5 ms·
MoviePass (incorrectly) assumed it would be able to strike sweetheart deals with all theater chains, thus drastically reducing overall costs. It even sounds goo
by paxys 8y ago
MoviePass (incorrectly) assumed it would be able to strike sweetheart deals with all theater chains, thus drastically reducing overall costs. It even sounds good in theory - why wouldn't the theater want to get paid for seats that would have otherwise gone empty and have more people inside buying concessions?
It could even have worked - maybe five or ten years ago. Now the theaters themselves quickly realized the value of such a subscription model, and made the logical decision to cut out MoviePass entirely and just offer it themselves.
It's similar to how Netflix would never exist had it started out today, because no studio would surrender their back-catalogs to them for pennies.
- devoply 8y ago> It's similar to how Netflix would never exist had it started out today, because no studio would surrender their back-catalogs to them for pennies. I personally doubt the longevity of Netflix. On it's own it's not much more than a cable channel, like say AMC. Its success depends on producing very good content... it has not mastered this at all. Over time most studios will back out of their deals with it.
- exelius 8y agoIt’s more like HBO, but yes, I agree. In fact, Netflix has largely become HBO while HBO was becoming Netflix, so they’re largely the same at this point. VOD services are here to stay, and the catalog shifting will continue in order to maximize value. Netflix is doing it at least as well as anyone else.
- kumarvvr 8y ago> on producing very good content This is not necessarily true. Even moderately good content, catering to a specific audience will suffice. IIRC, NF has loads of user data and behavioural data to help it guide in production. Assuming an average, not fully satisfied consumer subscribes to NF for 1 year, that's 120 $ per consumer. Assume a show that takes 100 million to produce, say 3 seasons. To make the production break-even, NF will need around 840000 paying subscribers (currently it has around 125 million subscribers, so about 0.672% of its total subscriber base) , who don't even have to watch it in the first place. Now that's a very small number compared to the amount of paying subscribers currently on it's platform. To me it seems to be a very profitable model, at least for 10 - 15 years from now. Edit : Updated the math. Edit 2 : An average episode costs between 3 - 5 million. Lets take 5 million as the cost per episode. With 125 million subscribers paying 120 $ per year, Netflix can produce 3000 episodes. That's just for 1 year. Also, in India, many shows cost way less than 5 million USD. But I have seen NF splurge of shows (it is hiring top notch actors in India for it's shows, where traditionally and culturally, a movie star playing in a "TV" series usually means an end-of-career move, so it's a big thing to work on a NF show here in India)
- fred256 8y ago$10/month = $120/year, not $1200/year.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoYour "Edit 2" math doesn't take into consideration any of the costs for Netflix's infrastructure or employees not related to content production, which is substantial.
- kumarvvr 8y agoYes. With other operational expenses taken into account, maybe NF can produce 1000 episodes a year. That is a huge figure by any margin.
- shanghaiaway 8y agoDivide by markets and genres and its not so much.
- mynameisvlad 8y ago> it has not mastered this at all This is incredibly subjective. They've definitely shown they can produce such content. They had more nominations than any other provider, including HBO for this year's Emmy Awards.
- scarface74 8y agoHBO and all of the pay channels survive off of $10 a month subscriptions. It doesn’t have to be very good content. It just has to be good enough. The real issue with Netflix is that it has to fund all of its content via subscription revenue. The upcoming Disney service doesn’t. By the time it’s content hits the service, it’s slready made money from theatrical releases, pay tv services(?), video on demand, DVD sales, cable TV etc.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoHaving Disney content available on all those other distribution channels makes their streaming service less compelling though. Whereas if you want to watch a Netflix series, you sign up for Netflix. Also, Netflix is building a huge content catalog that has value outside their streaming ecosystem if they decide to leverage it that way. They could do theatrical releases and let cable do reruns of their shows. Maybe they will some day. But for now I think they see the greater CLTV in keeping that content exclusive to drive (and retain) monthly subscriptions.
- scarface74 8y agoDisney's streaming can afford to be less valuable. It's just additional revenue. Netflix's total revenue for 2017 was 11.69 Billion. Disney's revenue was $45 billion. Estimated are that once they combine with Fox, it will have revenue of close to $75 billion. Another thing that makes Disney's content more compelling is that it's "evergreen" kids can watch the same shows over and over again. They will watch the first Toy Story movie just as excitedly as the last Pixar movie.
- paxys 8y agoNetflix has been losing third-party content very rapidly for a while now, but users seem to be sticking regardless. Scrolling through their front page right now I'd say a good 80-90% of shows I see are Netflix-produced, and it isn't going to be hard for anyone to find something that is good enough to watch.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoGlobally Netflix doesn't have much competition. HBO, Amazon, Hulu etc are America focused while Netflix has done a lot to cater to local markets.
- Mindwipe 8y agoNetflix has stacks of local market competition in every local market. They're just not companies Americans know of.
