6 ms·
>Imperfect Produce claims they’re saving the world by reducing food waste–and helping farmers by buying surplus ugly produce that would have been thrown out. So
by komali2 8y ago
>Imperfect Produce claims they’re saving the world by reducing food waste–and helping farmers by buying surplus ugly produce that would have been thrown out. Sounds great. The reality is that this produce would have otherwise gone to food banks, to be redistributed for free.
I've been chewing on this for a while. Who's in charge of setting up a social safety net? Whose responsibility is it to make sure people don't starve in the streets?
I thought I paid taxes to my government to socialize the issue across my representative district, but my government (in the USA) has disagreed with me - that money is to be spent on fighter jets (to quote the executive branch), while the churches are responsible for taking care of the homeless. And by the way, the homeless are responsible for policing themselves (to quote my mayor).
A couple weeks ago Domino's Pizza filled a bunch of potholes and stamped their logo on the asphalt after. I thought that would cause a national discussion. I thought at the very least, the city that it happened in would be humiliated enough to make the foolish mistake of maybe trying to slap back at Domino's for putting their logo all over the street. Nope, business as usual.
In other words, why suddenly are people starving again because imperfect produce found a capitalist way to reduce waste?
- marcoperaza 8y agoLooking to the government may not be the best approach. See San Francisco, for example, where the local government is more concerned with banning plastic straws than with the absurd homeless population, rampant crime, and drug needles littering the streets.
- jacobolus 8y agoHow many board of supervisors meetings have you been to? Various programs and policies related to homelessness are discussed constantly. Can you name a supervisor you think is more concerned with plastic straws than homelessness?
- marcoperaza 8y agoIf they're just as concerned, they're certainly not as effective. I can't believe they have their priorities straight when they are willing to allocate enforcement resources to a plastic straw ban, which will accomplish absolutely nothing, while there is rampant open defecation, used needles on the streets, openly feuding gangs (which the city protects from deportation), and an absolute epidemic of car break-ins (30,000 smash-and-grabs per year, only 1.7% of which someone is arrested for).
- ribosometronome 8y agoWell, sure? Banning straws is easy. Solving homelessness is not. It's not as if the SF Supes can just have a "No more homelessness" vote.
- door4 8y agoSure they could. Just pay for housing for all homeless SF residents. The only reason it doesn't happen is because people with money and power don't care enough to make the material sacrifices required to solve the problem.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoHomelessness is rooted in two things: very serious personal problems that have no easy answer combined with a dire shortage of genuinely affordable housing in the US.* We need to dramatically improve availability of affordable housing. That would get a lot of retirees and the like off the street. But the ones who would, say, burn the house down while you weren't looking need a lot more than a free place to live. If you care deeply about this issue, work on affordable housing. But please stop acting like homeless people are all puppies that need to be adopted by some well-meaning stranger. It's incredibly dehumanizing and tends to compound the problem. * https://www.geekwire.com/2018/every-100-families-living-poverty-west-coast-no-30-affordable-homes/ https://www.geekwire.com/2018/every-100-families-living-pove...
- wdewind 8y ago
- remote_phone 8y agoSF spends over $300M a year on homeless and we still have homeless people defecating openly on Market Street during the day. They don’t even collect metrics to figure out if the money is working (which it’s not) or have any accountability.
- komali2 8y agoIt seems you're implying that we should pull that money out of "on homeless" (not exactly sure what that means, can you clarify?) So then what happens? The homeless die? What solution do you want?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 8y agohow about measuring the effectiveness of the programs using that money, and improving them at least even if you want to keep at the same budget? why is bad acceptable when you spend 300M a year?
- komali2 8y agoDo you have evidence that the city council is not measuring the effectiveness of that money, and improving methodologies?
- ekianjo 8y agoIf they are, then it looks like they are pretty bad at what they are doing. And since its a public program all measurements should be public as well, by definition.
