4 ms·
If I put my shareholder hat on I can believe that competence at the CEO level is 312x more valuable than at the worker level. Personally, I'm suspicious that a
by roenxi 8y ago
If I put my shareholder hat on I can believe that competence at the CEO level is 312x more valuable than at the worker level.
Personally, I'm suspicious that all the extra money won't correlate with any sort of useful increase in performance. How is paying these people more going to encourage better decisions? It just means they'll have more comfortable holidays. I've seen head-office politics, and believe that the system used for promotions can tell great from terrible. But there is no way it has the capability of picking who would be best choice to run a company out of 50 senior management figures. There is a lot of pot luck in whether the market conditions are favorable in any given CEOs tenure. Anyone 3-4 levels away from the frontline probably has a reasonable shot at being the best choice to manage a large company.
- ballenf 8y agoAnother informative metric might be the ratio of pay of a manager to all managed employee salaries. So as companies grow and consolidate, you have a single CEO managing the employee force of a dozen acquired companies (or what could be separated out into many different companies). Just seems like CEOs today are something like the CEO of multiple CEOs, companies have grown so large. Should the person who is skilled at managing CEOs be paid more than the CEO that is skilled at managing business units? The market says 'yes'. Maybe CEOs should just explain that they have x jobs, one for each business unit. And then get paid independently for each one.
- duxup 8y agoI think the pot luck you describe combined with it being super hard to evaluate who is a valuable executive and who isn't ... just makes it a very muddy / weird market.
- Eridrus 8y agoMaybe it's just me, but I'm not really mad at how much the CEO of the big tech company I work at makes, it really has no impact on me. If we took his compensation and spread it around, no-one would feel it. I was much more irked by the difference between founder/early employee stakes at a startup where the magnitude of the difference was much smaller than 312x, but redistributing their stake would actually have been felt due to the smaller size.
- aeternus 8y agoHow much risk did those founders take though? Consider the salary they could have made at a large company and that they effectively invested 100% of that at seed-stage multiples. (Assuming they were taking zero salary early on). There was significant risk the founders investment in the form of time could have gone to zero, they deserve some return on that risk.
- village-idiot 8y agoIirc studies have shown very little correlation between executive compensation and company productivity/profitability. The CEO is worth more than the typical janitor or manual laborer, you’d be pretty hard pressed to prove otherwise. But the current compensation scheme seems to be way out of wack with what each employee actually brings to the table.
- zimablue 8y agoI think this study has the same problem as the argument that hedge funds are a waste of time because hedge funds don't make money on average. Imaging the average return of hedge funds was 50%, what would happen? people would open up more and more less and less competent hedge funds until it was a flat return and no longer attractive. You're measuring the results post (arguably) a market force which has impacted the results. If paying managers more than the current average showed obvious results, the average would go up. You also have correlation/causation. I'm not sure if i'm pro bosses mental pay or whether I think it makes any difference just don't buy this argument/study.
- jimbokun 8y ago"I think this study has the same problem as the argument that hedge funds are a waste of time because hedge funds don't make money on average." Maybe they are a waste of time, on average?
- zimablue 8y agoNot making money on average like I'm trying to say is a true but meaningless statement. But there's a difference between the statement: "I can't make money on average by putting money into this system (this system isn't undervalued)" and "This system is worthless" which is kind of conflated. Like the system will always expand to the point that there's no free cash on the table, so looking at it and saying "on average paying more for CEOs or putting money into a random hedge fund doesn't move the dial" has no bearing on whether executive pay being high or hedge funds existing is keeping money off the table (if they were smaller/lower there would be gain to expanding). The gradient at the equilibrium is always zero, "We found that paying developers more or less doesn't impact the average success of a firm". Yeah because there's an equilibrium where the firms/market has decided roughly what a developer costs, and everyone is paid close to that. That's not an argument that developer pay should be wildly less, because if the average was moved to "developers make $10k per year" than at THAT point, far from the equilibrium, you'd see a big gradient that firms who paid developers more (ergo probably got better devs) did far better.
- vwcx 8y agoPersonally, I think of the 312x multiple (or other obscene comp number) as a mind-controlling poison a board likes to force upon a CEO. The compensation is so high that the executive is forced to adopt a "company/profit-first" mindset. The multiplier helps dissuade humanist thinking.