9 ms·
What happens if you mistakenly apply for British citizenship?
- tinktank 8y agoCan't say I'm surprised by this outcome at all. The British government has long since been screwing over would be immigrants in fees, bureaucracy and rules. The point to note is -- had he not been an American with resources, and instead, say a Somali refugee, the outcome would have been very different and we'd never have heard about it. For those of you interested in how validated legal extortion can become, go look at the VISA and naturalisation fees the UK government charges.
- throwaway8689 8y agoHow is it extortion if you are not forced to visit or migrate to the UK? For context, cost of settlement is similar to what the Philippines charges. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/visa-regulations-revised-table https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/visa-regulations-...
- xaranke 8y agoAs someone who recently applied for a UK Visa, I was shocked that it cost around $120 for 6 months. A comparable US visa for 10 years costs around $160.
- cm2187 8y agoThat's nothing. Citizenship costs over £1000.
- personjerry 8y agoI don’t think the government did anything wrong; The rules aren’t meant to be bent, and if Lucas made a mistake in filing the wrong paperwork, it absolutely makes sense for the consequences to follow. In these serious legal matters, you need to seek counsel. This article attempts to paint a picture of the poor child, but the law was clear, and any emotional appeal should be invalid.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoWell, I don't know the details of British law on this, but the German constitution has as its first article "Human dignity is unviolable. To respect it and to protect it is the duty of all institutions of the state." So, not bending the rules in such cases would actually potentially be illegal. If there is no such rule in place in the UK, then that is where the government did something wrong.
- smikhanov 8y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if in addition to your “the complex and opaque rules are there for everyone to follow without any leeway for a mistake, period” philosophy you also practice cannibalism.
- blattimwind 8y ago"Indefinite leave to remain" sounds like some almost Orwellian concoction of meaninglessness to me. How exactly do you get from "permission to stay in the country" (aha, it means one has the permission to stay in the country) to "indefinite leave to remain" (uhm... to remain here, I need to leave indefinitely?)
- avar 8y agoThis is just what the UK calls permanent residency: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permanent_residency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permanent_residency
- gsnedders 8y agoAnd admission to the country on a temporary basis is done by granting leave to remain (v. indefinite leave to remain).
- ksdale 8y ago"Leave" in this instance means "permission" rather than "exit"
- vidarh 8y ago"leave" as a noun that means roughly "permission" and the verb form of "leave" to mean "depart" both comes from Old English words (the noun form from "leafe", the verb form from "læfan") that has meanings closer to the noun form ("permission"), but the meaning of the noun form is older, as the verb form first took on the modern meaning ca. 1200.
- jccooper 8y agoYou do know that's "leave" as a noun, meaning "permission", right? It's a bit formal, but this is a government office we're talking about.
- Rexxar 8y agoMeta comment: "blattimwind" comment is grey at the moment. What is the point to down vote someone that has just misunderstood an arguably ambiguous expression ?
- pavlov 8y agoAnti-immigration people in various countries often argue that they just want to prevent “bad ones” coming in, they’re not looking to throw out the “good ones”. The reality is that there’s no leniency for perceived good immigrants as these people imagine, and it’s just getting worse as immigration policies are tightened across Europe. Officials are under pressure to refuse as many applications as they can, and it’s easiest in cases like this where you can hide behind a legality. The “good ones” are the first to suffer.
- cm2187 8y agoI don't think what triggered Brexit was "bad immigration". The wave of immigration that triggered the reaction was mostly a polish immigration that integrated well. I think the problem was rather too much immigration.
- nutjob2 8y agoThis is not Europe wide. I have current and first hand experience of two EU countries in this regard and nothing has changed in the last couple of years. In any system mistakes are made on both sides of an application and most countries have reasonable systems to resolve them, but in the case of the UK authorities, they are no longer acting in good faith.
