3 ms·
The key quote: >"It’s worth considering all this misdirected spending in the context of the Soviet Union’s decline. Around the middle decades of the 20th centu
by baybal2 8y ago
The key quote:
>"It’s worth considering all this misdirected spending in the context of the Soviet Union’s decline. Around the middle decades of the 20th century, Moscow presided over a China-style economic miracle that caused many in the West to fear they would be overtaken."
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThe key question may be to what degree China's economy resembles Russia's. If China's is some free-market lipstick on a planned-economy pig, they are likely to suffer Russia's fate. To the extent that the free-market reforms are real, they have a better chance of escaping it. My personal opinion is that China's free market is real, but the state intervention is still fairly heavy for a "free market economy". What does that translate into in terms of China's chance to avoid collapse? I don't know.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nickserv 8y agoThere's also the fact that the Soviets over-extended themselves militarily at the same time, Afghanistan comes readily to mind. China has a large, powerful and I would assume expensive militarily, but has not deployed significant number of troops in the past few decades (since Korea?), and in any case has never occupied a foreign country. That's a huge amount of resources available to spend on infrastructure and "soft" power. The Chinese approach seems much more likely to succeed than the Soviet one.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoChina has been far more worried about (a) internal security, the party is deathly afraid of its own people, and (b) its border countries. On the latter point, China and Russia have even fought some skirmishes over their vast border, and have only been recently back on friendly terms. China did make it all the way to Hanoi during the Sino-Vietnam war back in 1979. I'm not sure what definition of occupy you want to use here.
- AnimalMuppet 8y ago> China ... has never occupied a foreign country. I'm not sure that Tibet would agree with you.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIt is China's position that they never invaded Tibet. The Yuan dynasty invaded and conquered Tibet, but they don't count since they were Mongolians. It is weird logic to be sure, but there it is. Otherwise Tibet was supposed to be Chinese territory afterwards even if the Chinese dynasties following the Yuan didn't actively govern it and mostly left them to their own devices.
- Latteland 8y agoWell then based on what actually happened (invading a county where there were other countries people & troops there since before the founding of modern china) it's not true to say that they haven't invaded anyone. Will they 'not invade' taiwan next? Invading and then declaring it was ours historically is still invading.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIt’s not called the People’s invading army, it’s called the People’s Liberation Army. Now who needs liberating?
- nickserv 8y agoYou're quite right in the sense that the military invaded, but it was not so much an occupation with a puppet government and continuous guerilla warfare , like the Soviets in Afghanistan, the Nazis in France or the US in Iraq. It was more of an anexation of adjoining territory based on historical claims (fabricated or not), like Germany with Alsace Lorraine, Russia with Crimea or the US with certain parts of northern Mexico. The point was not so much about seizure of territory but the huge cost of a prolonged occupation with local resistance. I was definitely not trying to legitimize the invasion of Tibet nor downplaying the suffering of the Tibetan people, so thank you for bringing this up.
- mrep 8y agoTo me, the free market is best represented through market competition. Can anyone comment on how competitive the chinese markets actually are because I have heard that it is still very government/single company dominate focused.