9 ms·
> If we could ever produce such matter then we could start some spacetime engineering. Imagine the exotic "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advance
by Razengan 8y ago
> If we could ever produce such matter then we could start some spacetime engineering.
Imagine the exotic "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand (or care about) the long-term consequences of that tinkering.
Destabilizing solar systems or even entire galaxies, maybe even violating causality..
Imagine the home (and only) planets of younger, insignificant civilizations being caught up in those cataclysms, all traces of their existence wiped from cosmic history in what might amount to the equivalent of a traffic accident or "oil spill" of a greater civilization.
..maybe that has already happened and some of the leviathanic voids we've observed were a result of that? :)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_(astronomy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_(astronomy)
- SiempreViernes 8y agoWell, there was that time Earth was demolished to make room for a bypass. I'm not sure I recall all the details but I think the universe ended as a convoluted consequence?
- Razengan 8y agoYep, that is exactly what I was thinking about. :)
- golergka 8y agoThat sounds like some great sci fi, actually.
- Razengan 8y agoEver since I played the awesome old RPG called Planet's Edge [0] and the better-known Star Control II, I've been taken to muse about cosmic coincidences. Popular sci-fi like Star Wars or Star Trek etc. don't really touch on those possibilities in a convincing way. As in, very few fiction truly conveys the ..indifference.. of the universe, and all the actors in it going about their own businesses and interacting only incidentally, even if to monumental consequences to each other, but without a lot of conscious intent or an overarching plan. Kind of like how most of Earth's history has played out, even if it may all seem interconnected and purposeful due to the much more relatable scales involved. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet%27s_Edge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planet%27s_Edge
- DennisP 8y ago> indifference.. of the universe, and all the actors in it going about their own businesses and interacting only incidentally That was pretty much the point of Rendezvous with Rama, until the sequels ruined it.
- ben_w 8y agoMy brother has (I think jokingly) suggested that the dark energy expansion of the universe is an indication of such pollution.
- ainar-g 8y agoThis is very similar to Strugatsky Brothers' Roadside Picnic[1], a book which inspired, among other things, Andrey Tarkovskiy's film Stalker and the S.T.A.L.K.E.R. video game franchise. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadside_Picnic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadside_Picnic.
- dmix 8y agoThanks for the recommendation, I adore the Stalker film.
- yoodenvranx 8y ago> Imagine the "pollution" caused by civilizations [...] Destabilizing solar systems or even entire galaxies, maybe even violating causality.. If you are interested in such a plotline you should read the "The Three-Body Problem" triology by Liu Cixin. Without going to much into detail: This topic pops up several times in the third (and perhaps already in the second) book of the series.
- krapp 8y ago>Imagine the "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand (or care about) the long-term consequences of that tinkering. I once had, and never used, an idea that the consequence of using such technology was to accelerate dark energy, so that the more civilizations used FTL travel, the greater the energy requirements became. As if seafarers had to deal with the oceans expanding just a bit every time they were crossed.
- Razengan 8y ago> so that the more civilizations used FTL travel, the greater the energy requirements became. That sounds like a recipe for some terrible monopolization by the first few civilizations that manage to achieve FTL: Those who are the earliest to expand into the universe, would have access to the most resources, so they would be the only ones left who can afford to use FTL anymore, while younger civilizations may never have a chance to get out of their home stars.
- krapp 8y ago>That sounds like a recipe for some terrible monopolization by the first few civilizations that manage to achieve FTL: Yeah, that's where the "evil empire/East India Trading Company but in Spaaaaace" was going to come from. I wanted to use hyperspace/FTL as a vague metaphor for a scarce but crucial resource like fossil fuels (or whale oil, back in the day.)
- Razengan 8y ago> "evil empire/East India Trading Company but in Spaaaaace" I think it would be much more sinister. The FTL controllers would be seen as gods by species who have yet to leave their homeworld. Every civilization within their sphere of influence would be either have to be their allies, thralls, unable to move around in the galaxy unless they get piggyback rides by the FTL barons, or engulfed and extinguished by them. Imagine if we in the real world found out that there was no way to explore the universe we've been observing for centuries, unless we allied with some alien species that does not, can not, have our best interests on their minds. Interstellar travel would require resources, and resources would require interstellar travel.. To go against the FTL species you would need to control at least as many planets as they do, and to control that many planets you would need FTL travel.. Sounds like a monumentally hopeless reality.
- jimmytidey 8y agoIf someone violates causality, who should be held responsible?
- klank 8y agoYou.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThere’s some Star Trek episodes that touch on this, maybe in later TNG or DS9. Can’t recall exactly at present. Edit: here we go: http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Speed_limit http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Speed_limit
- rainbowmverse 8y agoPreventing this damage without a speed limit was the function of Voyager's moving warp nacelles. I think they solved it without moving parts in later designs.
- stephengillie 8y agoThe Defiant class's warp nacelles are angled slightly toward the bow of the ship, at least in some parts of the canon. Some speculate this is for the same reason - a fixed-nacelle design that prevents this damage without a speed limit. Tangential - comparison of warp coils in different Starfleet ships: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXAoIGTQEBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXAoIGTQEBY
- 3rdAccount 8y agoI missed your comment and made a similar comment without the attached episode. Thank you and the below comment on how they solved it. I assumed they just didn't care as it was the delta quadrant and the whole show is an emergency.