- ethbro 8y ago> no longer acting in good faith This seems to be the greatest legal casualty of anti-immigrant rhetoric -- cover for bureaucratic apathy. Maybe the author of the initial decision acted with malicious intent. But I'd bet they just didn't care and certified it that way so as to not have the case boomerang back to them. And the political climate gave them flexibility to do so. The only defense against this seems like a more robust, independent version of a Dean of Students, albeit for everyone interfacing with the legal system. Empowered to bring action against egregious ethical or moral breaches. The legal profession seems to have no inclination to weed out those lacking ethical standards, so tragedies like Aaron Schwartz go unpunished. Carmen Ortiz, who oversaw the prosecution as US A, now practices law in the private sector. [1] I get that handling lots of cases with limited resources is difficult. But when you fuck up, and then insist you were right rather than act with some compassion? There should be consequences. [1] http://www.andersonkreiger.com/attorney/carmen-m-ortiz/ http://www.andersonkreiger.com/attorney/carmen-m-ortiz/
- jarym 8y agoThere are two* UK government departments that are full of incompetent decision makers and absolutely no culture of common sense or doing the right thing: 1. The Home Office 2. HMRC (aka Her Majesty’s arseholes) This doesn’t surprise me. I honestly am begining to think that change will only come once senior civil servants meet a dose of mob justice. The public’s tolerance is at breaking point imo. *at minimum
- DanBC 8y agoHMRC are better than DWP.
- caiob 8y agoIs there something about English-speaking countries that make them behave like dicks when it comes to immigration?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe same reason that people living in nice neighborhoods with nice houses don't invite all the people living in the slums to come live with them. This happens in non-English speaking countries also.
- caiob 8y agoMind providing an example?
- i_am_nomad 8y agoJapan. South Korea. Switzerland.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoMy point is people all over the world with high quality of life don't want to lower their quality of life to benefit others. It happens on a city level, state level, country level, and global level. With sufficient resources, you can buy access to all countries, just like you can move to the nice part of town.
- matz1 8y agoWell, for example, my neighborhood. Wherever that is.
- mrec 8y agoDunno. They might just be more popular destinations to immigrate to, being (mostly) stable and rich, and English being one of the more common second languages around the world.
- Havoc 8y agoOthers aren't much better frankly. The German process was pretty much "Sit tight, don't ask for updates...oh and it may take 2 years" (It did).
- nutjob2 8y agoThis is par for the course in the UK right now. The Tories have been pandering to the xenophobes and racists for some time now an their "hostile environment" for immigrants isn't restricted to ones who are doing something illegal, instead it seems to be targeted toward making life miserable, if not impossible for any immigrants wether they're doing the right thing or not. They have no problems breaking their own rules and aggressively using the courts (appealing cases and then withdrawing their claims the day before the hearing, for instance). In the case of the Windrush Generation, who just happen to be black, the Home Office destroyed archives that contained proof of eligibility of residence, against their own rules, that caused people to become destitute and/or deported when the government wrongly took away their rights: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-43782241 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-43782241 This poor guy should be thankful that the government didn't deem him a terrorist and ruin his life completely: https://qz.com/1275866/the-british-government-is-using-simple-tax-errors-as-a-reason-to-deport-migrants/ https://qz.com/1275866/the-british-government-is-using-simpl...
- chrisseaton 8y ago> The Tories have been pandering to the xenophobes and racists for some time now ... In the case of the Windrush Generation, who just happen to be black, the Home Office destroyed archives that contained proof of eligibility of residence Just to fact check this, https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-who-destroyed-the-windrush-landing-cards https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-who-destro..., it was a Labour-administrated Home Office that decided to destroy them, although it looks like it was a bureaucratic decision rather than a political one and probably no politicians knew anything about it.