- woah 8y agoThere’s a common refrain that “SF doesn’t spend enough money on the homeless, because they are rich and greedy etc etc. if only there was some compassion!!!!” In fact SF spends as much money on the homeless as they spend on the streets and parks. This shows that throwing money at the problem hasn’t helped.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoSure, blame the local governments, don't blame the tax revolt that happened 40 years ago and has crippled the entire state since then.
- hw 8y agoYet so many people want to live in SF. In all seriousness, banning plastic straws is a much lower hanging fruit than solving the homeless situation. The money to build and maintain affordable housing has to come from somewhere, probably by raising taxes. Would the SF residents, lots of whom are high income earners and who ironically are the ones feeding the crazy housing and rent prices, be willing to chip in to solve the problem or just sit on the sidelines and complain about the homeless?
- geezerjay 8y ago> Yet so many people want to live in SF. They do mainly because of the promises of a high-paying job in the tech industry, not because a politician focuses his policies on plastic straws instead of taking care of people in need.
- couchand 8y ago> found a capitalist way to reduce waste? I don't know anything about either of these groups, but the article says that this is simply the marketing of Imperfect Produce that doesn't bear out in reality. Do you have information contradicting their points that you decided not to share?
- komali2 8y agoI don't think I understand what you mean... But I almost certainly have less information than them or probably you, so am happy to hear more.
- sleepychu 8y agoIP assert: "This food was going to be thrown out & going to waste. We are using it for something!" Article asserts: "That food wasn't being thrown out it was going to food banks and homeless shelters." So while IP is almost certainly helping the farmers by paying them for produce they can't normally sell they certainly aren't reclaiming mountains of food otherwise destined for rot.
- Karishma1234 8y ago> why suddenly are people starving again because imperfect produce found a capitalist way to reduce waste? They don't. They wont. The article is nonsensical and ignores basic economics. Suffers from "we know better" attitude. Small farmers are struggling. If the ugly produce helps them become little more profitable it is both good for them and also good for the food security of the nation. More available food would mean food will be cheaper for everyone. Will the world be better place if small farmers are out of business and a large businesses like Amazon takes up farming ? Personally do not think there is anything ugly about ugly produce. Note: I am not a rich techie. I earn less than $10K a year.
- ascorbic 8y agoIt's not small farmers that this is helping though. The article quotes Imperfect Produce as saying they need to be able to take at least a truckload of produce off a farm each week for it to be economical, so they don't deal with small farms. This is helping the large agribusinesses, not the mom and pop farms.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoThe article's term "gentrification" has a more specific focus than overall social welfare, and I think it's spot-on. Entrepreneurs notice an "underutilized" resource (housing / food waste) and create a new distribution network, disrupting the old one. This is good ol' competition (which I am a fan of), but it's important to acknowledge that it impacts people who aren't "competing", like food bank visitors. Even if the new network captures more value than the old one, it may also redistribute that value -- as the article contends, from food banks that would get more donations to "conscious consumers" who prefer this to traditional groceries, and of course to Imperfect Produce via profits. Regardless of how you feel about the ethics of the above, it's at least part of Imperfect Produce's identity. If they are marketing to conscious consumers, this article helps those consumers consider more broadly their social impact. For my own value judgement, I feel like I'm missing some important data: - If IP is taking waste produce from larger farms, are they actually competing with BeetBox for the supply of produce? - Downstream of above, has IP's activity actually reduced the amount of food donations being made available to food banks? If IP is mainly competing with BeetBox for the "conscious consumers" that subsidize their charitable work, maybe BB can focus efforts to marketing their distinction from IP. Maybe this article is the first step. Alternatively, if the BB folks are prioritizing social impact, have they tried to convince/train IP to work with the same social gaps they fill? If IP is more efficient in extracting conscious-consumer dollars, they have more surplus that could be poured back into the community.
- maxerickson 8y agoI bet Domino's worked with the city and had some sort of explicit permission.