19 ms·
DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months
- WisNorCan 8y agoThis is why the best time to join a startup is increasingly at the post $1B mark. Significantly derisked with product and economics proven, solid comp, crazy upside. The unicorn is a silly designation, but it also isn’t. There are exceptions of course as it is not zero risk.
- captain_perl 8y agoThe above is pretty good advice (except for DoorDash) and is what VCs are doing these days - piling on after a company is a runaway success. In other words, if it's a small startup, do it as a founder. Otherwise, stick to BigCo and Unicorns.
- ericd 8y agoI'm not sure - as a common stockholder, I'd be very worried about the liquidation prefs on a lot of these high flying companies. If we see their valuations come back to earth even a relatively modest amount, common shares become worthless. Also, unlike a BigCo, it can be very hard to get any liquidity unless they're friendly to secondaries.
- naveen99 8y agoWhat’s ycombinator’s policy in their startups, is it friendly to secondaries ? aren’t the founders common stockholders ?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI believe founders have preferred shares, and employees have common shares. Edit: Above can be disregarded, see below replies, I misremembered my options paperwork.
- mikenyc 8y agoThere are definitely exceptions, but the classic scenario is that the founders get common stock, not preferred.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ericd 8y agoSeconding this, I can't remember ever hearing of founders getting preferred, so their incentives are generally aligned with the other employees.
- ericd 8y agoI don't know the policy on secondaries. But yeah, founders are almost always common stockholders in my experience, and they certainly don't want a preference overhang. And to be clear wrt my original comment, I think DoorDash is an excellent business, and I have no reason to believe that the valuation isn't fully justified, I'm just speaking more generally about the funding environment of companies doing large rounds at high valuations, and if a macro trend pushes startup valuations in the other direction.
- birken 8y agoI disagree about joining a startup worth over $1B. First, compare it something that actually is de-risked, a big company. Amazon has grown 6.5x in the past 5 years. Google has grown nearly 3x in that period. So in addition to have basically no risk of failure, you get high compensation, fully liquid stock and pretty decent growth if you are lucky. Let's compare that to unicorns. I own some shares in a unicorn that has been worth over $1B for nearly 3 years. In that time myself and all the other shareholders have had exactly 0 opportunities to sell the stock. I'm not saying the valuation is made up, but I certainly wouldn't say anything is de-risked. Taking a lot of money in investment just means the outcome is expected to be bigger and bigger. It doesn't mean less risk and it doesn't mean more liquidity. If you want upside, there is just going to be so much more potential if you join a really early company. If you want to de-risk, join a big company.
- WisNorCan 8y agoThe valuation increase in the FAANGs are a historical anomaly. I’ll bet you that Amazon will not 6.5x in the next 5 years. I am not saying that Amazon is a bad company, or working there is a bad idea. Just that reversion to the mean is a powerful force.
- birken 8y agoMaybe it an anomaly and maybe it isn't (I can't predict the future), but I know the growth was real. If I bought stock 5 years ago and sold it today, I could pocket those gains. That is the problem with looking at private company valuations and trying to decide if they are good investments or not. You don't know how the story is going to end for the common shareholders and what the overall return is going to look like. I'm not saying the upside wont be there, it very will could be, but the level of risk is still much much higher than the big public tech companies.
- mrep 8y ago6.5x is big but not that crazy when you consider they are growing at %40+ YOY (even more in the past). How long that continues is anyone's guess but I can see them gaining just as much if we don't have a recession between then.
- mbesto 8y ago> with product proven Sure, but that doesn't mean it has a viable business. > and economics proven Says who? Uber still doesn't have positive unit economics and its valued at $60B+ > solid comp, crazy upside. Base comp? Sure. Options (upside), no. Liquidation preferences wipe these out if the company doesn't meet it's valuation in a liquidity event. One thing that is (almost) for sure - it looks good on your resume.
- compcoffee 8y ago>Significantly derisked with product and economics proven, solid comp, crazy upside. What, exactly, is "proven" about this model? It's food delivery. Smells like late stage bull market to me.
- dingaling 8y agoOutside Silicon Valley, a company with a $1 billion market valuation isn't a startup... For example in the UK a company of that size is Balfour Beatty, an enormous construction and services company established in 1909
- gammateam 8y ago> an enormous construction an enormous construction OOPS sounds like they have tangible hardware and operating costs. tech companies get to that point, but they can offer services with very little overhead for a very long time until they scale to the point that they have to build their own hardware infrastructure to support them. and then they also resell/rent out that hardware infrastructure to smaller tech companies and everyone else.
