3 ms·
> you'll end up with a product only the fringe wants to use. Is that a problem? I mean, my first thought when I hear this is, "yeah, broad adoption is totally
by danShumway 8y ago
> you'll end up with a product only the fringe wants to use.
Is that a problem? I mean, my first thought when I hear this is, "yeah, broad adoption is totally necessary." But, then I think about it more.
- Is it a problem for indie developers to build games that appeal to niche audiences?
- Is it a problem for software developers to build CLI tools or advanced software that solves very specific problems at the expense of user friendliness?
- Is it a problem for communities to be built around specific problems and for them to adopt very specific, focused codes of conduct or moderation?
Maybe it's OK to have a bunch of small, separate decentralized networks instead of one big decentralized one? With something like Facebook, sure, the point is to have everyone in one place. But one of the big points of systems like Mastodon is that small communities are better than big ones. Small communities are easier to moderate, more flexible to adapt to novel situations, and faster to pivot when things go wrong. Having niche adoption in that scenario could be kind of a feature, in the same way that having niche adoption for a game probably means you're getting something more focused and custom tailored to the people who want it.
It might be that not every social network needs to appeal to the overwhelming public at large. It mind end up being completely acceptable to have a social network that's very specific to one or two communities.
In that scenario, the death of Facebook might not be, "here's a replacement, everyone get off." It might be death from a thousand cuts; "here's a dozen replacements, there's probably at least one you like more."
- joe_the_user 8y agoUnless Facebook is replaced by one other thing, network effect will keep people on Facebook as well as one whatever else might suit a culture they're in. Edit: that said, there's no reason that an obscure subculture adopting a different social networking technology couldn't lead to that tech becoming universal. Facebook rose through a certain high-prestige subculture adopting it but with the Internet tending to creating different association patterns, high-prestige/"early adopter" may not, in fact, be the leaders of adoption in the future.
- danShumway 8y agoWell, but that's the thing. Do you have only one network, and does everyone belong to the same network? I was on Facebook for the network effect - then I got into indie game development, and all of the other game developers and gaming press are on Twitter. So I dropped off of Facebook and moved to Twitter. I still pull up Facebook occasionally to cross-post something to friends, but it's a different tool for a different purpose. In theory, nobody wants to join multiple social networks. In practice, I don't see people actually all that worked up about logging into multiple sites. My siblings jumped to Snapchat with no problem even when they were still using Facebook. When I started moving away from Facebook I told them to start emailing me - also wasn't a problem, they handled it fine. I run a small Discord server specifically for people who want to talk to me about the stuff I build. It's a really tiny community, but it's still a useful enough tool that I'll probably never build a Facebook page for anything I release. So those are maybe 3 or 4 tools that have successfully migrated communities off of Facebook. There are maybe 1 or 2 communities left that I have to take care of, and then I could just flat out delete my account. Certainly I'm only checking Facebook maybe 2 or 3 times a week now because of a few stubborn holdouts I haven't convinced to move off yet. Network effect is definitely a thing - but it's probably not all or nothing. It might be fine to replace Facebook for only for one or two communities. It might be fine to say, "Okay, all of my college friends are on X, but all of my professional contacts are on Y, and my hobby model train community is on Z." And multiple small, federated social networks are likely to be better at serving small communities than something like Twitter or Facebook is. How necessary is it to you that there be one service that you use to contact literally everyone? I was on the side of "pretty necessary," but the more that I think about it, the more I realize that distributing my contacts across multiple services is not actually all that much of a problem for me. In fact, it's often quite helpful, since it allows me to tailor content more.
- joe_the_user 8y ago"I was on Facebook for the network effect - then I got into indie game development, and all of the other game developers and gaming press are on Twitter." Sure, if one has one reason to be on a network, getting off it is fairly easy. But if one has IRL professional-collegues, friends, family, and multiple special interests with friends, then it's hard for all those to switch. "How necessary is it to you that there be one service that you use to contact literally everyone?" Well, you want to be able to be-contacted-by a variety of people. Facebook can wind-up indeed just one of several of the networks the average person is on but that doesn't it won't remain the largest and quite possibly not much smaller than today.