible to conduct a study of peoples' diet that will be more accurate.
- throwawaylalala 8y ago37% of your dietary intake from carbs is not low carb.
- dbcurtis 8y agoTrue, but how many people are below 37%? They are not if they eat a typical American diet.
- lawn 8y agoMost people aren't on low carbs no.
- boltzmannbrain 8y ago+1. Keto is vastly lower, typically 5%. Someone eating a 37% carb diet will receive none of the health benefits that spending substantial periods in ketosis can bring, e.g. lowering cholesterol.
- anewone 8y agoAlternatively: the study was about "low carb", while keto is "extremely low carb".
- Phantasmagoria 8y agoBut it appears people are slandering keto with this study so.
- nonbel 8y agoId say the highest you could possibly call "low carb" is ~100 g/day. That'd be ~400 cal/day, or 20% of a 2000 cal/day diet. And really 100 g/day is a lot. Most people on "low carb" diets are going to be eating half or a quarter of that. So, this is just more ridiculous nutrition research funded by the US government, produced by academia.
- 8y ago
- GateCrasher 8y agoSo overweight people (high carbohydrate),and people with dietary restrictions (for whatever reason) have a lower lifespan. Shocking.
- nurblieh 8y agoIf you're looking to make dietary choices based on the results of high-quality dietary studies, my goto is "How Not to Die"[1] and the author's non-profit website at, http://nutritionfacts.org http://nutritionfacts.org [1] https://www.amazon.com/How-Not-Die-Discover-Scientifically/dp/1250066115 https://www.amazon.com/How-Not-Die-Discover-Scientifically/d...
- mrnobody_67 8y agoI found that the author used a lot of animal/mouse studies to draw conclusions and make recommendations... most things that work in mice, don't work in humans.
- nurblieh 8y agoIn my experience the author avoids animal/mouse based studies if at all possible. He mentions only those that are frequently cited so as to address their results.
- StavrosK 8y agoDoes anyone have a summary?
- mrnobody_67 8y agoSo the 18 month Keto diet I've been on has been lowering my lifespan? At least I'll look good in the open casket.
- inawarminister 8y agoThis study's definition of low carb diet doesn't reach ketosis though. I do want a proper study on a keto diet, on one hand it's an unnatural biochemical process for the majority of non-starving humanity, on the other hand there seems to be no downside to ketosis under than the Flu in the short term.
- theprotocol 8y agoResults vary so widely in this field. My general understanding is: • Polyunsaturated fats, the supposedly "good" fats in the classical model, actually go rancid really easily and cause damage. • Saturated fats are associated with high cholesterol, which is a marker of some misunderstood kind of arterial and vascular inflammation. Not everyone gets an increase in cholesterol from consuming saturated fats, and we don't know why. It may be determined by the intestinal flora. But these "bad" fats are actually very stable, and do not appear to cause damage via oxidation as they don't go rancid easily. • Monounsaturated fats have the best qualities of both. tl;dr (imho): Have some of everything in moderation and with the due awareness of what you're having vs. your particular body. Consume limited PUFA and be very aware of the potential rancidness vs. the effectiveness of antioxidants present in the source. Whole foods with antioxidants e.g. fruits tend to mitigate the oxidation of any PUFA that they contain. Consume limited saturated fat as per your propensity for LDL. You can't go wrong with monounsaturated fats, which are relatively stable and tend to come in high-antioxidant sources, and also do not cause LDL to rise. But overall, eat a moderate amount of fat. Don't go too low carb as it causes a stress state (cortisol + damage-inducing free fatty acids). Get your carbs from buffered, whole food sources (e.g. fruits, whole wheat bread), but don't go high carb because it's damaging. Have as much fiber (incl. resistant starches / FOS / FODMAP / "soluble fiber") as you can stomach. If they make you feel especially sick, you probably have gut fermentation (SIBO or similar). Some people like myself cannot tolerate anything fermentable. Be aware of your idiosyncrasies, e.g. I can't tolerate histamines, so I must avoid high histamine or histamine-releasing foods like avocado, as well as anything fermentable or fermented. Moderate exercise is superior to intense exercise. Exercise that is too intense is damaging and is linked with poorer health.
- agumonkey 8y agoI asked above but since you seem to be knowledgeable, I'm looking for some super solid textbooks on fats/fatty acids. Because as you say, you can read contradictory statements in different books.
- theprotocol 8y agoSorry, I don't know of any books that I can recommend. I don't read health books. I find they require too big an investment in a single source.
- shanev 8y ago“There are limitations to this study that merit consideration. This study represents observational data and is not a clinical trial; however, randomised trials of low carbohydrate diets on mortality are not practical because of the long duration of study required. Another limitation of this study is that diet was only assessed at two time intervals, spanning a 6-year period, and dietary patterns could change during 25 years.” This study is based on a 66 question FFQ (food frequency questionnaire) spanning a six year period. Do you remember what you ate last month? A year ago? Six years ago? Maybe a more modern version of these types of studies can be done if the subjects are required to take pics of everything they ate instead of reporting from memory on a questionnaire. “LMS receives grant funding from the California Walnut Commission” Oh? “SC reports grants from the National Institutes of Health (NIH), and personal fees from Novartis and Zogenix” Novartis and Zofenix are in the business of making statin drugs.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI know the majority of those who read that study will either ignore it, dismiss it out of hand, or "study it carefully" and find all sorts of problems with it, the best to convince themselves that it's not conclusive, or that it's badly designed and its results can't be trusted, etc. The truth is, it is extremely hard to accept that something that directly hits your fabled pleasure centers -like fat, sugar, salt, nicotine, alcohol etc- is so bad for you it's decreasing the time you have to enjoy it. There is an extreme form of denial that seizes the human mind when someone tells you "this thing you really like, it's very bad for you". Our pleasures are immense sources of bias. Take what your heart desires with, um, a huge pinch of salt and don't listen to the people who tell you salt, fat, sugar, smoking, drinking etc are good for you when this contradicts years of research and hundreds of trials, especialy when the evidence for keeping your dietary habits unchanged is based on a couple of studies with poor practices and few participants.
- nonbel 8y agoSorry, but there is really no debate about this study. Their definition of "low-carb" is not the one used by people who are adopting a "low carb" diet, so there is no reason to think their conclusions apply.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI think "the people who adopt a low-card diet" would do well to pay attention to a study that reports increased mortality for people who reduced their carbohydrate intake less than they have. If a moderate reduction of carbohydrates in your diet is bad for you, almost entirely eliminating them does not look very promising.
- nonbel 8y ago>"If a moderate reduction of carbohydrates in your diet is bad for you, almost entirely eliminating them does not look very promising." Why?
- 8y ago