8 ms·
I don't see any justification for the Soviet analogy other than wanting to conjure up the image of the impending collapse of China. This sounds like the infrast
by Barrin92 8y ago
I don't see any justification for the Soviet analogy other than wanting to conjure up the image of the impending collapse of China. This sounds like the infrastructure version of the 'financial bubble' prediction that crops up every other year.
If one wanted to pick a positive story there would be the example of the American progressive era, the creation of the interstate system, the railway system during the 19th century, and so forth. Not every large infrastructure project is indicative of corruption, someone needs to build infrastructure, after all, I don't think we've somehow transcended the need for transportation.
That there's military or geopolitical motivation, especially as far as the land component of the belt and road initiative is concerned seems accurate, but doesn't strike me as particularly bad. From a Chinese perspective it obviously makes sense to invest into continental infrastructure because it does not control the sea.
- lainga 8y agoFrom 3rd paragraph TFA, and unlike 1910-1950s USA, Like the Soviet Union in the 1970s, China is coming to the end of a long labor-force boom, and hoping that an orgy of investment will keep the old magic going while stabilizing its fraying frontiers. Cornelius Vanderbilt wasn't trying to overcome a graying America or shore up the Monroe Doctrine by building railroads in Latin America and Africa. If anything, I fail to see any justification for your comparisons between China and the progressive-era US.
- Barrin92 8y agoI wasn't trying to create any definite story, I'm just saying that it is easy to make a historical analogy depending on what you wantto take away from it. China is not the Soviet Union any more than it is the United States. Doing away with the belt and road initiative by painting it as a Soviet vanity project seems too simple, the country is communist only in name. For me, this narrative seems to be very typical of our European/American mindset. All great infrastructure plans are grandiose planning, we're done growing, we're 2 years away from the next crisis and so forth and projecting it onto China, which seems to have shaken off that very prediction over and over. China's current mode of development does not comply with our 'End of History' like narrative about how countries ought to develop, so we're stuck in a constant loop of shallow pessimistic analogies. I would want to see an in-depth analysis of the project really looking at the consequences with an eye on the long-term effects rather than just stories about some harbor in Africa falling short of expectations. This is not illuminating.
- slimed 8y agoSri Lanka is off the coast of India. Your lack of attention to detail does not give one confidence in your argument.
- Barrin92 8y agoSorry did you respond to the wrong person? The harbour story that recently made headlines concerned the port in Djibouti, which to my knowledge is located in East Africa. I did not mention Sri Lanka.
- greglindahl 8y agoAs mentioned in the fine article: > Failed projects like Sri Lanka’s Hambantota port may indeed be a way for China to quietly extend its strategic power around the world.
- Barrin92 8y agooh well sorry, did not catch that!
- dang 8y agoPlease don't be rude, even if someone got a detail wrong. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- diminish 8y agoFinding a neutral in-depth analysis of the project is not easy. In a Google search, I find Japanese, Indian and European opinions . Yet best is the Wikipedia article IMHO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_and_Road_Initiative You won't find a neutral in-depth analysis of the project in Bloomberg (or FT, Economist,etc) as a substantial amount of stories about China are "wishful thinking" meant to be "self fulfilling prophecies" by influencing investors [1]. I mean mostly against China. [1] David Fickling stories - see the ones about China. https://www.bloomberg.com/authors/AQrSL0m_2u4/david-fickling https://www.bloomberg.com/authors/AQrSL0m_2u4/david-fickling
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThe comparison to Soviet Union is problematic but definitely more relevant than US investment scenarios that you highlighted. The US scenario you highlighted would be more comparable to Chinese investment in the last 25 years, no? The clear difference between Soviet Union and China is that China has a growing and robust economy, with a firm grip on the situation whereas the Soviet Union was aching away on so many lies. Chinese fabricated financials can be papered over with any kind of magic the state wants to apply to it - so long as the economy continues to move forward the numbers will say anything they want them to say. The articles comparison may be overblown but it's not without reason. I believe that the China boom has mostly been had, and we're going to see lower growth from here on in; that said, it'll be consistent and positive and they aren't going to disappear as a superpower.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThere are more booms to be found in China, for sure. But corrections/recessions/crashes are needed to wash out the bad elements so the better ones can thrive. The party has stated they can do this on their own, but given that their families' control of large parts of the economy has become a huge part of the problem they are unwilling to manage (which would have been hard anyways).