- DanBC 8y agoThe hostile environment is definitely a Conservate thing though.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- Someone1234 8y agoI have experience with both the UK and US immigration systems. I agree, it is very easy with how complicated the processes can be to make mistakes, even seemingly big ones, just by misunderstanding a single requirement. Even non-immigration lawyers make serious errors. > Lucas made his application for naturalisation on 14 May 2014, a couple of weeks before the expiry of his visa. I'm playing devil's advocate here, but neither indefinite leave to remain OR naturalization would be processed in "a couple of weeks." So even if he had filled the right application he might have ran into problems. As the article points out, indefinite leave does technically extend their existing visa (whereas citizenship does not), but in both cases you have the same issue: If you're denied then you get deported since your visa has expired. They should have extended their existing visa first, only then apply for indefinite leave to remain or if eligible citizenship. Otherwise you've built a house of cards, which is one denial away from deportation. > So instead of Lucas’s application being promptly returned to him [...] It took eight months for him to receive a refusal of his application with the above explanation That exceeds the government's estimates, but they tell you before you apply it can take 6+ months: https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/uk-visas-and-immigration/about-our-services https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/uk-visas-and-imm... They don't even look at the application until it is processed, and there's a huge backlog. Plus they cannot deny until the application is fully vetted, otherwise they might miss another avenue for acceptance, or it might be a data problem their side. Essentially the article is complaining that the other applicants that applied before him were processed before him. It is unfortunate what happened to him after the initial mistake, and I won't defend that, but his mistake wasn't only applying for the wrong thing, he also left it until the last possible moment.
- comex 8y ago> Essentially the article is complaining that the other applicants that applied before him were processed before him. Only if you assume that the Home Office's capacity is fixed. I don't know any of the details myself, but presumably they could have avoided creating such long backlog by hiring more employees.
- tssva 8y ago
- Silixon 8y agoTuttle or Buttle, was it?
- jacknews 8y agoBureaucrats the world over are frustrating. It's surprising in some ways, since the thing that distinguishes government from the private sector is that government is optimized for safety, equality, impartiality, etc, rather than for profit. But perhaps the way they achieve such impartiality is by codifying absolutely every detail, and then you end up with situations like this one. Stepping back though, the British immigration system is indeed quite hostile. Possibly one reason may be that once you are 'in', you get automatic access to a huge array of valuable state services; free healthcare, schooling, etc. If you've ever lived in places that have none of these, you can really appreciate how valuable they are. And I think a 'solution' to that issue could be to have stricter controls on who gets access to all those services, but be less strict about who can come and stay - based on skills perhaps. And while they're at it they could make it easier for Britons who have married foreigners and had kids abroad, to be able to repatriate - as it is, it's more than a little difficult. I understand the rules are to prevent some the gross abuses that have occurred, eg recently-established Britons bringing in uneducated "wives" from foreign rural villages and so on, but they also deeply affect more legitimate situations.
- CPLX 8y agoI mean the British bureaucracy has an extremely well chronicled tradition of Kafkaesque obstinacy and causing chaos via slavish adherence to rules that long predates this issue right. I believe Douglas Adams used this fact as the basis for a series of books.
- andybak 8y ago(After finding out his home was scheduled for demolition and being told he'd had ample time to file a complaint) “But the plans were on display…” “On display? I eventually had to go down to the cellar to find them.” “That’s the display department.” “With a flashlight.” “Ah, well, the lights had probably gone.” “So had the stairs.” “But look, you found the notice, didn’t you?” “Yes,” said Arthur, “yes I did. It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying ‘Beware of the Leopard.”
- aluren 8y ago"Arthur reached out for the bedside light, not expecting it to come on. To his surprise it did. This appealed to Arthur’s sense of logic. Since the Electricity Board cut him off without fail every time he paid his bill, it seemed only reasonable that they should leave him connected when he didn’t. Sending them money obviously only drew attention to yourself." -from So Long and Thanks for All the Fish
- js2 8y agoAlso, Terry Gilliam's frustration with it boiled over into Brazil. https://youtu.be/nWbIxFKtTmE https://youtu.be/nWbIxFKtTmE
- jwilk 8y agoWhat a weird submission title ("Mistakenly apply for British citizenship instead of indefinite leave to remain"). The original title ("What happens if you mistakenly apply for British citizenship instead of indefinite leave to remain?") is probably too long for HN, but I'd rather shorten it to: "What happens if you mistakenly apply for British citizenship?"
