5 ms·
>11. Imagined pain does not hurt less because it is imagined. I guess I can see how this might be classed as "not bullshit", but I don't see how it's profound
by foldr 8y ago
>11. Imagined pain does not hurt less because it is imagined.
I guess I can see how this might be classed as "not bullshit", but I don't see how it's profound at all. It just seems false to me.
I agreed with all the other classifications.
edit: I know complaining about downvotes is verboten here, but seriously, that's just my take on it. I'd be interested to hear an explanation of what the profound meaning is that I'm missing here.
- alkonaut 8y agoPerhaps because all pain is, in a sense, "imagined"?
- foldr 8y agoI don't think so. The sentence seems to be accepting the distinction between imagined pain and real pain, and saying that the imaginary nature of the former does not cause it to hurt less than the latter (technically leaving open the possibility that it does hurt less for some other reason). Also, we clearly can distinguish imaginary pain from real pain. For example, there's a difference between the real pain I feel if I stub my toe and the imaginary pain I "feel" if I imagine myself stubbing my toe.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoBut a pragmatist in many people would say: “why then that person does not take any antidepressants/codeine?”, if that pain is so painful? So it may be quite a bullshit statement, depending on how you take it.
- foldr 8y agoWe're just talking about cases where people suffer pain because of false beliefs, which can easily happen to people who have no mental health issues. If you heard that a loved one died, you'd be in a lot of pain, regardless of whether or not that report was true (so long as you believed it).
- malloryerik 8y agoBingo. You'd never say, "Oh thank the heavens they didn't die after all and so I was just imagining that pain!"
- abbasaamer 8y agoImagine you are paranoid and you suspect someone is deceiving you. The reality of whether or not they are actually deceiving you does not have an impact on how much pain you feel. Alternatively, someone with a mental condition that leads them to believe they are in pain would conceivably feel the same pain as someone who is actually being physically hurt. Just my take on it.
- foldr 8y agoAs malloryerik said in another comment, that seems to be confusing the cause of the pain with the pain itself. The paranoiac's pain is real, even if the cause is imaginary.
- mcphage 8y ago> The paranoiac's pain is real, even if the cause is imaginary. That's exactly the point of the sentence.
- foldr 8y agoNo, the sentence talks about imaginary pain, not real pain with imaginary causes.
- SamBam 8y agoBut pain is subjective by definition. What does "imaginary pain" mean? The answer can only include some notion of "cause."
- foldr 8y agoImaginary pain is pain in your imagination, just like an imaginary car is a car in your imagination. If you stub your toe, you are really in pain and not just imagining it. If you imagine stubbing your toe, you are only in imaginary pain (assuming that you imagine it to be painful).
- red75prime 8y ago11 does make sense even if it is false. As I see it, the distinction is on make sense/doesn't make sense axis.
- foldr 8y agoIt's supposed to be a distinction between bullshit statements and profound statements, which isn't the same thing at all.
- red75prime 8y agoSurface profoundness is similar in those statements, so I don't think that dividing them by "makes sense" axis is too wrong.
- foldr 8y agoSurface profoundness is a contradiction in terms.
- red75prime 8y agoOK, deep soundingness.
- foldr 8y agoWell, the bullshit sentences also “sound” deep to the untrained ear. That’s part of what makes them bullshit as opposed to just plain nonsense.
- gadders 8y agoI thought it was true, because of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_limb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_limb I guess you could debate whether that is "imagined".
- foldr 8y ago1) It doesn't make sense to call that "imaginary pain". The pain is real -- that's why it's a problem. 2) Do we know that phantom limb pain does not hurt less than the corresponding non-phantom pains? It seems entirely possible that while phantom limb pain is very acute, it's not as actually as bad as the pain associated with losing the limb in the first place. 3) Even waiving 1 and 2, that would be one rather obscure instance of an imaginary pain and a real pain having the same intensity, which would in no way establish the truth of the general statement.
- extragood 8y agoI interpreted that one as emotional/psychological vs physical pain. I was still wrong, because I categorize them differently (not that one is necessarily easier to deal with than the other). In the end it comes down to semantics either way.
- runesoerensen 8y agoI participated in various research experiments at the local university (to earn a bit of money on the side while in high school). The ones that paid the most where usually pain experiments, so I've been through quite a few of those. One thing I found interesting is how incredibly subjective and relative painful experiences are. Increasing and varied types of pain would typically be inflicted over the course of an experiment, while I had to perform various tasks and grade the pain on a scale from 0-10. Very often I'd grade the initial pain around 6-7, and increase that to the maximum of 9-10 during the experiment. The pain I experienced by the end would however be much more severe, and if I could've corrected the initial grading it'd have been closer to 2-3. I guess you could say that I was unable to imagine the level of pain I'd later experience, and how relative pain is perceived in this type of experiment. Just a tangential anecdote, but I didn't call BS on that statement :)
- foldr 8y agoI don't see how that's relevant. That's a situation where you were comparing various real pains to each other in terms of their intensity. You weren't comparing them to imaginary pains.
- runesoerensen 8y agoSure it's a bit of a tangent, but related in the sense that I was hurt more, or less, based on my ability to imagine pain (which in my experience was easier after experiencing it). In any case, the sentence doesn't seem to require the imaginary pain to be equivalent (or even compared) to the pain experienced from whatever is causing the imaginary pain. I don't think that's even possible. It just requires that the pain someone experience from imagining/actually being tortured hurts just as much, albeit likely differently, regardless of the nature or cause of the pain ("imagined"/"real"). The "profoundness" of the sentence is probably related to the already questionable concept "imagined pain"; and how the pain experienced by other people can easily, and way to often, be dismissed and classified as "imaginary". The pain still hurts the person experiencing it though, regardless of whether some might call it imaginary (and whether "imaginary pain" even makes sense).
