7 ms·
Exactly? Scarface is saying that the refusal to promote a message is also part of free speech, and an easier case than the refusal to serve gay customers. At be
by threatofrain 8y ago
Exactly? Scarface is saying that the refusal to promote a message is also part of free speech, and an easier case than the refusal to serve gay customers. At best your response is to ask those who have sympathy towards gay people, "Why don't you get angry at laws which suggest that businesses have to serve gay people, even if their religious beliefs tell them that homosexuality is a sin?"
I also wouldn't be surprised if the thinking behind so many Fortune 500 companies is at least due to a calculation of brand posture going into the future. A lot of the companies being discussed at the moment are social media companies, and youth are the ones who can drive a MySpace event.
I also must ask for elaboration as to the Alex Jones brand of conservatism -- does it involve a narrative of white extinction and undeserving blacks? False flag stories about the Sandy Hook shooting? Does he represent American conservatism?
- Dagwoodie 8y agoThe baker comparison doesn't work. You don't see one guy or even three companies in Colorado controlling 99% of the messages going on cakes, globally, like you do with social media speech on Google/Facebook/Twitter platforms in California. Whether you like it or not, they are monopolies who are coordinating attacks on conservatives by stifling speech that is by and large perfectly legal in the US. Very concerning.
- scarface74 8y agoIf you are completely dependent on exposure through Google, Facebook, and Twitter, you're doing it wrong. I read about plenty of bloggers who lost half thier traffic the day Google Reader shut down for instance. Wasn't their a clickbait company that went out of business due to an algorithm change on Google? Even if you aren't controversial, you are just one of millions of people trying to get your ideas out. You're going to languish in obscurity unless you have an alternate means of promoting yourself. No one "stifled" Alex Jones' speech. His podcast is still being published on his own site like it always was and you can still add it to your podcast app of choice.
- aviv 8y agoHe represents free speech. He is just one of several conservative leaning voices silenced by Big Tech in recent months. One of the most troubling aspects of the Alex Jones ban is the obvious coordination among Apple, Facebook, YouTube and others to completely take him off their platforms at the exact same time. How this doesn't bother HN is crazy. It's truly crazy how YouTube takes down Alex Jones easily but ElsaGate pedo like predatory channels are still thriving on their platform, with millions of views and comment threads full of cryptic information exchange of the worst kind one can imagine. And it's still up. Insanity prevails.
- tomc1985 8y agoIf FANG were government institutions then yes I think a lot of the people here would be alarmed. But they aren't -- they are private companies, who can suppress or promote whatever they want. It doesn't matter whether or not you or I or anyone else likes it, that's just how it is. The courts have affirmed corporate personhood, and their resulting freedom of speech, and in this case they are free to suppress things they host on their platform. There is an interesting legal argument I heard recently that says that if you operate a private space much in the way as if it were a public space (like a privately-owned park open to the public) then there is a sliding scale regarding how much that space is legally considered 'public' (regardless of ownership), for the purposes of law enforcement, or whatever else (like being a venue for protected free speech). I wonder if, at some point, Google/YouTube et al could possibly be seen under such a lens. Maybe then you could argue private takesdowns are a violation of free speech.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoWhile you may genuinely believe what you're saying, I think many people saying as much are doing so out of cognitive dissonance. For instance, imagine if these tech companies decided to start removing all negative discussion of Trump. There would be quite the outrage, and very understandably so. I say understandably so not because of the topic in question, but because these companies have become monoliths of speech in the US. It's not like a local coffee shop or whatever kicking somebody out because of their views - removing direct access to hundreds of millions of people is something altogether different. One issue we have is that companies today, in the era of the internet, have grown well beyond any conceivable notion of what it meant to be a company in the past. Facebook now has more than 30% of the world's population in monthly users. They have more active users than any country has citizens. And they exercise more control over them (at least within the confines of the digital world) than nations do as these users' rights and privileges are dictated under a set of unidirectionally imposed terms as opposed to any sort of a public constitution or system of rights. In a way it almost feels like the digital era is perhaps echoing back our evolution from master-slave societies which gradually evolved to feudal societies and eventually onto democratic ones. Should companies begin to be treated more as we might think of governments once their reach begins to expand beyond that even of governments? I'm not sure, but I do think that we also can't simply appeal to former views. For instance the founding fathers certainly gave no consideration to how companies, with more users than the world population in the 18th century, ought be regarded.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThat's a typical but significant misrepresentation of the bakery case. The baker was/is completely willing to serve gay individuals in any capacity aside from creating customized cakes for gay weddings. He would have been fine with the gay couple buying absolutely anything in the store, including pre-made cakes that could be used for a wedding, and he also offered to create customized goodies for any other service including wedding showers -- but the one thing he would not make is the centerpiece cake for the wedding itself as he felt it would require him to personally 'endorse' their marriage with what he viewed as customized art, something the price tags these cakes carry tends to validate. Most people do not intuitively see wedding cakes as art, but you can see the issue much more clearly if you view him as a literal artist. An artist refusing to sell a print of one of his pieces to a gay individual because they were gay is illegal and absurd. An artist refusing a contract because he felt the piece requested would endorse homosexuality, which went against his personal views - is not unreasonable. --- As for companies positioning themselves for the future, I think you might be surprised if you decided to do some searching for information on the aggregate views of generation z. Political trends in the US are on a pendulum. One side goes batshit insane in one direction which results in the growth of a major counter culture which eventually reaches a happy medium but then they themselves start to go batshit insane in the other direction, breeding what would now be seen as a counter-counter-culture to people who have lived long enough. This repeats seemingly to no end. The 60s created the 80s which created the 2000s which is now creating the 2020s. Probably not coincidentally that 20 years is just about the length of time it takes for a new generation to come into its own. Oh well, we can all at least look forward to the 2030s - Mars and political sanity!
- scarface74 8y agoAnd in the case of Apple - the first company that took action against Jones - they didn't block access to his website or podcast. They just decided not to index it. Edit: To clarify that Apple doesn’t host the RSS feed. It just indexes it like Google indexes web pages. The RSS feed is self hosted on another server.
- scarface74 8y agoWith the changing demographics in America, I doubt we will ever go back to the Trump style populism where if you’re not a White Evangelical straight Christian you aren’t a “true American”. I’m Black, live in a town that was famously a “sundown town” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundown_town https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundown_town) up until the mid 80s and even here the demographics and mindsets are changing. We are still very much the minority but my son’s classmates and thier parents welcome him with open arms into thier homes. True the county is overwhelmingly Republican but they are more Romney/Bush style Republicans thsn Trump populists.