3 ms·
>> Folklore would have it that single-thread performance is the most important aspect of desktop performance There are a few places where it matters. We talk
by sandworm101 8y ago
>> Folklore would have it that single-thread performance is the most important aspect of desktop performance
There are a few places where it matters. We talk of "gaming" but that is too broad a term imho. Many AAA games do leverage AMD chips well. They know how to split loads across threads to maximize performance. But in recent years the hot games have come from indi developers. Pre-release titles from tiny developers aren't properly optimized. If you want to play kerbal space program, single-thread performance is vital (KSP's physics is still single-threaded iirc). If you want to surf the web while running a factorio server, AMD will work fine. But if you want to maximize the performance of that factorio server, the faster single-thread performance of Intel chips would be better.
- ReverseCold 8y agoKSP 1.1 finally added multithreading btw
- orbital-decay 8y agoOnly for different spacecraft, so it only really matters for some planetary bases. A single spacecraft is still processed in a single thread.
- sandworm101 8y agoWhen launching a rocket, that rocket's physics engine is still on a single thread. Given that the physics engine is the most CPU-intensive part of KSP, I'd say that KSP's support of multithreading is nominal at best. Multithreading aside: KSP's approach to physics also doesn't help them. Rather than make creative decisions re what should and shouldn't be calculated, they just hammer the physics thread with lots of calculations that have zero impact on the user experience. In a larger dev these would be optimized away.
- Twirrim 8y agoKSP is now owned by Take Two Interactive (since May). Here's hoping they can get those dev resources!
- blattimwind 8y agoMinecraft reigns king in that category. I don't know if it still does, but a couple years ago Minecraft actually managed to somehow still use the OpenGL immediate mode. Back then the larger Minecraft servers required ridiculous amounts of memory and dedicated a dozen cores just to Java's GC.
- mjevans 8y agoThat's still pretty much the case today. Though the underlying java GL library the desktop client uses has been updated a bit and the newer versions have migrated to higher versions of OpenGL; breaking a lot of mods pretty hard with the changes to the rendering engine. I hear the (Windows/console only?) version is faster for all the reasons you'd expect, but I'll probably end up never playing it.
- jandrese 8y agoWindows version has way better performance, but it doesn't support mods so nobody cares about it.
- hyperpallium 8y agoWas the "Windows version" the one released 1-2 years ago that looks really pretty, with god rays etc? I wondered if it would be a hit, since 8 bit graphics is part of the charm and concept of minecraft, but I didn't consider the mod ecosystem.
- jandrese 8y agoYeah, the one based on the mobile version.
- Dylan16807 8y agoMinecraft has made some very, uh, interesting performance decisions. For example they decided to forcibly split everything into server thread(s) and play thread(s), even when you're doing single player. This made things more consistent, and sometimes helped performance, even though it broke a huge amount of mods. While making this clean break it would have been easy to put world generation into its own thread, or even let it use multiple threads. Minecraft's world generation is inherently very parallel, and it bogs down servers all the time. Responsiveness could be improved by a huge amount by cutting it out of the simulation loop. They didn't.
- philwelch 8y agoEven when I'm playing Kerbal Space Program, there's a marked difference between just being able to play KSP and being able to play KSP while having reference materials open on another screen (the KSP wiki has a great delta-V map of the Kerbol system, for example). Long before my computer is old enough that games like KSP become unusably slow, it gets old enough that the only way I can run games like KSP is to close my browser and free up all of my resources.