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 8y agoThe context is important: mistakenly applying for citizenship in what circumstances, as opposed to what?
- mmsimanga 8y agoI speak as an immigrant. I see a lot of comments not being too kind to people who aren't welcoming of immigrants. As a person, I actually do understand. Not everyone is going to like me. As an African I do wish some of this energy would be directed to the African leaders that make their countries so terrible that someone feels it is better to jump on a rickety boat in search of a better life. These African "leaders" send their kids to school in the west, they go to the west when sick. I wish all this energy against people who don't want immigrants is directed at the people who made us immigrants in the first place. My first choice is a return to my country.
- tinktank 8y agoIt's much easier to hate on an individual in front of you than a president, policy, regime or country (and takes less effort). The bigger grind for me is that the same countries (UK in particular) hammering citizens from those countries welcome leaders with open arms and provide them with refuge, the ability to buy sheltered properties etc. The UKG loves nothing or nobody but money, I just wish they would be upfront about it so their policies were consistent with their actions.
- mmsimanga 8y ago100% with you. At some point, someone has to ask who/what is causing the immigrants. I know the answer isn't simple. Some will even say the West is caused all the issues in the first place. At some point though we have to start discussing concrete ways of changing the status quos and moving forward. Changing UK immigration laws might help a few of us get into the UK but not much will change in the home country. The same African dictators rigging elections are allowed to vote on UN resolutions and make grandstanding speeches at global conventions.
- tinktank 8y agoYes, that's the point I'm making. The west maintains the status quo because it's of benefit to them, they just don't want any of the side-effects (including increased migration). Colonization hasn't gone away, it's just changed form.
- ppod 8y agoI moved to the UK seven years ago, and have clearly noticed a change in the time I've been here. It wasn't perfect to begin with, but there is now a clear popular attitude against non-British people. It's worse against non-white people and eastern europeans, but there is also a level of general xenophobia. Of course, this is not the prevailing situation in London and cosmopolitan cities, but it is prevalent among the electorate, and the government and civil service is slowly starting to reflect that preference. I know people living in London will read this and claim it isn't true, but remember I'm talking about the country as a whole. Immigration is consistently ranked as the most important issue in opinion polls, and a large majority favour admitting "none" or "a few" from most countries. https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/uk-public-opinion-toward-immigration-overall-attitudes-and-level-of-concern/ https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/uk...
- lsd5you 8y agoPolls consistently show that Britain is one of the most tolerant countries in europe (debatable wether that is a good thing if it leads to intolerance in the long run ...) in any case I would suggest it is more likely the common language makes any alienation feel more raw. Alienated in a european country - can often be charitably put down to language differences (and learning the local language is a greater signal of integration when it's not english).
- vixen99 8y agoIf you look at the graph here https://www.migrationwatchuk.org/statistics-net-migration-statistics https://www.migrationwatchuk.org/statistics-net-migration-st... you can see migration levels consistently rising from 1975 to 2017 with 250,000 expected this year. Is there any level of migration for which critics would not be perjoratively labelled xenophobes by you? The definition of xenophobe is 'one unduly fearful of what is foreign and especially of people of foreign origin' it could be that folk are not 'unduly fearful' in the UK where to mention only a few problems related to population density, there is an acute housing shortage, roads are clogged and the National Health Service is close to breakdown in many areas.
- 8y ago
- ConfSibi 8y agoThere are legitimate and rational reasons for not wanting a large influx of poor immigrants into a developed nation. Using the US as an example, in the 1800's and early-to-mid 1900's, American work was largely labor intensive agricultural and factory based work. Labor was in huge demand, and as a result the middle class was able to thrive. Today that is no longer the case, and a massive rift between rich and poor is developing as the middle class collapses without an economic foundation to support its existence, this being the labor intensive industries that have largely disappeared in modern Western nations. This has been the development path of all developed nations. As modern economies are already struggling with worsening labor conditions for the majority of their people and the resulting stresses on social programs, it makes little sense to open immigration to the impoverished masses. This is a realist perspective. Denying the economic factors at play here will only lead to increased socio economic tension in developed societies at a time when such tension is already at a high water mark in modern history.
