3 ms·
Both Wenzhou and Shenzhen had 20 year leases, and I think only SZ or Shantou had 15 year ones. These days, I think, only far inland cities still do 20 year leas
by baybal2 8y ago
Both Wenzhou and Shenzhen had 20 year leases, and I think only SZ or Shantou had 15 year ones. These days, I think, only far inland cities still do 20 year leases, and BJ experimenting with shorter term 3 to 5 year ones.
I found these:
>Most of this happened before the property boom began at a national level. So it is those cities that set the early pace in residential property development that have been first to encounter the issue. Wenzhou is one of them. Shenzhen, China’s oldest special economic zone, is another. A few property owners there started experiencing problems about 15 years ago. In that case most were given an option to renew their expired titles by paying 35% of a ‘baseline land value’, calculated on a historic rate far lower than the prevailing market price, Guangzhou Daily has reported.
>https://www.weekinchina.com/2016/04/a-nation-of-homeowners/ https://www.weekinchina.com/2016/04/a-nation-of-homeowners/
I the end, Wenzhou's leaseholders got free extension, but most likely just to shut them up. The govt did not yield to demands on relinquishing the right to set lease extension conditions. More on that in Chinese "ministry of land and resources decision, 23rd december"
I myself think that government's blessing on short term leases, (edit) plus hefty property tax on regular real estate seem to be the most logical way out of China's housing bubble.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoMy understanding was that WZ leaseholders got a free pass because their case was high profile during the property boom: if they were going to be charged market rates for extending the lease, then people would begin to doubt that their 70 year leases would eventually be turned over easily as well. The government wants everyone to think that the leases are just like buying. I think China will abandon the entire leasing system once they get a national property tax in place. The current system is unsustainable at the local level, and localities need the continuous income a property tax can provide, rather than the windfall of leases every 70 years (if that).
- baybal2 8y ago>WZ leaseholders got a free pass because their case was high profile during the property boom Yes, pretty much it. Shenzhen been very happy reselling land from all those short term leases under the new sky high prices for at least a decade. Excerpt: "land user could apply for an extension without usage change if they pay a renewal fee based on the benchmark land price – the initial auction price on the land set by the local government" Interesting fact FIY: the 2007 property law was the most debated act ever in Chinese legislature, with it failing to pass a number of times. While Chinese legislators are handpicked yes men, they also are quite wealthy people in their majority. Understandably, art. 149 was not on the govt's draft, but was added under the unprecedented extreme pressure from the assembly members. Will the govt resort to the "nuclear option?" The temptation to solve the money problem in one swoop is just too high. My coworker was evicted 2 month ago by his landlord in Shenzhen when the landlord suddenly learned that his land lease has expired when the police came to hand him a note without any prior warning.