4 ms·
> In law school, they told me I wouldn’t be able to read anymore. That the pleasure of the text, like a lover in a non-law degree, would slowly grow opaque to m
by gnicholas 8y ago
> In law school, they told me I wouldn’t be able to read anymore. That the pleasure of the text, like a lover in a non-law degree, would slowly grow opaque to me.
This is strange — I never heard anything remotely like this in law school, and most lawyers I know do a good deal of outside reading. I wonder where the author heard this advice, and why she doesn't say who "they" is.
Am I the only one who never heard this cautionary advice in law school?
- th0ma5 8y agoMaybe it was that person's experience they mistook for a useful generality. I personally experience this reading 8+ hours a day but I probably could get into more casual reading if I really wanted to. It is weird to say to people that I read constantly but I think the last novel I read was several years ago.
- gnicholas 8y agoI also don't read many novels, but I never did. I read dozens or hundreds of news articles daily, as well as non-fiction books. Did you ever read novels (outside of those assigned in school)? I assume you still read a lot of non-work stuff, even if just news?
- th0ma5 8y agoYes I guess I do read a bunch of non-work stuff, or stuff that may be work someday :P I did re-read Douglas Adams, and I guess I read The Grapes of Wrath, that's within the last decade... I'm sure I've read some New Yorker long pieces, and I guess I do watch a lot of film.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSame, I worked in a technical/legal role which involved lots of reading and almost completely stopped reading for pleasure.
- engi_nerd 8y agoAs part of my current job I have to read about 100 - 300 pages of technical material a day. I still read for pleasure, but less so when I cross that 300 page marker for a day. The worst was when I had to review ~ 10,000 pages of material for a presentation. I wasn't reading all of that -- I maybe read 1/10th in great detail, and skimmed half after I determined it was relevant -- but even so, for a couple of weeks after that I didn't read for pleasure at all.
- gnicholas 8y agoWhat line of work are you in?
- jaredhansen 8y agoI never heard anything like this either, and in fact my own experience was opposite that of the author's: the precision emphasized in law school simply adds an additional dimension to the enjoyment of prose (or, once in a great while, poetry). The whole idea that "thinking like a lawyer" should mean you forget how to enjoy reading and writing reminds me of Keats' claim that Newton destroyed the rainbow by explaining it. It's unfortunate that the author had such a bad experience with the law - but this is either strikingly bad pedagogy or simply a poor match with her specific personality, and shouldn't be taken as a reflection on the practice of law itself.
- mirimir 8y agoI never went to law school, but I did spend a few years consulting with law firms. And it was then that I learned to read critically. And strategically. Even after a PhD and some years in academia. However, I didn't read much fiction then. There just wasn't enough time.
- crooked-v 8y agoI'm also reminded of tabletop gaming, where if done well the rules text affects the je ne sais quoi of the game without having to be so crass as to actually tell people how to play. One example is the game Monsterhearts, where you play Buffy/Twilight/Teen Wolf/etc "teenage supernatural drama" types. The rules are carefully designed to make relationship drama and petty inter-group conflict a natural result of play, even if the players are levelheaded sorts who wouldn't act that way at all on their own.
- fenwick67 8y agoOr Risk, which is apparently designed to make you hate your friends
- BrandoElFollito 8y agoWe had a rule of never finishing a Monopoly game. We would end at 70% or so, so that people continue to talk to each other that night.
- cafard 8y agoI am not a lawyer, and never attended law school. However, I can think of lawyers who have been novelists (Louis Auchincloss comes to mind) or notable critics (John Jay Chapman). And certainly I've known quite a few lawyers who read widely.