- Filligree 8y agoOkay, but what does that have to do with this story? The guy was gainfully employed until the Home Office did their thing.
- stupidcar 8y agoThis isn't "realist", it's the usual clichés and lies that are always propagated by people trying to justify anti-immigrant sentiment. It perpetuates the falsehood that immigrants stress social programmes. In fact, social programmes in Western countries are stressed by the shifting demographics of their indigenous populations, and require immigrants to prop them up. Social programmes like state pensions and healthcare were created in an age when Western countries had large working-age populations, and relatively small numbers of older, non-working people. However, the decrease in fertility and increase in life expectancy across the West has flipped this. There are too many older people, and not enough indigenous tax-paying citizens to support them. Politicians in Western countries saw this problem coming in the 1990s. Since cutting social programmes that affect the elderly is politically impossible, they realised the only solution was to liberalise their immigration policies. Immigrants are statistically younger, healthier, harder-working, and pay more taxes than the average indigenous citizen. As a bonus, many of them return to their home country when they get older, so you don't need to pay for their pensions / healthcare. Ironically, old people in these countries then decided, or were persuaded, that they disliked immigration. So they started supporting parties with anti-immigrant policies, even though this was totally against their economic self-interest. The result is a political paradox that no Western politician has been able to unravel, although populists have made hay exploiting it.
- rdl 8y agoIf the wait for review/decision is going to be months, there really should be some kind of pre submission check to test validity. This could be done by one’s lawyer usually, but an automated screening and/or immediate cursory validation by government seems like it would make sense. Maybe only extend validity of visa during processing if it passes the validation.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoAutomated screening? For a process that can result in the immediate detention and removal of persons when the system makes a mistake? I'm afraid this doesn't sound like such a great idea, although I'm sure the Home Office would love it.
- rdl 8y ago"Is this form complete?" "Do you X, Y, Z?" when it is known that those things are what are required, etc.
- curiousgal 8y ago> "indefinite leave to remain" My brain breaks whenever I read this. Like who the fuck came up with this name?
- dogma1138 8y agoLeave means permission, going on leave means you go with permission and why AWOL stands for absence without leave. “Old English lēaf ‘permission’, of West Germanic origin; related to lief and love.”
- shripadk 8y agoWhile the Home Office in UK was vigorously trying its best to throw Lucas out, the same Home Office in UK is trying its best to keep economic offenders like Vijay Mallya and Lalit Modi from being deported: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/04/28/india-asks-britain-to-deport-vijay-mallya/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/04/28/india-asks-brita... "The Home Office said the suspension of Mr Mallya's passport was a matter for Indian authorities and declined to comment on the individual case, citing its policy of neither confirming nor denying if any extradition request has been received until an arrest is made." It's been 2 years since India sent a formal extradition request. It has been rejected twice. Just to explain the absolute ridiculousness of this entire exercise to those who aren't aware: The case is still pending in UK court and the defence is actually arguing about the cleanliness of Indian jails and if adequate toilet facilities are provided for a fugitive: https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/give-us-mallya-we-ll-give-him-the-toilet-he-wants-modi-govt-to-uk-court-118073101568_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/gi... With this action of the Home Office, it has been made abundantly clear that the "human rights" of an economic fugitive far outweighs the human rights of Lucas.
- xaranke 8y agoI wish I could upvote this more than once. While in London, I saw Mallya's residence from the outside and it doesn't look like anything has changed for him - he still has a Maybach and a mansion near the Baker Street tube station. Seeing him living in luxury instead of being brought to justice really broke my heart.