- fipple 8y agoThese valuations are driven by huge liquidation preferences which will totally wipe out common stockholders in any down round or distressed sale.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 8y agoWait, explain the connection between liquidation preferences and valuation? Or is the argument that these companies get very high nominal valuations but the terms on the rounds they raise include punitive preferences?
- WisNorCan 8y agoLiquidation multiples and preference gives the investor protection when things go bad (and also a kicker when it goes well). Let’s say you put in $100M and have a 2x liquidation multiple at a $4B valuation. Even if the company falls apart and sells for $100M you still get your money back. If it declines to $200M you get all of that before anyone else. In reality terms vary substantially. In this case, Doordash had just raised and didn’t need to raise again. Depending on how desperate investors were to get in, they might have gotten clean terms.
- tptacek 8y agoNo, I get what a preference is; I'm wondering what the connection between them and valuation is.
- WisNorCan 8y agoHigher multiples and preference means that you have less downside and higher upside in the investment -> higher valuation.
- vecter 8y agoI think he's saying that the valuation would be lower if the liquidation preference were lower. This makes sense since a higher liquidation preference reduces the risk of the investment, thus allowing you to grant a higher valuation.
- th0ma5 8y agoThis hearsay but I've heard restaurants hate all of the delivery services. They take a cut and decrease walk in traffic which usually buys high profit stuff like alcohol and fountain beverages.
- truebosko 8y agoWe've had a few coffee shops in our area drop the delivery/mobile purchase (Ritual) apps, perhaps due to this. Or, just the logistics may have been unbearable for them. Sometimes, I do enjoy walking into a coffee shop and ordering like a human.
- fierro 8y agoHold on, your door dash coffee to your house? Thank you for this
- mynegation 8y agoRitual is an “order ahead and pick up” app.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoDunkin does this and it can be a little frustrating when you're next in line but they gotta handle like 3 online orders. I wish they'd hire an extra person to mostly handle such heavy load... But I'm not in charge of everything everywhere.. Otherwise I want to say don't do online ordering if you don't have more than enough people to handle both regular customers AND online ones... It just sucks. The one time I was next in line, there were probably 3 or more orders, and like 5 or more people behind me in line, plus the person in front of me was ordering the whole menu.
- kerabatsos 8y agoWe are parents of two small boys and it’s damn near impossible to go out. Ordering DoorDash helps us try different restaurants and not have to deal with the madness of corralling two kids in a busy environment.
- brazzledazzle 8y agoIt’s not really directly relevant to their valuation but if I can prevent someone else from that experience: DoorDash will happily let you pass your phone around a group browsing and adding things but it’s only during the actual payment attempt that they’ll deny it and inform you that you can’t order more than $50 worth of food. It was (at least at the time) documented nowhere. The app didn’t prevent you from adding more than that amount and their FAQ said nothing. Uber Eats (for better or worse) didn’t have any of those issues.
- theDoug 8y agoI don't deny your experience, but it doesn't match mine. I am able to confirm 15 orders over the last two years higher than $50, the highest landing at $73. Unless we're to believe the app is detecting multiple users surreptitiously and has an opinion on them, group orders / a phone being passed around seems irrelevant, but also not within my personal experience. (Zip: 94086, and I love Indian leftovers from Ulavacharu, usually individual orders)
- brazzledazzle 8y agoMaybe I’ll give it another shot. The app bugged and double charged me for one order and it took a week or so to sort out so maybe they flagged me. That would be bit obnoxious but understandable if they couldn’t differentiate between a bug and fraud.
- abkumar 8y agoI imagine they must do this to minimize risk for certain accounts based on factors unknown to me. I don't know what your error message said exactly, but perhaps the restaurant themselves placed an upper limit on delivery orders because they don't like that they are missing out on the tip for large orders. This is purely speculation by me of course. Some of the fancier places will easily be over $25 of food so if you order for two, $50 is not difficult to reach. Out of curiosity had you ordered from DoorDash multiple times before you attempted that group order?
