3 ms·
You're dramatically over-simplifying by using one example to claim it's law. That is not the US law, that's one individual instance. In fact it's unsettled lega
by adventured 8y ago
You're dramatically over-simplifying by using one example to claim it's law. That is not the US law, that's one individual instance. In fact it's unsettled legal territory. The Supreme Court has yet to settle it, and they will very likely be the final word.
- ransom1538 8y agoI re-read my comment, I didn't say "That is the US law".
- ben509 8y agoRe-read the parent as well, because it also doesn't claim you did. You absurdly oversimplified the situation, which is the criticism, please address that.
- emiliobumachar 8y agoThat one precedent sets the most reasonable expectation of what U.S. law means in practice, unless and until overturned.
- eric_the_read 8y agoOnly in the 3rd Circuit; other jurisdictions aren't obliged to follow its precedent.