- JdeBP 8y agoThere's a definition of bullshit given in the paper. It does not relate to whether the statement is true or false (indeed quite the converse, it relating to an absence of concern with truth) and it does relate to whether the statement consistently has an unambiguous meaning. Consider that you understood the statement without complaint of ambiguity, enough to question the truth of the assertion and discuss that with other people without your having to impart your own meaning that you construct. And consider the gyrations and gymnastics that people are applying in this very discussion to impart their own meanings to the other statements that are without consistent unambiguous meaning.
- foldr 8y agoI said that I'm ok with calling it "not bullshit", so I'm not sure what you're getting at. I was questioning whether or not it could properly be called profound.
- JdeBP 8y agoOn the contrary, you've spent almost every post in this sub-thread questioning whether it is true. To question whether it should properly be called profound would be, conversely, to question the paper's methodology. There is, as I said, a definition of bullshit. There is no equivalent definition of profundity. Nor were test subjects asked to evaluate the sentences with an explicit profundity criterion. The so-called profoundness-receptivity metric was actually a measurement of bullshit-receptivity of non-bullshit statements.
- foldr 8y ago>On the contrary, you've spent almost every post in this sub-thread questioning whether it is true Yes, because it's difficult for a statement to be both profound and obviously false. I just said that it's obviously false, so I don't understand why it is labeled "profound" in the paper. That's it.
- munchbunny 8y agoBased on the other comments further down, you seem to be caught up on whether the statement is technically true for specific definitions of pain, rather than the underlying point of the statement. The underlying point is that whether you think that someone's suffering (physical or emotional) has a real or imaginary cause, that doesn't make them suffer any more or less, because you are not in their head, and they are not in yours. Their degree of suffering depends on their perception of reality, not yours, or even objective reality. The statement is an appeal to empathy.
- zamber 8y ago> The statement is an appeal to empathy. Apparently, I'm a highly functioning sociopath then ;).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- foldr 8y agoI agree with the "underlying point", but it simply isn't what the sentence says. If you're willing to put that much effort into interpreting it, practically any statement could qualify as profound.
- munchbunny 8y agoYou've already put far more effort into debating that everyone else's interpretation isn't "simply what the sentence says," when their (and my) interpretation tend to hover around the same approximate meaning. If you're going by effort, it seems that your interpretation is anything but simpler or lower effort. If you're trying to make the point that the statement could have been phrased better, I don't think anyone would disagree with you.
- foldr 8y ago>If you're going by effort, it seems that your interpretation is anything but simpler or lower effort. Hmm? You seem to be mixing up the effort required to reach that interpretation with the effort required to argue with other people about whether it's the correct interpretation.
- tlb 8y agoProfundity is best understood as the quality of leading to a better understanding of situations. The profound statement itself doesn't have to be 100% literally true. "All models are wrong; some models are useful." #11 counters people's default assumption that imagined pain doesn't hurt, because it's not real. You gain more understanding of people who report imagined pain by assuming it hurts the same (even if it might actually hurt a little less) than by assuming it doesn't hurt at all. In the book Dune, Paul Atreides' hand is put in a pain-simulating device and he has to demonstrate his humanity by resisting the urge to pull it out or he'll be killed by a cyanide needle in the neck. You can only understand that scene by assuming the simulated pain hurts as much as real pain.
- slowburning 8y ago“I must not fear. Fear is the mindkiller. I will face my fear. I will let it pass through me. When it is gone, there will be nothing, only I will remain.”
- neltnerb 8y agoThey defined "bullshit" as equivalent to "vacuous" meaning it has no meaningful content at all. That sentence may be obviously true, but it is not vacuous.
- sjbase 8y agoI love this comment thread so much! In challenging whether the statement is profound, you've triggered a lively and thoughtful debate on whether or not it is actually profound, and in doing so proved it to be profound (at least to the HN readership) :)
- rebuilder 8y agoMy wife and I have very different pain thresholds. A few days ago, I was stung by a bee. I told my wife about it after a while, and she was shocked, asking if I wanted a pain killer, but to me it was just a curiosity. To her, a bee sting is a relatively major source of discomfort. You can't grade pain on an objective scale based on what caused it. It's a subjective experience, and therefore if you truly imagine it, it exists.
- foldr 8y agoThat has nothing to do with comparing imagined pain to real pain. You and your wife experience different degrees of real pain in the event of a bee sting. Imaginary pain doesn't come into it. >It's a subjective experience, and therefore if you truly imagine it, it exists. Nope, I can imagine being in pain without being in pain. Similarly, taste is subjective, but I can't satisfy my appetite for chocolate by imagining eating it.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoIt's a direct response to the common belief that mental ailments--depression, anxiety, dysphoria--are less "real" than physical ones. Basically this: http://www.robot-hugs.com/helpful-advice/ http://www.robot-hugs.com/helpful-advice/
- foldr 8y agoCould just be a bad translation then? Perhaps "mental pain" is what is meant.
- mattnewton 8y agoThe question isn’t whether the statements are true or false, it’s between “bullshit” and “not bullshit” - not bullshit being something like “maybe has an element of truth or is a reasonable position to take” Believing pain to not be lesser because it comes from psychosomatic sources is reasonably - Most people will act similarly in my experience, and in any case the statement is saying something Contrast that with the bullshit statements - “The whole silence infinite phenomena”
- cimmanom 8y agoit seems that the point isn’t whether the “profound” sentences are true, nor whether you agree with them. The point seems to be more about being able to detect that the “bullshit” sentences are completely and utterly meaningless despite being (for the most part) grammatically correct and sounding similarly woo-ish to the “profound” ones on the surface.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]