3 ms·
Countries in Europe with higher suicide rates than the US: Sweden, Switzerland, Austria, Belgium, Finland, France, Russia, Belarus, Poland, Latvia, Hungary, Sl
by adventured 8y ago
Countries in Europe with higher suicide rates than the US:
Sweden, Switzerland, Austria, Belgium, Finland, France, Russia, Belarus, Poland, Latvia, Hungary, Slovenia, Ukraine, Estonia, Croatia, Serbia, Bulgaria.
Countries with nearly as high of a suicide rate:
Germany, Czech, Portugal, Iceland
Countries in Europe with high suicide rates, but solidly below the US:
Slovakia, Denmark, Netherlands, Ireland, Romania, Norway
All of these nations have higher suicide rates today than the US did in the late 1990s.
So is the premise that the US would have a far lower rate of suicide than European nations if guns were more tightly controlled, or would people in the US commit suicide in other ways as they do in European nations?
- bsder 8y agoYour statements match neither raw data nor standardized rate: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_r...
- _delirium 8y agoUnless I'm misreading, the data you link suggests that the correct interpretation is that the US has basically middle-of-the-road suicide rates by European standards, no? Going by the age-standardized rates, it's sandwiched between Sweden and France in the list. Some European countries are significantly higher (Belgium, Poland), while others are significantly lower (Spain, UK), but the US doesn't seem to be a real outlier.
- DanBC 8y agoThe linked page says you can't compare suicide rates across countries. For example, the UK statistics would tend to over count deaths. Here's the definition we use: ---begin The National Statistics definition of suicide includes all deaths from intentional self-harm for persons aged 10 and over, and deaths where the intent was undetermined for those aged 15 and over. This definition was revised in January 2016 and further information on the impact can be found in the 2014 suicide registrations bulletin. Deaths from an event of undetermined intent in 10 to 14 year-olds are not included because although for older teenagers and adults we assume that in these deaths the harm was self-inflicted, for younger children it is not clear whether this assumption is appropriate. Deaths from an event of undetermined intent cannot be applied to children due to the possibility that these deaths were caused by unverifiable accidents, neglect or abuse. ---end I'm unable to find the definition used by the CDC, but I think it's likely to include language like "with the intent to end life".
- Markoff 8y agonot sure what have suicide rates to do with guns, they are based on various socioeconomic factors so if you want honestly compare us with something you should find country with similar living standards, environment etc which doesn't have easily accessible guns but you are right banning access to guns doesn't mean that 100% of those people won't commit suicide, but I guess it could shave at least few percentage points from suicides by gun and most importantly gun accidents would be drastically reduced, you don't see children accidentally killing/hurting someone daily in Europe if you want serious comparison i am aware of only one country with similar cultural background - Australia, proving limiting gun access can reduce crime, accidents etc
- DanBC 8y ago> not sure what have suicide rates to do with guns The most important public health action to reduce suicide is to reduce access to means and methods, especially the most lethal methods. Guns are particularly lethal. > but I guess it could shave at least few percentage points from suicides by gun It's closer to 50%. There are 20,000 suicide deaths by gun in the US each year, out of a total of 45,000 suicide deaths. The US has decided that those 20,000 deaths are a price worth paying for the fun of playing with their guns.