- al2o3cr 8y agoOne estimate of the total exotic matter required to form a bubble puts it around 10^20 galaxies worth. https://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9702026.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9702026.pdf Those insignificant civilizations don't need to worry about pollution, they need to worry about being gobbled up for mass-energy.
- antidesitter 8y agoAccording to Wikipedia: “In 2012, physicist Harold White and collaborators announced that modifying the geometry of exotic matter could reduce the mass–energy requirements for a macroscopic space ship from the equivalent of the planet Jupiter to that of the Voyager 1 spacecraft (~700 kg) or less, and stated their intent to perform small-scale experiments in constructing warp fields. White proposed changing the shape of the warp bubble from a sphere to a torus. Furthermore, if the intensity of the space warp can be oscillated over time, the energy required is reduced even more.”
- jerf 8y ago"Imagine the exotic "pollution" caused by civilizations which are advanced enough to tinker with the fabric of spacetime, but not advanced enough to understand (or care about) the long-term consequences of that tinkering" That's fun science fiction, as others have pointed out, but in terms of real science, at the moment that's just a sort of subtle way of anthropomorphizing the universe and projecting human experience far, far beyond where it is applicable. Einstein's equations for spacetime evolution don't have anything that looks like "pollution" in them. There's no "stress term" for "space time that has been put through the wringer and is broken now". Black holes do not seem to leave "broken space" behind them or anything like that; indeed, "leaving broken space 'behind' them" would be an incredibly ill-defined term. In what preferred reference frame does your "pollution" take place in? The only real concern is if there is some way to violate the conservation of energy, as real space does seem to do that at large scales at the moment. In that case someone might explode something, potentially large enough to make a mess of a galaxy or more. But we don't have even a hypothetical example of how to do that; just because the universe is violating energy conservation does not mean there's any conceivable organization of energy we can create that will do it, if the reason conservation is being violated is the injection of energy from some other effect or something.
- Razengan 8y agoI just imagine that once you do work at such scales, and with such strange materials and results, then the "waste products" of that work would be just as weird. Also, would black holes not be considered "broken space" themselves?
- jerf 8y ago"Also, would black holes not be considered "broken space" themselves?" Even that is really an anthropomorphization. They don't "spread". They don't "damage" the space around them. They don't leave behind anything as they pass through space. They aren't having the effects that people imagine when they think about "pollution".
- throwaway76543 8y ago"In what preferred reference frame does your "pollution" take place in?" Pollution would be any undesirable side effect and there are plenty to be imagined in these scenarios. Your comment strikes me a bit like a chemist denying environmental pollution as it's all "just chemicals."
- 3rdAccount 8y agoOf course, there is a Star Trek episode (TNG) where some alien scientists discover this, but nobody wants to believe them including the Enterprise as the consequence is greatly restricted warp drive (warp 9 becomes only emergency). I think they mention it again once or twice. Maybe a super fan can attach the episode #.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- drewrv 8y agoSeason 7 episode 9 (Force of Nature). I believe in Voyager they mentioned something about a new warp engine design that mitigated the problem.
- egypturnash 8y agoTake it up a level: maybe the entire universe is the result of this. The Big Bang was the result of flushing another universe’s waste processes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- FroshKiller 8y agoIf you can engineer spacetime, there really isn't such a thing as a long-term consequence anymore.
- Razengan 8y agoNot even to those who can't engineer spacetime yet?
- ballenf 8y agoSo the ant in the universe where shoes have just been invented and people stop hesitating to step on them? The scale between ant and human is large, but probably still smaller than the ratio power-wise between the civilizations with and without exotic matter. Might as well just call one gods and the other mortals.
- FroshKiller 8y agoThat's right. The engineers have eternity to achieve outcomes satisfying to all parties. And if they choose not to, well, that's an all-time consequence, not a long-term one.
- swayvil 8y agoI recall a bit of scifi, the title escapes me, where they placed an opaque cloud between our galaxy and Andromeda, to block any form of communication, so they could have FTL without violating causality.
- klank 8y agoWhat you describe is a teeny-tiny bit of a a spoiler. Erring on the side of cation, obfuscating my reply. The book you're talking about was by Alastair Reynolds. It's the third book in the "Other" section here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alastair_Reynolds#Novels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alastair_Reynolds#Novels.
- knight-of-lambd 8y agoIn Accelerando, there was a similar plot device. The anisotropies in the CMB (or maybe just minor aberrations) were caused by waste heat from Type IV/V civilizations running gigantic computations (trying to probe/find vulns in the laws of physics, if I remember correctly). I thought that was a cool idea: that something as studied, ubiquitous and generally accepted as a natural phenomenon as the CMB is just a landfill, we just don't know what we're looking at.
- oppositelock 8y agoHa! Star Trek: TNG actually had an episode about that. [0] http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Force_of_Nature_%28episode%29 http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Force_of_Nature_%28episod...
- sgt101 8y agoDespite the sword and sorcery veneer this is actually the premise of several of CJ Cherryh's works, for example : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile's_Gate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exile's_Gate
- AgentME 8y agoThere's a plot point in one of the sequels to The Three Body Problem like this. Certain spacetime-warping propulsion technologies turn out to leave behind a large mark in spacetime which isn't directly harmful, but is easily detectable even at stellar distances. Because of the Dark Forest theory, such a mark is taken as a giveaway of a careless and technologically dangerous civilization, which causes other advanced civilizations to immediately try to kill the civilization that made the mark before it can advance further or launch its own attacks.