- jscholes 8y ago> Netflix has stacks of local market competition in every local market. They're just not companies Americans know of. I'm in the UK and I can't really think of any serious competition they have here. Maybe Amazon, but I don't know anybody who's talking about Amazon Prime originals.
- brianstorms 8y agoProblem is, it's nigh impossible for a tech company to "strike deals with all the theater chains," be they sweetheart or not so sweet. The movie theater biz is one of the most inept around, stuck in the 1950's in terms of its business model. I did a tech startup that tried to bring social/mobile/local tech to the movie theater experience, and the theaters balked. They fear technology. It took a decade of fearmongering for theaters to fork over millions to buy digital projectors. The last thing they want is tech that will empower moviegoers. What you discover with the "exhibition industry" (what theaters like to call themselves) is that they are in the fast-food business. Popcorn, soda, candy, junk food: this is what the theater sells. The movie is there just to bring you into the building. But what they want you to buy is the concessions. Without the movie nobody in the world would wander into a theater and order a popcorn and a soda for $12 or whatever. When I spoke with exhibitors, I found them to be like realtors: really paranoid, untrusting of their competition, and particularly untrusting of uppity little tech startups (can't really blame 'em, I mean, if a tech startup ever gets successful they tend to wipe out everything in their wake--witness Netflix, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, Craigslist, etc.) Despite the fact that we had built an app that presented a compelling case for a $1 billion or higher bump in annual U.S. box office revenue--we basically came up with ways to get more people to go to more movies more often--the exhibitors would have none of it. They didn't trust it, they wanted nothing to do with it. ESPECIALLY if their competitors in the same city had the same tech. The idea of a mobile app that empowered moviegoers to get alerted to every moving coming, and track upcoming movies after you indicated you liked the trailer, and tracked your favorite stars/directors/etc, and tracked the reviews of your favorite critics, and tracked what your friends were planning to go see, none of that meant diddly to exhibitors. It was the craziest thing I've ever seen. The way theaters are trying to survive now is by focusing on what their core competence is: food. Notice how many theaters now sell hamburgers and pizza and sandwiches, and beer and wine, and so on. You go to a movie now, you may be set back for $30 in meal fees per person easily. For an exhibitor, that's nirvana. Nah, MoviePass was doomed from day one.
- paxys 8y agoThat isn't always true - e.g. Fandango was able to find success even when theaters wanted nothing to do with the internet, until all of them were forced to partner with it or risk being left out.
- hristov 8y agoNope it would not have worked. You see movie theater owners have to pay the movie owner a per viewer fee. So it is not merely about filling up empty seats. The entire "filling up empty seats" story relies on the misconception that if you have empty seats there is a zero marginal cost to extra viewers, but that is not the case, movie owners charge per ticket sold. The deal movie pass offered theaters was "if you make a deal with us, we can help you raise revenues at a marginal loss." No sane business person wants that. The point of business is to make money not lose it. Moviepass was always a crazy impossible scheme. The business model was: get famous, get high growth, then we'll figure something out. This is something we rational people do not like to think about, but there are people out there that take bold and reckless actions without thinking much or at all about the consequences, under a belief that it will all work out in the end. You can just look at the political news to confirm that.
- Crazometer 8y agoThe marginal cost is likely significantly lower than the ticketed price. I'm sure there is a win-win there somewhere. In Australia tickets are about $20 ea retail. Many of the cinemas have deals regularly offering tickets for around $15. If you are with certain telcos you can get tickets all year round for $13.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hristov 8y agoI am not sure your statement about the marginal cost is correct. This is a closely guided secret among studios and exhibitors, but the little anecdotal information that leaks out indicates that for well publicized major releases the studios want pretty much the entirety of the ticket price and the theater can only make money off of concessions. There isn't much room for moviepass in here. Even for movies that are not as well popular and give more margin to exhibitors, it is very hard to see how you can accommodate moviepass and the crazy discounts they give. Lets take a person that sees about 4 movies per month which should be kind of usual for moviepass. That gives about $2.50 per showing. This has to be shared between moviepass, the theater and the movie owner. While before moviepass, only the theater and the movie owner could share $10. I don't see how this does not end up severely impacting the profitability of the theater, the movie owner or both. I really do not see a win-win in the moviepass pricing model.
- rmc 8y ago> It's similar to how Netflix would never exist had it started out today, because no studio would surrender their back-catalogs to them for pennies. Netflix: "The Goal Is to Become HBO Faster Than HBO Can Become Us" https://gizmodo.com/5980103/netflix-the-goal-is-to-become-hbo-faster-than-hbo-can-become-us https://gizmodo.com/5980103/netflix-the-goal-is-to-become-hb...
- phobosdeimos 8y agoAs I understand it Americans buy a lot of food and drink at movie theaters at exorbitant prices without a care in the world. That is were the income comes from.
- deboflo 8y agoKindof like uber potentially being left out of autonomy by OEM’s who will likely offer their own ride sharing services.