4 ms·
Having read through a lot of battery breakthrough reports, I tend to zero in on the 'hard bit' which in this particular case is here: U-M researchers solved thi
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
Having read through a lot of battery breakthrough reports, I tend to zero in on the 'hard bit' which in this particular case is here: U-M researchers solved this problem with chemical and mechanical treatments that provide a pristine surface for lithium to plate evenly, effectively suppressing the formation of dendrites or filaments.
My reading of that was if you create this pristine surface, you get a wonder battery. On the other hand, if the surface has a defect in it anywhere you get dendrites, and the subsequent shorts they cause.
When I read that part I said "Ok, so this will make great bespoke batteries that the military can use for their human carried gear, but they will be too expensive to compete with the existing lithium ion technology."
I really hope that I'm wrong here, and there is some process that can reliably make massive numbers of pristine plated lithium / ceramic nodes but until we see that I don't see this breakthrough making it out of the lab.
- tomp 8y agoIs “pristine ceramic” that much harder to create than e.g. “pristine silicon”? Cilicon chips seem relatively cheap these days.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThat is an excellent restatement of the core question. Can the process that makes "pristine ceramic" be scaled. (harder is a dependent variable on scaling difficulty.) I don't know how much harder it is to make ceramics pristine. I am inferring that it is the thing in the article that wasn't already part of making batteries so the 'new' bit. And after seeing many, many breakthroughs where the 'new' bit was doable in small scales at great expense in a laboratory, but impossible to do at scale in an automated process, I've watched those breakthroughs go from 'world changing' to 'laboratory curiosity.' So when Nature Materials publishes the paper on the process to repeatedly make tons of pristine ceramic material, then I will be excited for the new batteries that my devices will surely get in an upgrade.
- tomp 8y agoThat's interesting perspective. > And after seeing many, many breakthroughs where the 'new' bit was doable in small scales at great expense in a laboratory, but impossible to do at scale in an automated process, Can you elaborate on that, maybe give a few examples? I always thought that inventions were mainly judged by their merit (efficiency), I guess I was blind to the "scaling" (i.e. "actual industry") variable, and just assumed that there must be some way to automate and streamline almost everything, as long as the demand is there (as Elon Musk has recently been showing, with batteries/electric cars and rockets).
- petra 8y agoChemistry(and biology) is one such field: the chemical/biological process behaves very differently whether it's don't in small quantities of the lab or in the huge volumes required for a commercial effort. So think of that large($100mm) factory as a research process , that can often fail. Example: commercializing biotech often fails because it's not possible to control contamination and genetic evolution of the bacteria you grow in huge processes .
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI have found that many times when people are "talking past" each other it is because there is a belief in there somewhere that one holds one way and the other holds a different way. In this case you have illuminated it nicely, which (slightly edited) is this: I ... assumed that there must be some way to automate and streamline almost everything, as long as the demand is there. I have experienced many things over my life where this assumption was invalid. The most common reason I have seen that this assumption breaks down is that "demand" is expressly tied to "price." And more specifically when the price goes up, demand goes down (in the economic sense, the number of people willing to pay that price for a widget) and at some price the demand goes to zero. Thus "not possible" which is not literally true, it is only actually true. Do a search on "Battery breakthrough" (Google Scholar will give you better results but the web search works too) and pick any one where the improvement is >= 50% improvement in any axis (cost, charging, capacity, weight, what ever). This works best for articles that are 5 or more years old (you have to allow some time for them to come up with a way to do it), and then try to find that breakthrough used in any battery today. Sometimes you will find a 'why we couldn't do it' article but mostly it will just not be there. Even though batteries that were 50% better on any axis would seem to have a market right? And then read through to find the 'hard bit' in the break through and go back to Google Scholar and see if you can find papers related to that bit. You will find "the rest of the story" as it is sometimes said where some thing prevents wider adoption than laboratory curiosity. Here is a simpler technology, silicon anodes (announced in 2010) reviewed in 2018 [1], maybe hitting the market if they can go to production [2]. This is a simpler process and as it has matured its impact has gone down to 10 - 15%. [1] https://sci-hub.tw/10.1016/j.nanoen.2016.07.023 https://sci-hub.tw/10.1016/j.nanoen.2016.07.023 [2] [BMW] plans to incorporate Sila Nano batteries into vehicles by 2023 to boost energy capacity by 10 to 15 percent. --https://venturebeat.com/2018/08/16/sila-nanotechnologies-raises-70-million-for-next-generation-battery-development/ https://venturebeat.com/2018/08/16/sila-nanotechnologies-rai...
- tw04 8y agoBut most silicon isn't pristine, that's why we have chip binning.
- Itsdijital 8y agoHere'a post a made on reddit a few years ago about this very problem. I think its pretty relevant here and just about anywhere else that does cutting edge research: "I want to expand on this because it is a point so often overlooked with all these "holy shit we just created a new tech that is 10000% better" articles. I'm gonna use a loose analogy to try and explain it. Say you made a perfect cupcake. It is insanely fucking delicious, and will revolutionize the idea of cupcakes. You spent years researching the art of cupcakes, and now have written down the perfect combination of all cupcake factors to make this divine cupcake. Your milk must come from a special dairy who set aside the .02% of the milk that meets your needs, your flour must come from one certain granary using a special indoor grown grain, the eggs from your own 3 specially bred super pampered chickens. The mixing takes place over eight unique specialized mixing procedures, with varying steps in between. The cupcake paper is made from the wood of an endangered Guatemalan tree (requiring federal clearance to obtain 10 sheets of it) and the baking tray from a steel alloy made by one company in Japan, and it's not reusable. The baking process has been tailored to the unique characteristics of your $20,000 1'x1'x1' oven. It takes 3 hours to bake with precise temperature control and positioning adjustment needed throughout the process. The icing also requires it's own set of unique ingredients and precise procedures. To make one of these cupcakes takes 14 hours and costs $2600. If any corners are cut in the process the whole thing falls apart. But done right it is indeed perfect. A business man finds out about the cupcake that makes people cry tears of joy. He comes to you and needs you to make 35,000 of them a day to sell for $10 each in order to be profitable. Logistically this is simply impossible. No equipment on earth exists that can follow such precise steps for such large quantities, much less a company capable of making it. Your oven costs 20 grand and can bake one cupcake in 3 hours, you need 5000 in 3 hours. Your ingredients come from sources that produce only a minute fraction of what you would need. Never mind that they are scattered around the country making same day delivery impossible short of having your own air fleet. Or that there are only 3 chickens on earth that produce the right eggs. Or that the rare beetle poop in the icing comes from an entomology professor in Peru. Even if you could do all this you still need to adjust the recipe to account for being handled by machines and conveyors. And packaging. And shipping. Oh and slash the cost by a factor of 260. Since this is all obviously impossible at the time (and for the foreseeable future), you instead just submit the recipe to a food journal and let cooking magazines and TV shows have a field day with sensational articles about the coming cupcake jesus. You become well known and grant money for your legendary lasagna project pours in. There never was any intention to bring this to market, it was just a proof of concept with the added benefit of getting your name out there. It's up to someone else down the road to pick it up and figure out mass production. If anything people should get more hyped about advancements in production techniques. That's when you will actually get new shit in your hands."