11 ms·
Who Left Open The Cookie Jar?
- lainga 8y agoIf you don't want to visit BoingBoing, https://wholeftopenthecookiejar.eu/static/tpc-paper.pdf https://wholeftopenthecookiejar.eu/static/tpc-paper.pdf
- driverdan 8y agoAnd their website: https://wholeftopenthecookiejar.eu/ https://wholeftopenthecookiejar.eu/
- nothrabannosir 8y ago## Enabling the option to block third-party cookies in Edge has no effect ## Third-party cookies are still included in all requests when enabling the option to block these in Edge. Oh my God T_T
- darpa_escapee 8y agoIE cursed Edge from beyond the grave. Its legacy must live on.
- efficax 8y agodo we hate boingboing now?
- ldarby 8y agoThere is a popup. Remember when browsers added popup blockers? They've worked around them now with JS & CSS...
- ColanR 8y agoumatrix with first-party scripts disabled had no problem.
- ldarby 8y agoMy browser can also disable js (per site as well) with out any plugins, but doing it globally breaks too much and whitelisting those sites (and 3rd party they rely on) is way too much effort. Worst case that happened to me is a payment that went through but some bit of JS never ran so the order didn't make it to the shop. Looking forward to a blocker that can detect if a script is going to pop up and block that (and it'd be ok to have to whitelist the few sites whose entire funtionality is popup based, like twitter), but I think that's equivalent to solving the halting problem.
- djsumdog 8y agoI was running uMatrix with first-party scripts disabled by default for a while, but I found a lot of pages I needed 3 or 4 refreshes to get content. It opened my eyes to how much simple static stuff in dependent on Javascript; stuff that really shouldn't be.
- smichel17 8y agoI did the same, but instead decided most of those sites weren't worth my time. (For the few that I cared about, I whitelisted the bits needed to function).
- kardos 8y agoIt's pretty heavy on trackers, including canvas fingerprinting.
- ibrahim81 8y agoIt's a place where journalists post.
- originalsimba 8y agoThere's no such thing as unblockable.
- Y_Y 8y agoDespite the title, they do not actually host the techniques.
- bankspot 8y agoWould it be possible to change the link from bb to the source: https://wholeftopenthecookiejar.eu/ https://wholeftopenthecookiejar.eu/
- sctb 8y agoSure, we've updated the link from https://boingboing.net/2018/08/16/who-left-open-the-cookie-jar.html https://boingboing.net/2018/08/16/who-left-open-the-cookie-j....
- k__ 8y agoI worked for a web analytics company and they simply used reverse proxies.
- orf 8y agoMind elaborating?
- nolok 8y agoI guess he means something like all requests to www.yoursite.com/foo123/BAR proxies to www.soulsucking.com/BAR
- munchbunny 8y agoI'm not the parent poster, but I worked in ad tech. With third party cookie policies getting more stringent, many websites now use either a reverse proxy within the first party domain that points to third party servers, or they use a first party subdomain that points to third party servers. In either case, it allows the servers belonging to the data gatherer to appear as first party, thus getting around third party cookie restrictions. Combine that with browser fingerprinting, and you now have a harder but very viable way to replace the functionality third party cookies previously had.
- k__ 8y agoA company has multiple websites and all of them use a reverse proxy for tracking. (a webserver that is between clients and the real webserver and just "proxies" requests and responses between them, logging all that happens) This is completely transparent from the outside.
- greenshackle2 8y agoThis is rather offtopic but it bothers me how most people in IT seem to use 'transparent' to mean 'opaque'. When I hear PMs say "this change will be completely transparent to clients" what they mean is, the client will see no difference, which means really, the details are hidden in a black - opaque - box.
- chopin 8y agoAgain a reason to block at least third party JavaScript.
- js2 8y agoI use Safari 11 as my primary browser. This is promising: > Safari’s Intelligent Tracking Prevention managed to mitigate all third-party cookies to a tracking domain, apart from redirects. However, we found that future completeness can be undermined by having this option disabled for even a short interval. Third-party cookies set in this interval by tracking domains, which otherwise would have been prevented, will still be included in cross-site requests after enabling the option again, identical to the results when the option is disabled. Luckily, this option is enabled by default, so future completeness can only be affected through explicit disabling by the user. I'd also like to know whether that applies to iOS, but the paper didn't perform any mobile browser testing. That said, every so often I view my stored cookies and I'm always shocked at the number of domains that I've never heard of that have stashed cookies. :-(
- kulahan 8y agoI never wanted to "waste money" on a mac, but I feel like Apple takes user privacy seriously, and I'm genuinely considering making the switch from Windows just to support that practice. I dunno, maybe that's silly, but it seems like the whole world stopped caring about user security and privacy, and this is refreshing to see fairly consistently.
