4 ms·
"Imagine the exotic "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand
by jerf 8y ago
"Imagine the exotic "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand (or care about) the long-term consequences of that tinkering"
That's fun science fiction, as others have pointed out, but in terms of real science, at the moment that's just a sort of subtle way of anthropomorphizing the universe and projecting human experience far, far beyond where it is applicable. Einstein's equations for spacetime evolution don't have anything that looks like "pollution" in them. There's no "stress term" for "space time that has been put through the wringer and is broken now". Black holes do not seem to leave "broken space" behind them or anything like that; indeed, "leaving broken space 'behind' them" would be an incredibly ill-defined term. In what preferred reference frame does your "pollution" take place in?
The only real concern is if there is some way to violate the conservation of energy, as real space does seem to do that at large scales at the moment. In that case someone might explode something, potentially large enough to make a mess of a galaxy or more. But we don't have even a hypothetical example of how to do that; just because the universe is violating energy conservation does not mean there's any conceivable organization of energy we can create that will do it, if the reason conservation is being violated is the injection of energy from some other effect or something.
- Razengan 8y agoI just imagine that once you do work at such scales, and with such strange materials and results, then the "waste products" of that work would be just as weird. Also, would black holes not be considered "broken space" themselves?
- jerf 8y ago"Also, would black holes not be considered "broken space" themselves?" Even that is really an anthropomorphization. They don't "spread". They don't "damage" the space around them. They don't leave behind anything as they pass through space. They aren't having the effects that people imagine when they think about "pollution".
- throwaway76543 8y ago"In what preferred reference frame does your "pollution" take place in?" Pollution would be any undesirable side effect and there are plenty to be imagined in these scenarios. Your comment strikes me a bit like a chemist denying environmental pollution as it's all "just chemicals."
- mikec3010 8y agoPollution is undesirable on earth because it causes us harm from which we can't escaoe or reverse. The idea of "polluting" spacetime makes no more sense than humans "polluting" the natural organization of air molecules by displacing them by existing, or polluting the natural distribution of entropy by making decisions. It's just bringing politics into a place where it doesn't belong.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 8y agoPutting "pollution" in quotes was to substitute it for "waste", or byproducts, or side effects, that may or may not be undesirable for some species somewhere and somewhen.
- klank 8y agoPollution, by definition, is something that causes harm: "the presence in or introduction into the environment of a substance or thing that has harmful or poisonous effects." I have no idea why you have this idea that polluting is some politicized term.
- mikec3010 8y agoPollution is intimately tied to politics because most inhabited property is owned, which means it's regulated by some governmental systems having varying degrees of regulation and penalties for pollution. I have no idea why that has to be explained to you.
- repolfx 8y agoBy violating conservation of energy are you referring to dark matter?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IForgotUsername 8y agoHe could just be referring to the existence of matter at all to be fair. Violations of thermodynamics are required for anything to exist at all.
- antidesitter 8y agoDark energy. Generally speaking, energy is not conserved in general relativity: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2010/02/22/energy-is-not-conserved/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2010/02/22/energy-i....
- marcosdumay 8y agoAccording to General Relativity, energy on our Universe isn't conserved.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- empath75 8y agoThere’s no ‘nuclear holocaust’ term in the equations for atomic physics, but nonetheless it is an undesirable consequence of screwing around with nuclear weapons.