5 ms·
Anti-immigration people in various countries often argue that they just want to prevent “bad ones” coming in, they’re not looking to throw out the “good ones”.
by pavlov 8y ago
Anti-immigration people in various countries often argue that they just want to prevent “bad ones” coming in, they’re not looking to throw out the “good ones”.
The reality is that there’s no leniency for perceived good immigrants as these people imagine, and it’s just getting worse as immigration policies are tightened across Europe. Officials are under pressure to refuse as many applications as they can, and it’s easiest in cases like this where you can hide behind a legality. The “good ones” are the first to suffer.
- cm2187 8y agoI don't think what triggered Brexit was "bad immigration". The wave of immigration that triggered the reaction was mostly a polish immigration that integrated well. I think the problem was rather too much immigration.
- nutjob2 8y agoThis is not Europe wide. I have current and first hand experience of two EU countries in this regard and nothing has changed in the last couple of years. In any system mistakes are made on both sides of an application and most countries have reasonable systems to resolve them, but in the case of the UK authorities, they are no longer acting in good faith.
- ethbro 8y ago> no longer acting in good faith This seems to be the greatest legal casualty of anti-immigrant rhetoric -- cover for bureaucratic apathy. Maybe the author of the initial decision acted with malicious intent. But I'd bet they just didn't care and certified it that way so as to not have the case boomerang back to them. And the political climate gave them flexibility to do so. The only defense against this seems like a more robust, independent version of a Dean of Students, albeit for everyone interfacing with the legal system. Empowered to bring action against egregious ethical or moral breaches. The legal profession seems to have no inclination to weed out those lacking ethical standards, so tragedies like Aaron Schwartz go unpunished. Carmen Ortiz, who oversaw the prosecution as US A, now practices law in the private sector. [1] I get that handling lots of cases with limited resources is difficult. But when you fuck up, and then insist you were right rather than act with some compassion? There should be consequences. [1] http://www.andersonkreiger.com/attorney/carmen-m-ortiz/ http://www.andersonkreiger.com/attorney/carmen-m-ortiz/
- duxup 8y agoIn the US they explicitly have stopped targeting those with serious criminal violations in favor of whomever they come across. If anything that would seem to mean fewer resources are dedicated to serious criminal situations in favor of the low hanging fruit of someone with a current address and some minor issue years ago.... Effectively this seems to be the opposite of targeting serious criminals.
- conjectures 8y agoYup. I think a lot of this is Goodhart's law in action. You measure a bureaucracy's effectiveness by how many people it can kick out / refuse and this is what happens. The guy unfortunately represented easy deportation points due to making an honest mistake. No discretion was used because of the above. The practical solution is to use a good immigration lawyer for stuff like this. It sucks, it's unfair, but it's true.
- cm2187 8y agoAgree. I am not aware of any hostility toward US immigration in the UK, this is just the Home Office being bureaucratically unhelpful. Having gone through the naturalisation process myself after the Brexit vote, and without a lawyer, I can confirm that even for EU nationals the rules are as clear as mud. And the fees are clearly designed to prevent a cleaning lady from applying.
- dmix 8y agoThere are plenty of gov agencies where 95+% of the time they deal with 'bad' people that they become very ill equipped (or mentally unprepared) to deal with the odd 'good' one when they come by. So the whole system becomes a cynical exercise, as they get so deluged with people forever fighting to game the system that they forget that good honest people still get forced through their meat grinder. Or they simply suck at 'customer service' like the classic DMV-worker cliches. These are often failures of systems rather than some high-level racism or xenophobia by politicians. As they exist in a variety of agencies across every western countries, even the super liberal ones. The problem is a hard one to solve, as the operations of these agencies often gets left on the wayside, regardless of national debates. This lawyer in the article is dealing with the lowest tier, not-giving-a-shit type of government workers, who are likely underfunded, poorly staffed, with plenty of pressure on both ends - just like most gov agencies. That is a system detached from the latest populist outrage. Remember this whole story started by the guy getting the wrong 'form' when he applied. I'm sure plenty of conservatives would be interested in fixing this particular failure and having a more efficient (and accurate) immigration system.