- NathanCH 8y agoTry developing for Safari and get back to us. Safari is easily the worst browser to develop for this year.
- kevinherron 8y agoAnd this is the end users problem... how?
- sbarre 8y agoLack of support for one.. Safari doesn't have the market share to force developers to support it when it's painful to work with..
- mgliwka 8y agoI have to disagree with the statement, that those techniques are not being used in the wild. I‘ve observed a porn advertising network delivering some js once, which opened a third-party domain served pdf with cookies in the background and then closed the popup immediately again. I was wondering what that was about. Now it’s clear to me.
- blattimwind 8y agoA friend of mine might have noticed something similar (on a news site, of course).
- tomvangoethem 8y agoIt would be very useful if you could point us to such examples! (I'm an author of the paper)
- blattimwind 8y agoPornhub. It could of course be a popup playing a different role (e.g. being part of a "you need to upgrade your vulnerable software naow!1"-scheme) that's only visible if no blockers at all are used.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoSelf destructing cookies will mostly defeat these problems unless trackers get clever about cross-correlating cookies from different sessions. Restricting JavaScript makes that even harder for them to accomplish. For most purposes there's little benefit to keeping old cookies hanging around. Just whitelist the sites you want to stay logged in to.
- jiveturkey 8y ago> Self destructing cookies Is that what Safari has? Do any other browsers have plans for this? Or stated plans to NOT do this? I imagine Chrome falls in the latter camp.
- confounded 8y agoIt’s a Firefox extension.
- pvorb 8y agoHaven’t almost all browsers always had this feature in the form of “keep until browser is closed” or “delete local data after closing the browser”? At least Firefox and Chrome have it hidden somewhere in the settings.
- pseudalopex 8y agoWhen was the last time you closed your browser?
- fake-name 8y ago"Currently Unblockable" Unless you don't allow jerberscript. Which blocks all of them. Hyperbole, much?
- benbristow 8y agoDon't allow 'jerberscript' and don't expect the web to work properly. Simple as.
- wwweston 8y agoIf it doesn't work w/o js, it's not actually the web, the de facto truth of your statement notwithstanding. It's an eminently defensible descriptive statement; the trend is certainly away from building the web and towards treating the browser as the VM to rule them all. It is not a particularly well-defensible normative statement.
- jrockway 8y agoI don't know if I agree that. It's pretty standardized. Every user-agent includes it. You can give people documents without scripts, but it's not mandatory for them to work. And it's not like Javascript is some obscure single-vendor extension, it's widely supported.
- zeveb 8y agoThe web works perfectly well without JavaScript: HTML still displays text & images fine, links still work properly &c.. Now, a whole host of things which aren't the web will break, but honestly that's okay.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoDo you honestly never buy anything online?
- zeveb 8y ago
- linguistbreaker 8y agoIt's funny this is posted on Boingboing.net - I stopped reading years ago because their monetization attempts made their site unusable...
- kodablah 8y agoThis WontFix made me sad [0]: > Yes, this is accurate - extensions cannot intercept requests from PDFium. PDFium, in Chrome, is (partially) implemented as a component extension, and extension requests cannot be monitored or manipulated by other extensions. The behavior of protecting component extension requests is critical for security reasons, and we are unlikely to change it. Ug, not exactly sure what triggers PDFium vs PDF download, but this is especially bad if I could load a PDF in an iframe and get around any of your ad blocking. I also question why it's considered an extension at the user level. Anything installed and enabled by default should be considered part of the core browser and not an extension (regardless of the mechanisms, such as the extension one, they are implemented with). I understand the levels of separation and implementation difficulty fixing this entails, I really do, but the practicalities of your on-by-default PDF renderer making web requests different than a web page is too bad to ignore. This goes to show that you can not count on extensions to filter web requests in your browser. You must do it at the network level or have a dedicated browser for it (e.g. Tor Browser). Unfortunately it's often extensions that have all the contextual information needed to make the decisions you want. 0 - https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=824705#c4 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=824705...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sp332 8y agoIn Firefox, add-ons aren't allowed to modify built-in pages either, like settings pages. At least they do seem to work on PDFs.