- fspeech 8y agoCrashes are happening all the time. For example right now P2P lending is crashing hard. The question is if it is worth it to have a systematic crash in order to clear the markets, as in Andrew Mellon's "liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate the farmers, liquidate real estate." China is not the only one in the modern world unwilling to crash systematically.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> Chinese fabricated financials can be papered over with any kind of magic the state wants to apply to it - so long as the economy continues to move forward the numbers will say anything they want them to say. My feeling is business people and economists are upset that China utterly refuses to follow neoliberal economic polices. Preferring instead to follow old school Keynesian policies. Policy makers thus view China as economically in a state of sin. Typically countries that try to follow Keynesian economic policies get hammered by western central banks and monetary institutions. However China is way both too large to be 'punished' like that and has iron fisted control of it's own currency. That leaves western and in particular US monetary authorities powerless to do anything. Hence the constant butthurt blather for the last 30 years that that Chinese expansion only has 5 more years left before it collapses. Notable: In 2008 the US and Europe followed neoliberal austerity policies to make sure that the banks and paper wealth were made whole. Resulting in a very slow recovery and increasing poverty and political blow back. China responded by building the worlds largest high speed rail network.
- duxup 8y agoI think the main point was that the Chinese investment seems to at times fly in the face of where trade really is / is going. The us interstate system was where there was trade already and not many alternate routes / better systems. China's strategic concers are obvious and make sense...and yet if push came to shove and they were cut off from the sea, are they really trading via rail with Europe or others in that scenario anyway? / is incurring the costs of whole backup systems making sense? Personally I don't have a clue how any of this plays out, just speaking to what the article is indicating.
- fspeech 8y agoNo it doesn't make sense to expect rail to replace sea, however the article failed to note that the Yiwu-Europe rail link is over existing rails and there was very little infrastructure investment other than inland port facilities. The major drive was on the software side -- making trains going through multiple countries less cumbersome. Whatever happens to the BRI the Yiwu-European rail certainly is not to going to be the one to break the bank.
- jeffreybezos 8y agoDo you have a reference for the US interstate system being built where there was trade already?
- duxup 8y agoI guess I don't have any links, but it isn't hard to imagine interstate trade in the US in the mind 20th century. There were military considerations later on but the groundwork before that wasn't entirely military focused.
- jeffreybezos 8y agoI always thought the interstate was a big 'F you' to the rail industry. ...and the rail system seemed to follow along the path of most of the rivers. Now fiber is also placed along these paths.
- factsaresacred 8y ago> it obviously makes sense to invest into continental infrastructure because it does not control the sea. Easier and cheaper to pursue a Blue Water Navy than pump money into questionable projects in corrupt States -- projects who's success is anything but assured (See Malaysia PM planning to cancel all Chinese projects and the mess in Pakistan as recorded by WSJ recently). > someone needs to build infrastructure, after all, I don't think we've somehow transcended the need for transportation. It's more about the opportunity cost and ROI than the need, right?
- oblio 8y agoThe money also buys you influence and good will from the locals (usually), which I imagine China also probably wants. And when did a Blue Water Navy become cheap? It's one of the most expensive military investments, especially if your plan is to break a potential US blockade.
- factsaresacred 8y ago> influence and good will from the locals No good deed goes unpunished. And in this case, the deeds often aren't even good. Locals from Ghana to Bangladesh complain about how China brings in their own workers rather than employ locals, and how the end result is shoddy work and more money in the pocket of corrupt officials. Now it may buy influence from the goverment, but as I mentioned, governments are fickle things and power changes hands frequently. All the same, I don't think this is irrational behavior from China -- they need to win friends and influence people. > And when did a Blue Water Navy become cheap? You'd have to compare the payback period for investing in slum upgrades in Indonesia vs investing in one's own Navy. In many cases it's never vs some intangible number of years.
- DanielGee 8y ago> This sounds like the infrastructure version of the 'financial bubble' prediction that crops up every other year. My favorite is the yearly "end of china" report by gordon chang. I remember the guy talking about china's collapse in the 90s and he's been wrong since.