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RestlessMind 8y agoBased on my personal experience with this service, I guess two things have happened that would make them profitable: 1. DoorDash has started gouging customers with exorbitant fees - restaurant tip, service charge, delivery fee, driver tip etc. I stopped using service after that. Remaining customers could the true "target demographics" for DoorDash, who might be price insensitive or really busy in their lives, thus improving DoorDash's financials. 2. Softbank betting big and investing lavishly on gig economy companies (see: Uber, Didi, Grub, now DoorDash etc)
- mmt 8y ago> DoorDash has started gouging customers with exorbitant fees - restaurant tip, service charge, delivery fee, driver tip etc. I stopped using service after that. This seems to be the case for PostMates, too. I recall being sceptical when they originally were acquiring customers with free (or $1-$3 flat fee) delivery promotions, but I figured it could be worth it even for double that amount. However, when I next looked, they had quietly [1] implemented fees that are a (high) percentage of total bill in addition to a higher flat delivery fee, that was a dealbreaker. Distance-based pricing would have been OK, but not percentage of the order on top of a flat fee. [1] A generous interpretation. Personally, I found it sneaky.
- thrav 8y agoYep. Postmates pricing got real absurd, real fast. It almost felt like it happened, even if you had premium. DoorDash, I should pay closer attention to. My wife usually orders, and she’s way too price insensitive for my taste at times. I at least insisted on one of the zero delivery fee restaurants last night, but don’t know what that actually means.
- mmt 8y agoLooks like here in the SFBA it's "This 11% service fee helps us operate DoorDash" which they bundle with sales tax under the "Taxes and Fees" line item during checkout. I find that practice to be paricularly objectionable, since it would be more honest to bundle it with the delivery fee, if the point were something like UI brevity. Instead, it feels deceptive, as if to imply that money they have to pay to the restaurant because the restaurant has to pay it the state is in some way related to their operating costs. I could probably accept a variable fee of less than 3% under the assumption that their payment costs are higher than the restaurant due to card-not-present. I could even accept variable-by-my-location (i.e. distance-based) delivery pricing. However, both of these would need to be clear and up front. Seeing an inflated total only at checkout make me feel cheated, and I cancel the transaction. In my suburban setting, a restaurant far enough away is maybe $3 in incremental driving costs plus 30 minutes of my time. In a dense, urban setting, presumably everything is much closer [1]. The time savings could be worth it, but the benefits of going myself are a much higher incentive to make sure my order is correct and a much lower latency (i.e. higher freshness). [1] And places like Manhattan have had delivery services, sometimes done by individual establishments themselves, for ages.
- khazhou 8y agoGood for them. And by "them" I mean the founders and investors. Employees may make some money if the company exits, but not much relative to time/sweat investment, certainly several orders of magnitude lower than the guys up top, and probably comparable to or worse than FANG compensation (even disregarding RSUs). This isn't unique to DoorDash, but it's what comes to mind when a pre-exit company's valuation is being marketed in public. It's meant in part to entice eager recruits, but they don't realize that money is never meant for them.
- huangbong 8y agotldr: capitalism
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoAre their employees not paid a salary like everyone else?
- khazhou 8y agoIf they are like a standard SV startup, they are indeed receiving salary, plus equity many orders of magnitude smaller than founders.
- robk 8y agoThe unit economics in the US just don't quite add up. Assuming in a rational market a driver has to make about the equivalent of minimum wage (or else they'd take a less taxing minimum wage job) they need to make say $15 an hour in SF. So if I order a Cheesecake Factory from Union Square to the Marina, they arguably will take 30-40 mins roundtrip, so even at full utilization, the delivery is costing nearly $8. Unless the delivery fee is > $8 then the margin on food subsidizes the delivery which seems like a pretty rotten strategy to lower margins even further. Theoretically I guess they could do point to point delivery where they then pickup in Marina but that seems far more difficult and anecdotally never the case when I ask a driver. In that case you could assume a one way takes say 20-25 mins (waiting on delivery probably adds 5 to each order), then that's still a $7 delivery cost at the margin. One can make the case this can be made to work in dense cities say 1m or more with a density over X people/p. sq. ft. like in Europe/Asia. But I don't think there are many US cities with this kind of density to support.
- xtreme 8y agoThere are not many cities with $15 minimum wage either.
- mmt 8y agoAs mentioned in a different subthread [1], their actual delivery fee can easily be above $8 when including their 11% "service fee". (If the "delivery" portion is only $3, the total CCF check would need to be $45.50, which doesn't seem outlandish for that establishment). Even denser cities are likely to have even more (cheaper) competition. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17780377 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17780377