4 ms·
What does that scenario look like if Germany no longer gets to free ride on the Euro at the expense of Spain, Portugal, Greece, Italy? They get to use an artif
by adventured 8y ago
What does that scenario look like if Germany no longer gets to free ride on the Euro at the expense of Spain, Portugal, Greece, Italy?
They get to use an artificially cheap currency (cheap for them) to drive the largest trade imbalances on earth. They're plundering the Eurozone and EU, just look at the trade surplus they have in their own economic region ($180b trade surplus just with the EU alone). Were they using their own currency, their exports would suffer immensely. How long can that destabilizing arrangement continue? Not much longer, judging by several of their fellow Eurozone nations.
Even with all of that, their median household net worth is still lower than the US.
- pjc50 8y agoWhat do the internal US trade balances between e.g. California and the rest look like?
- toast_coder 8y agoCalifornia exports to the the rest of us mostly. Lots of food, high end manufacturing, services, and they have a huge slice of the asia-us trade logistics.
- pjc50 8y agoSo ... why does nobody care about trade deficits in the dollarzone? Why isn't this seen as "plundering"?
- WillPostForFood 8y agoLargely shared debt burden via the federal govt?
- toast_coder 8y agoExactly.
- tinco 8y agoIs this similar to how California gets a free ride on the dollar at the expense of Mississippi, Alabama and Louisiana? Seriously, I don't understand, what does a cheap currency (what does that even mean) have to do with trade surplus?
- atlantic 8y ago> eriously, I don't understand, what does a cheap currency (what does that even mean) have to do with trade surplus? The way international trade works in theory is like this: when a country is running a trade surplus, demand for its currency increases, so that other countries can buy its goods. That extra demand drives up the exchange rate, which makes its goods more expensive, which drives down exports, which brings the balance of payments (exports minus imports) back into equilibrium. What happens in the EU is that, because you have a shared currency, this balancing mechanism breaks down, and so trade imbalances between countries can only be corrected via deliberate subsidies (exactly as happens between rich and poor regions inside the US, for instance). But, more than any other EU member, Germany has blocked this kind of policy, choosing to interpret trade imbalances in moral rather than economic terms (southern countries are too lazy, laid back, inefficient, etc).
- tinco 8y agoSo are you saying wealth is distributed less socially in the EU than it is in the states? I've never heard that before but it could be right, I don't know the details of how countries contribute to the EU. I certainly have heard the moral arguments from Germany, as well as from the rest of the rich EU countries. Are poor regions in the US effectively assisted by subsidies? I feel in the EU the main problem is lack of integration, for example if I design a product here in The Netherlands, it would be a lot cheaper to set up a factory in say Poland or Spain, but I'd be hesitant to do that because of cultural and language barriers. I suppose that's less of a problem in the US, though in the US distances are greater.
- atlantic 8y agoRead again. I'm explaining the connection between exchange rates and the balance of payments. Nothing even remotely controversial. Macroeconomics 101.
- skummetmaelk 8y agoYes, as we all know. Germany was a total economic failure before the euro was introduced in 1999. /s
- WillPostForFood 8y agoYes? Germany had decades of high unemployment, and low gap growth until relatively recently.
- seqastian 8y agoExportweltmeister none the less.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoYes, it's just that Germany wasn't looked at as an economy to be emulated until relatively recently. Whether that is due to the benefits of being in the EU, I don't know.
- tim333 8y agoGermany running a trade surplus because people like to buy Mercs and BMWs isn't really plunder. And if say a spaniard builds them a holiday flat on the costa in return for the Merc that's kind of a fair trade though on the accounts I think it'd show as an imbalance as property purchases are accounted for differently to shipped goods.