- tomvangoethem 8y agoThe main reason why the issue isn't present in Firefox is because their PDF reader (PDF.js) does not have an API to trigger requests (it does execute JS included within the PDF though)
- tim1994 8y agoIt depends. Extensions cannot modify or do anything with the content of a PDF tab (I wanted to make a PDF dark mode extension). I wish there were special permissions for that.
- abtinf 8y agoIs there a privacy-maximizing combination of browsers and extensions that keeps the web mostly usable? I'm currently running chrome with uBlock Origin and uMatrix. uMatrix is a bit of a hassle, but I didn't realize the scope of the threat landscape until I saw the huge number of (potential) trackers called out by almost every site.
- daxterspeed 8y agogorhill, the developer of uBlock Origin, has already fixed the issues affecting uBlock Origin (AppCache and SW). "Regarding [who left open the cookie jar] I was contacted in March by one of the researcher regarding the "behind-the-scene" issues (the "AppCache" and "SW" columns in the tables). This was fixed in 1.15.20 [...]" https://twitter.com/gorhill/status/1030071494263615489 https://twitter.com/gorhill/status/1030071494263615489 I believe the only proper step up from your setup would be to switch to browsing exclusively via Tor. Generally smaller browsers that advertise themselves as "privacy-maximizing" make basic mistakes like serving their own user agent - instead of using one of the extremely common user agents. Or at least that was the situation a few years ago.
- FridgeSeal 8y agoMaybe swap from Chrome to Firefox? If nothing else, Firefox isn’t built by a literal advertising company.
- abtinf 8y agoIs there a meaningful distinction between a browser built by an advertising company, and a browser built by another company that earns almost all of its revenue from the advertising company?
- move-on-by 8y ago* Well, Firefox being fully open source is certainly a distinction that counts with me. * Their built-in tracking protection is also another distinction [1]. * Ability to modify core settings to improve privacy is also really nice, but not viable for the average user [2]. * Firefox on android is the only mobile browser that allows you to install add-ons. I'm not talking special mobile-made add-ons. Any add-on that you can install on desktop, you can install on the mobile version. Although usability will definitely vary. uBlock Origin, Privay Badger, Decentraleyes, Cookie AutoDelete - all available on Firefox mobile for android I'm not going to go as far as saying Firefox deserves your 100% trust. They have definitely made some missteps along the way. However, as far as meaningful distinction, yes I think that is well earned. [1] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/tracking-protection https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/tracking-protection [2] https://www.privacytools.io/#about_config https://www.privacytools.io/#about_config
- pbreit 8y agoI always wondered if it was possible to embed JavaScript in a PDF for tracking or other purposes. The article suggests: "The techniques allowed them to track users across sites by means of Javascript in PDF tables" Has anyone done this? Is there any literature about it (I didn't find any after a quick look).
- phjesusthatguy3 8y agoBrowsers don't automatically attach cookies to all HTTP requests by default.
- zaroth 8y agoWait, I’m confused. These all seem like basic unit testing bugs? Unit testing cookie read/write permissions isn’t “a thing?” I’m going to say something crazy; At least some of the major browser vendors are violating a warranty with this. An entirely fake privacy crucial setting?! Obviously they knew and left it there deceptively, because the alternative is even worse.
- w0mbat 8y agoFrom the awkward grammar of the name, this project must have been named by a German.
- cm2187 8y agoI wish browsers had an option to make all cookies and site data local to the domain visited in the url of the browser. So if you are domain on “x”, and there is an iframe into domain “z”, the data would be local to domain “x.z”. When you would visit domain “y” which also has an iframe to domain “z”, its data would be local to “y.z” and therefore you couldn’t be tracked by “z” when going from “x” to “y”. Of course that would probably break google analytics, so I don’t expect this on chrome.
- joking 8y agoNot really, it would break adwords but for google analytics you don't need to correlate the users between x.z and y.z, and if you need as you control both sites, you can do changing the link between both to include de google analytics session id (watch for gid parameter on urls).
- cm2187 8y agoBut how can google analytics tell the demographics of a site if it can not identify its users and correlate it with what it knows on them?
- Dylan16807 8y agohttps://www.ctrl.blog/entry/firefox-fpi https://www.ctrl.blog/entry/firefox-fpi
- delidumrul 8y agoI hope there could be more tests on Brave browser, too, which aims to improve privacy. But its most lovely feature imo is opening any kind of tab (normal, private, private on Tor network) on the same window. I wonder if this causes some backdoors, though. I support so that it can become better.