4 ms·
The challenge of course, is multifaceted: 1. It's not a trivial problem to be able to identify what is hate speech in a regional dialect automatically 2. It s
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
The challenge of course, is multifaceted:
1. It's not a trivial problem to be able to identify what is hate speech in a regional dialect automatically
2. It sets a problematic precedent if Facebook throws 100s of - hard to find, hard to pay and hard to support - native language local reviewers at every place where Facebook could be abused.
I'm no Facebook apologist, however I recognize how hard of a technical problem, and how it's equally a personnel management, prioritization and scaling problem.
Facebook risks chasing every group that makes a loud enough noise, and then being criticized for it irrespective of what they do. No win situation.
- ardy42 8y ago> It sets a problematic precedent if Facebook throws 100s of - hard to find, hard to pay and hard to support - native language local reviewers at every place where Facebook could be abused. In what way is that a problematic precedent? Their negligence contributed to ethnic cleansing and genocide. If a multi-billion dollar company is too cheap to hire local staff to watch its platform, it shouldn't operate a localized version for that place. They need to act responsibly. Think if it like product safety testing.
- mango7283 8y agoUm wait you don't need a localised version of Facebook to type in a local language, you just need unfiltered internet... Or do you mean FB should prohibit sign ups from arbitrary countries?
- yorwba 8y agoJust yesterday I watched a Chinese woman on a flight from Beijing to Moscow struggle with the onboard entertainment system because it was only available in Russian and English, and I realized how much shared cultural context is necessary to operate even simple apps in a foreign language. If Facebook didn't have a version localized to Burmese, it would never have gotten widespread enough in Myanmar to be a significant part of the problem.
- charlesism 8y ago> It's not a trivial problem to be able to > identify what is hate speech in a regional > dialect automatically This sentiment, which I read repeatedly, really irritates me. Most of us program here. It's not that hard a problem! When social media execs claim it is, what they really mean is "it's a hard problem to solve for us, because we are unwilling to risk losing any percentage of account sign-ups ever, under any circumstances." The irony is that they are so timid about their precious sign-ups that they act against their own interest. For example, YouTube won't risk a short term dip in user retention metrics to scrub garbage from their comments... even though doing so would likely greatly increase sign-ups in the long term.
- LoSboccacc 8y agonatural language processing is like one of the hardest problems that's left to crack, don't be so dismissive about it i.e: "get rid of all black people" "get rid of all black people unemployment problems" "get rid of all black people unemployment problems sending them back to Africa" this can be expanded almost infinitely in every direction, and we're not even beginning with the false positive problems. "I hate black cars" so no, it's not just a claim that it's an hard problem.
- charlesism 8y ago> natural language processing is like one > of the hardest problems that's left to crack You don't need to "crack it" or come anywhere remotely near to a perfect solution. False positives are okay, providing you accept that some percent of your users won't tolerate the errors, and will leave your platform. And we're talking about social networks. So there's a wealth of additional information (ie: who you follow. previous behavior. who has reported you. account age) beyond plain text to augment this. And there's the setting of policy (eg: how come I can post within an hour of signing up on most social networks?). The point is, what we have now on most social networks is not geared toward long-term customer satisfaction or the public good. It's geared toward medium-term account retention at any cost - regardless of whether the accounts are bots, sock puppets, or trolls.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]