3 ms·
I disagree. Nations are kind of arbitrary from this perspective. Physics doesn't care about the lines we put on our maps. Per capita is better, but the best st
by api 8y ago
I disagree. Nations are kind of arbitrary from this perspective. Physics doesn't care about the lines we put on our maps.
Per capita is better, but the best statistic is probably per capita weighted by GDP per capita and other indices of development. This would show the most efficient countries that are getting the most value for the least emissions.
Here's a pure GDP list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_ratio_of_GDP_to_carbon_dioxide_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_ratio_of_...
The top ones seem like they could be outliers due to some distorting economic effect (e.g. huge exports and low per capita GDP) but among them you have the familiar European nations that are often cited as models of good governance: Switzerland, Sweden, Norway, etc. The USA is toward the middle of the pack. China is near the bottom.
This matters more because it shows the politically reasonable path that we might take, and because more development usually correlates with lower birth rates. Any path that reduces development will tend to increase birth rates, negating any benefit. The development / birth rate correlation holds across cultures, religions, and ethnic groups. (I find the fact that it holds even in majority conservative Muslim and Catholic countries surprising, but it does.)
- strainer 8y agoCO2 per kWh focuses purely on the issue of attained performance of electricity production - which is the main matter for production technology to concentrate on. Dividing by GDP flatters the view of wealthier nations, and GDP itself is not a real measure of wealth or benefit to self and others. The purely technical measure of CO2 per kWh avoids argument of who is most/least beneficial by examining where production is performing best.
- lcam84 8y agoWe need to get rid of GDP as a measure of progress. There are better measures like genuine progress Indicator. A measure that improves with pollution, disease and war must not be used for the sake of all.