- raverbashing 8y ago"its best", not "it's best"
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shripadk 8y agoNice catch! Fixed :)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- accnumnplus1 8y agoMuch mumbo jumbo in the comments. Immigration is seldom a problem anywhere. Excessive immigration is usually a problem everywhere. The coming of Britain's and Europe's immigration backlash was obvious nearly 20 years ago. Surprise, surprise, people like their culture and their homeland. Who would've thought? Something a European in London said yesterday: "We're moving outside London. I'm not a racist, but I'd at least like to have some white neighbours." Immigration is bringing in as many of the people you're targeting for not liking immigration. I've met countless anti-Britain immigrants; not anti as a result of living here and having bad experiences, but perfectly comfortable people who simply think their country's approach to things is better. Some were friends for as long as I could stand it. If you go around talking down the country I live in and need to be succesful then you're poisonous. Constructive criticism fine; poisonous, get lost. The pro-immigration groups' big mistake was pushing too hard, too fast, giving no time for the needed gradual adjustment, which might not have worked anyway, but had a better chance than bossing the natives around, forcing them to do things they didn't want, and then insulting them. What kind of half-witted strategy is that?
- xaranke 8y ago> forcing them to do things they didn't want Can you elaborate on this? As someone who just visited London, the opposite seems to be true at least in the service industry; most wait staff I encountered were non-British.
- accnumnplus1 8y agoNot sure what's unclear. Some people are pro-immigration, and some are anti-immigration, and some don't give a fuck, and some are undecided. The London wait staff you encountered, and the 65+ million people you didn't encounter, the overwhelming majority of whom are not wait staff, and most of whom live outside London, are all somewhere on that spectrum of opinion. The words you selected, obviously, I think, refer to those who are anti-immigration. If you're willing, you probably don't need to be forced, right? So, unlikely I was referring to the pro-immigration people. The first words of that paragraph are "The pro-immigration groups' big mistake", which hints at the pro-immigration stance not working out too well, so clearly there's push back from people who are anti-immigration, and those are the people who have been forced to accept immigration they didn't want. And my point was something like this: http://www.longlongtimeago.com/once-upon-a-time/fables/from-aesop/the-north-wind-and-the-sun/ http://www.longlongtimeago.com/once-upon-a-time/fables/from-... If your knowledge of the country is so entirely bankrupt I don't think you should be wading into this. Harsh, maybe, but fair.
- brm 8y agoIt shouldn't be this hard in the first place... Want a strong country? Let anyone who puts 50,000 of your currency in a local bank and has a college degree stay there. I shouldn't need 250K and have a business plan, or 2 million pounds to invest. I certainly shouldn't have to bond myself to a corporation or get married to be allowed to live there and pay taxes. Ban me from public government benefits for 5 years until I'm a citizen, sure... But you should welcome the young, educated, and reasonably stable. Who else is going to eventually pay to support everyone else? Really though further ax to grind... How is it that in 2018 the easiest way to move countries is still marriage?!
- xaranke 8y agoSome countries are starting to buck the trend; most notably Canada with Express Entry.
- victords 8y agoCan you elaborate on the recent developments regarding the Express entry in Canada?
- xaranke 8y agoExpress Entry is Canada's program for granting permanent residency to workers in skills shortage areas (sort of like a H1B and Green Card combo). It's a points-based system, so there's no guessing involved whether you'll make it; if you don't, you can easily see how you might improve your score. You can apply from anywhere without first having spent time in Canada as a student or worker (though you do get more points if you do so), aren't dependent on an employer filing for you, and jump straight to permanent residency (akin to Green Card or Indefinite Leave to Remain) within 6 months, which is quicker than the 1+ year Green Card takes. Unlike the Green Card, where you are from does not determine whether you'll get it; only your points do. So far it seems to be a huge success; by providing a fair and predictable immigration policy for high-skilled labor instead of one fueled by FUD as in the US. In general it seems like a system that is designed to help you succeed instead of trying to make you fail. Edit: you asked about recent developments, Canada just introduced a visa called Global Talent Stream for tech workers that allows you to start working in Canada in 2 weeks, which is crazy-fast for a work visa. You then get more points under Express Entry and might be able to apply sooner.
- waxwander 8y ago"I have essentially had the most important years in my career development taken away from me." This guy certainly has a sense of drama.